A Cleveland developer once again appears to be revamping plans for the long-delayed overhaul of the former Frank & Seder department store on Smithfield Street in Downtown.
In its latest brochure, Stark Enterprises is pitching a redevelopment that includes 150 residential units on the upper floors of the seven-story building along with ground-floor retail space.
There are no references to traditional office space. Coworking space is listed as a building amenity, along with a gym and tenant storage areas.
That’s a far cry from what Stark was proposing five years ago when it purchased the old department store and former county human services hub at 441 Smithfield for $10.4 million.
At the time, the developer envisioned a renovation that included 160,000 square feet of office space on the five upper floors and 60,000 square feet of retail on floors one and two — but no residential.
About 18 months later, Stark was back with a modified plan. It featured about 40 apartments on the upper two floors, three floors of offices, and 25,000 square feet of retail, including dining and entertainment. It also planned to use the building’s two basements for parking.
Read More
The latest version does not mention any office floors. It touts “150 units on the upper floors.” According to the brochure, the residential will include a mix of one- and two-bedroom suites and studios.
Stark officials could not be reached for comment.
In August, Dean Adler, CEO and co-founder of Lubert Adler Partners, the owner of the former Kaufmann’s department store across the street from the Stark redevelopment, suggested that plans could be changing.
He said then that Stark was proposing up to 160 apartments on the upper floors and 25,000 to 30,000 square feet of retail at street level. He added that he did not know whether offices were still part of the mix.
At the time, Lubert Adler was in what Mr. Adler called “early discussions” with Stark about possibly partnering in the proposed rehab of the Frank & Seder building. The Philadelphia developer was considering a $50 million investment in the project, dubbed Smith & Fifth.
So far, nothing official has come of those discussions, and several real real estate sources indicated that a potential partnership appears to have fizzled out. Mr. Adler could not be reached for comment.
A shift to all residential on the upper floors might make sense for Stark given that the Downtown office market, plagued by high vacancy rates, has taken a beating because of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Last May, Steve Coven, Stark’s vice president of asset management, acknowledged during a Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership presentation, that the developer was monitoring the office and residential situation “to make sure that when we come to market, we are appropriately sized for the demand.”
The Stark redevelopment has been dogged by delays since the firm bought the building in 2017.
In 2020, the developer put the building up for sale, seeking $22 million — more than twice what it paid. But it has not sold the structure and is still actively marketing the proposed redevelopment.
According to the brochure, signed tenants include Launch Workplaces, a Maryland-based coworking company. Stark announced in October 2020 that it was partnering with the firm to bring a coworking concept to the building.
The other advertised signed tenant is Another Broken Egg Cafe, a Southern-inspired breakfast, brunch, and lunch restaurant that got its start in Old Mandeville, La., in 1996.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.