A state appellate court is speeding up its review of litigation that could help determine the outcome of thousands of Allegheny County property assessment appeals dating from last year.
Commonwealth Court will hear arguments in April on what number is to be used to set the taxable values of properties in hearings before the county’s board of property assessment appeals and review.
In September, county Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg set that number, known as the common level ratio, at 63.53% — a significant drop from the 81.1% that was being used in the hearings.
At the 81.1% ratio, a house valued at $200,000 on appeal would be taxed at $162,200. But if the 63.53% ratio is used, it would be taxed at $127,060.
The Pittsburgh Public Schools appealed the September ruling to Commonwealth Court later that month, where it has remained with little movement since then.
Earlier this month, the county assessment board filed a motion with the court asking for an expedited review of the school district’s appeal in an effort to move the case along.
Read More
Last week, the court agreed to do so — ordering briefs to be filed by the end of February and for the case to be scheduled for oral argument in Harrisburg in April.
“It’s a good result for the county at large, meaning the people,” said David Montgomery, assessment board solicitor.
While he refused to predict how long it will take for the court to rule after the hearing, he is hoping it does so quickly.
“I’m hoping this matter will receive priority attention. This court is busy with a lot of issues, including election law, which I know takes up a lot of their time,” he said.
In his motion seeking the expedited review, Mr. Montgomery estimated the issue affected nearly 10,000 appeals currently pending before the assessment board.
While board members are hearing appeals and determining market value, they have stopped short of applying the common level ratio — the final step in setting the assessment at which a property will be taxed.
As a result, those property owners still have no idea how much they will be paying in taxes.
On Monday, Mr. Montgomery lowered his estimate on how many appeals could be affected, saying it now could be less than 9,000, given cases where there was no change in the market value.
In those situations, the same common level ratio in place at the time of the appeal would be used.
The expedited review comes just as County Council is expected to vote Tuesday on a bill that would give property owners a second chance to appeal their 2022 assessments.
The legislation would give those taxpayers until March 31 to file those challenges, which is the same deadline for filing 2023 appeals.
It also requires the assessment board to apply whatever common level ratio is established by court order for 2022 appeals, whether it’s 63.53% or another number.
In addition, if the 63.53% ratio to be used in 2023 appeal hearings ends up being adjusted by court order, property owners then would have 60 days from the date of that mandate to file appeals.
County Council President Patrick Catena, one of the bill’s sponsors, said he is expecting it to pass Tuesday.
“It’s the right thing to do for residents of Allegheny County,” he said. “Obviously, we want to make everyone whole or give them an attempt to try to make them whole.”
While the legislation, if signed by Executive Rich Fitzgerald, could trigger an onslaught of appeals, Mr. Montgomery said he had no problem with it, although he added he couldn’t speak for board members.
“This will give people a chance to appeal who otherwise would have appealed on a timely basis had they known the common level ratio was going to be reduced,” he said.
If upheld, the change in the ratio ordered by Judge Hertzberg would make a big difference in how much a property owner pays in taxes.
On the other hand, the lower ratio could cut into the revenue anticipated by school districts and municipalities through assessment appeals last year, prompting fears about “crippling” refunds and possible tax hikes.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.