A battle over the figure to be used to set taxable value in 2022 Allegheny County property assessment hearings landed in a state appellate court Wednesday, with the outcome of more than 5,000 appeals hanging in the balance.

During arguments in Commonwealth Court, Robert Max Junker, an attorney for the Pittsburgh Public Schools, argued that Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg overstepped his authority in setting the common level ratio for those hearings at 63.53%.

The ratio is used in appeal hearings to set the taxable value of a property, or the assessment, after the fair market value has been determined.

In his argument, Mr. Junker maintained that only the state tax equalization board, or STEB, has the authority to set the common level ratio, as it is typically the one that makes the calculation.

Advertise with us

He urged the court to overturn Judge Hertzberg’s ruling and to return the common level ratio to 81.1% — the level that had been set for use in 2022 appeals before Judge Hertzberg intervened last September.

“We have three reasons in the sense why this relief should be granted, and they can be summarized very basically as couldn’t, shouldn’t, and did it wrong,” he said.

The stakes in the court battle couldn’t be higher.

If the appellate court agrees with the district and orders 81.1% to be used, a house valued at $200,000 on appeal would be taxed at $162,200. But if it upholds the 63.53% ordered by Judge Hertzberg, that same property would be taxed at $127,060.

Whatever way the court goes, its decision will affect thousands of taxpayers.

Advertise with us

The county’s board of property assessment appeals and review has yet to finalize more than 1,000 appeals from last year as it awaits a court decision on which common level ratio to use.

In addition, thousands of taxpayers have taken advantage of the “special appeals period” offered by County Council and Executive Rich Fitzgerald earlier this year to challenge their 2022 property assessments because of the controversy over the common level ratio.

As of Wednesday, 6,365 such appeals have been filed, with the vast majority — 4,896 — filed by property owners looking to lower their assessments. School districts filed another 1,468, likely in a bid to raise the assessment.

Nonetheless, in his argument, Mr. Junker contended that Judge Hertzberg did not have the expertise to set the 63.53%.

“He should not have been a gatekeeper. He should not have been going through this process over the last summer to scrub these numbers because he was doing it wrong, because this was not his area of expertise,” he said.

Advertise with us

But John Silvestri, the attorney for the taxpayers who sued to lower the common level ratio, maintained that Judge Hertzberg did not exceed his authority.

He said that it was the county that had revised the way it coded sales data used in calculating the common level ratio. In April, the county acknowledged in consent order that the data sent to STEB “was wrong,” he told judges Wednesday.

“The county agreed to do, in voter parlance, a recount,” he said.

He further explained that the 63.53% was calculated by an expert for the plaintiffs using the revised sales data. But during the September hearing in which Judge Hertzberg set the ratio, the county did not say the calculation was out of hand, Mr. Silvestri asserted.

“You’re saying that the trial court did not come up with this number on its own. It relied on what was submitted to it?” asked Judge Anne E. Covey.

Advertise with us

“Absolutely 100 percent,” Mr. Silvestri replied.

He also maintained that when he objected to the state tax equalization board in a separate case about the way the county was coding 2021 sales, he was told that STEB doesn’t review such data, that it is a matter for the courts.

“I think at this point in time that is binding on this case,” he said.

But in rebuttal, Mr. Junker countered that what’s at issue in this case is not the coding but a simple calculation by STEB of the common level ratio using the data given to it.

“This is a routine process of transmitting data that is readily available, that is public records, that is information,” he said.

Advertise with us

He urged the court to keep the 81.1% for 2022 appeals and to use the 63.6% calculated last year by STEB for 2023 sales.

“There has to be some guide rails here. This can’t stretch on for years. It has to be addressed at the STEB level ... or else the tenuous nature that the base year system is holding by a thread is just completely gone,” Mr. Junker said.

Complicating matters is that Judge Hertzberg last month ordered the assessment board to use the 63.6% ratio in deciding 2022 appeals. He did so in a bid to get the appeals still pending from last year resolved.

If Commonwealth Court upholds the 63.53% the judge mandated in September, it means there will be conflicting orders before the assessment board as to what number to use.

In addition to the 6,365 so-called second chance appeals that have been filed for 2022, another 11,009 appeals have been submitted for 2023. There were another 4,465 appeals for both years. The deadline for all appeals was March 31.

Advertise with us

The numbers are still subject to change as the county reviews the filings for duplicates or if it receives additional mailed appeals postmarked by March 31.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com