The Pennsylvania Superior Court did not overstep its bounds in ordering the reinstatement of Pittsburgh International Airport’s airmall operator after its eviction last year.

That’s the argument Fraport Pittsburgh is making in urging the court to reject the Allegheny County Airport Authority’s bid to get judges to reconsider their ruling last month reversing the ouster.

In a 24-page answer filed earlier this month, Fraport, which under one name or another has managed the airmall since its debut in 1992, stated that none of the arguments the authority made provided any reason — let alone a “compelling one,” a legal standard — to overturn the ruling.

On May 9, a three-judge Superior Court panel reversed a decision by Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Christine Ward denying Fraport’s request for a preliminary injunction to stay on the job after it was ousted by the authority last June.

Advertise with us

It returned the case to Judge Ward with instructions to issue the injunction — in essence, putting Fraport back to work.

The panel did so after concluding that the judge had erred in determining that the master lease governing the relationship between Fraport and the authority, which runs Pittsburgh International, was more a service contract than an actual lease.

To the contrary, it stated at the time, the agreement between the two sides “is what it says it is — a lease.”

But the authority, in asking the panel to reconsider its ruling or for a reargument before the full Superior Court, accused the three judges of a “cherry-picking of the language and provisions in the agreement that could evidence a traditional lease” while ignoring those that Judge Ward thought supported a services contract.

Although the authority argued that the panel should have deferred to the lower court’s interpretation, Fraport, in its answer, said there was no reason for the panel to do so, saying it owed Judge Ward “no deference on matters of law.”

Advertise with us

“The panel committed no error in failing to grant deference to the trial court’s erroneous interpretation. Accordingly, no basis for reargument or rehearing exists,” it stated.

Likewise, Fraport maintained that the panel didn’t err in finding that the airport authority violated the Landlord Tenant Act of 1951 and “self help” provisions in the lease in using county police to force its eviction.

The authority, in seeking reconsideration or reargument, claimed that the ruling ignored federal security obligations built into the lease and that it was “flat-out dangerous for the panel to second guess” its and Judge Ward’s assessment of what legal remedies were required in the case.

In terminating Fraport’s lease, the authority accused it of multiple security breaches, including the careless handling of knives and other prohibited items. But Fraport has rejected such claims, saying it took steps to resolve any issues raised by the authority.

It charged that the authority was looking for “find something, anything” to pin on it to terminate the lease.

Advertise with us

And while the authority, in asking for reconsideration or reargument, chastised the Superior Court panel for ignoring security aspects, Fraport stated in its answer that the agency never even raised that issue before the appellate judges before their ruling.

“At no point in [the authority’s] forty-seven pages of argument to the panel did ACAA assert that these federal regulations constituted a basis for affirmance of the trial court’s order,” it stated, adding that issues not developed in the argument section of an appellate brief are deemed to be waived.

In its answer, Fraport said a reargument or rehearing should be granted only when there are “compelling reasons” to do so. Among them is when a panel’s decision is inconsistent with a prior decision by the same court on the subject or when the panel has “overlooked or misapprehended a fact of record material to the outcome of the case” or a “controlling or directly relevant authority.”

But the authority, it contended, advanced none of those.

“Rather, ACAA seeks reargument because: It disagrees with the panel’s decision and review of the record ...; it contends the panel should defer to the trial court’s contractual interpretation despite the panel owing no deference to that determination ...; it believes the panel overlooked an argument that ACAA never made ...; and it argues that the panel considered an argument that Fraport Pittsburgh Inc. ... purportedly never made when, in fact, that argument was made before the trial court and the panel,” it stated.

Advertise with us

There is no timetable for a decision by the court on the request for reconsideration or reargument.

Since evicting Fraport, the authority has been overseeing the airport’s popular airmall, with its mix of restaurants and shops.

The authority, at one point, offered Fraport $5 million to buy out the remaining years of its lease, which expires in 2029, but the operator rejected it.

According to the Superior Court panel, after the rejection, the authority “interfered with Fraport’s property rights and effectively forced the result it wanted.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com