The president of Allegheny County Council is up in arms over a decision to deny a group of taxpayers a second chance to appeal their 2022 property assessments.
In a statement Thursday, Patrick Catena, D-Carnegie, described the denial as an “injustice” and said he planned to discuss “potential legislative remedies” next week.
Mr. Catena reacted following a story by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette earlier this week detailing the plight of more than a dozen taxpayers who haven’t been able to get hearings on so-called “second chance” 2022 appeals.
The assessment board refused to grant the hearings because the taxpayers had reached settlements before the county’s board of viewers on separate 2020 appeals that included the 2022 tax year.
In January, County Council approved legislation that gave property owners who had not appealed their 2022 assessments by that year’s March 31 deadline another chance to do so.
It took the action after Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg ordered a reduction in the common level ratio — a number used to calculate taxable value in appeals hearings — lowered from 81.1% to 63.53%.
Read More
Attorneys for the group of taxpayers who were denied hearings charged that the appeal board’s decision violated the state’s uniformity clause and the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
They said the settlements were reached before Judge Hertzberg ordered the change on the common level ratio. As a result, they should be able to appeal again, in accordance with the county ordinance, they argued.
In his statement, Mr. Catena said the second-chance appeals could end up costing the county millions of dollars.
“But that is no excuse for refusing to grant taxpayers who were overcharged an opportunity to seek justice through the appeals process, despite council’s legislative enactment of a special appeal window for precisely that purpose,” he said.
The assessment board, solicitor David Montgomery has said, “doesn’t have the authority to overrule judicial settlements” and thus could not grant hearings to the taxpayers involved. He maintained that they should go back to the judge who granted the settlement and ask for the cases to be reopened based on incorrect or false information.
He could not be reached for comment Thursday.
But in countering Mr. Montgomery’s argument, Jeffey Wilhelm, an attorney for one of the taxpayers, said the group “should not have to file civil action to make the county comply with its statutory obligations.”
Jonathan Kamin, attorney for more than 12 of the taxpayers, was grateful for Mr. Catena’s intervention.
“We appreciate his leadership and think that this is what was intended when the county reopened the appeals for people who had relied on the previously erroneous information,” he said.
Dusty Elias Kirk, another of the attorneys involved, likewise welcomed Mr. Catena’s involvement.
“I’m glad he’s considering taking this back to county council to take a look at it,” she said. “Without legislative action, we would have to spend time and money and our clients would have to pay for something that, in my opinion, shouldn’t have happened.”
In his statement, Mr. Catena said he plans to discuss possible legislative remedies during a meeting of council’s special committee on assessment practices next week.
He added that the court-ordered change in the ratio “almost certainly will increase everyone’s county taxes, reduce the funding available for services to county residents, or both.”
Judge Hertzberg ordered the change after a lawsuit claimed that the county had invalidated some valid property sales while validating others that should not have been in arriving at the ratio, resulting in an inflated number.
By applying the inflated ratio, the county collected more tax revenue than it should have, Mr. Catena said.
“Fixing that overcollection will reduce the county’s revenues, and that reduction is going to force us to make some very difficult decisions about levels of services and tax rates for our residents,” he asserted. “At best, this administration incompetently made a math error, and at worst, this administration intentionally overcharged taxpayers. Either way, remedying what the administration has done will cost the county millions of dollars.”
In his opinion, Judge Hertzberg stated that from the evidence he heard, “there could be no doubt that Allegheny County’s Office of Property Assessment had been ‘cooking the books’” on common level ratio data submitted to the state tax equalization board for calculation.
County communications director Amie Downs has described that as “absolutely a mischaracterization.”
"Mistakes were made by the Office of Property Assessment staff that have since been corrected," she said in November. "They were just that — mistakes."
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.