It has been six years since a Cleveland developer acquired a seven-story building on Smithfield Street in Downtown, with ambitious plans to convert it to office and retail space.
But since then, Stark Enterprises has done little to redevelop the structure, one that stretches the entire block between Forbes and Fifth avenues across from the former Kaufmann’s department store.
And some Downtown leaders are growing more and more frustrated over the situation — with one even suggesting that the city use eminent domain to take over the vacant property.
John Valentine, executive director of the Downtown Neighbors Alliance, said the building has become an eyesore. Graffiti pockmarks the boarded-up windows on the Forbes side. The Fifth side, Mr. Valentine said, “reeks of urine” with homeless people sleeping in the empty storefronts.
“I just think we’re being held hostage by a company that isn’t headquartered in Pittsburgh,” he said. “They’ve taken a whole block and done nothing with it. It has a ripple effect. It creates more blight. People use it for a bathroom. It hurts the businesses around it. It hurts the residents.”
Mr. Valentine isn’t the only one who has concerns about the building at 441 Smithfield.
Read More
Jeremey Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, said Stark should either get moving on rehabbing it or sell it.

“I think it’s a critical development site in Downtown Pittsburgh,” he said. “It’s something that we want to see redeveloped.”
Stark paid $10.4 million in 2017 to buy the building, which housed the former Frank & Seder department store from 1918 to 1954.
Months later, it pitched a plan for the Icon on Smithfield — a redevelopment that was to include 160,000 square feet of office space on the upper floors and two floors of retail.
In 2018, it got approval from the city Planning Commission to transform the property into three floors of offices, 25,000 square feet of retail and two floors of apartments, about 40 in all.
Since then, it seemingly has vacillated between rehabbing the building or selling it.
Three years after buying it, Stark put the property up for sale with an asking price of $22 million — more than double what it had paid for it in the purchase from the Oxford Development Company.
Nothing came of that effort. A year ago, it tried again to sell it, reportedly to a New York-based real estate firm. But that deal apparently fizzled out as well.
In between, it has recast its vision for the structure, at one time dropping the plan for offices and apartments in favor of 150 apartments on the upper floors and street-level retail in what has been rebranded as the Smith & Fifth redevelopment.
At one point, Stark announced that it was partnering with Launch Workplaces to bring a coworking concept to the building.
It also has been embroiled in a legal dispute with Davio’s, a Boston-based northern Italian steakhouse that was to take 9,730 square feet of space on the fifth Avenue side of the building.
According to the city’s AgencyCounter website, the developer has tried to do some work in the building in the past. Last year, it applied for a partial demolition permit, but as of Dec. 1 that application was deemed as incomplete.
In 2020, it got permission to remove and replace six antennas and associated equipment. In 2018, it applied to do interior and exterior renovations. It requested an amendment in February 2022, with the application deemed incomplete.
A February 2022 amendment to a 2017 application for interior demolition also has been labeled as incomplete.
Stark’s website currently advertises the Smith & Fifth project as “in development.”
“The historic renovation offers state-of-the-art retail, residential and office space in a location that provides unique access to the city’s business and social assets,” it stated. A brochure describes a “Mixed Use Super Block.”
A Stark spokeswoman did not return emails seeking comment.
Mr. Waldrup said he’s not aware of any current development plans for the building. Mr. Valentine said he has tried reaching out to the developer and “nobody calls me back.”
“Now it’s just sitting there doing nothing. They don’t return phone calls. You don’t even know what the plan is,” he said.
Mr. Valentine said he intends to talk to the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey about the possibility of using eminent domain to take over the building.
He acknowledged that he’s not sure what the law requires in terms of such taking. Nor, he said, is he typically a fan of such an approach. But, in this case, he maintained that it’s worth a shot.
“When I think this holds up development of a whole city and we are held hostage, I think this is a perfect solution to use eminent domain,” he said.
Maria Montano, a spokeswoman for the mayor, could not be reached for comment.
But Jonathan Kamin, a local real estate attorney, said eminent domain would be very hard to justify in such a situation. In order for a government takeover of a property, there has to be a public purpose involved, he noted.

“It’s hard for me to think that the city taking over that building by eminent domain would be a good use of tax dollars,” he said.
Mr. Waldrup said the PDP has used its own resources to do power washings and to clean up the area around the building. It also has placed planters with flowers on the sidewalk in front of it on Smithfield.
But he added that he is hoping Stark will do more to “address the public health issue” of people using doorways and storefronts as a “restroom facility.”
It could make such activity less inviting, he said, by covering up storefronts and gates.
The lack of redevelopment is even more disappointing given the turnaround of the Kaufmann’s building across the street, Mr. Valentine said.
Since Philadelphia-based Lubert Adler Partners took over that building in 2020, it has spent $40 million finishing the redevelopment, which includes apartments, a hotel and retail. Target and Five Below stores have opened at the location and Burlington is expected to follow later this year.
If the Stark building is redeveloped, “there’s a really good chance that we can turn part of Downtown that was bad into something great,” Mr. Valentine said.
At one time, Lubert Adler had considered investing $50 million in the 441 Smithfield building as part of a collaboration with Stark. But nothing ever came of that overture.
Mr. Valentine said he’s running out of patience waiting for something to happen.
“I think we’ve given them every benefit of the doubt but it’s been years and years. When does it end?” he asked.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.