Froggy’s is proving to have more lives than a cat.

A city board once again has denied a developer’s bid to tear down the old night spot and two other Market Street buildings Downtown.

In a six-page ruling issued Monday, the board of appeals in the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections for the second time did not buy arguments by the Troiani Group that the structures had to come down in order to raze an adjacent building at 209 First Ave.

“While the board does not doubt the good faith of Troiani’s team, the evidence does not support their assertion that the circumstances here are so unique that they must take the extreme and unprecedented step of pre-emptively demolishing adjacent structures,” the board stated.

Advertise with us

The case ended up back before the appeals board following a state Commonwealth Court ruling earlier this month.

A three-judge panel vacated an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court ruling and a prior board of appeals decision that denied Troiani’s emergency appeal to tear down the decaying Market Street structures.

It concluded that the board appeals appeared to have disregarded “strong critical evidence” — a standard set in a previous court case — that Troiani had presented in favor of demolition.

In making its decision, the court remanded the case back to the board of appeals “to issue a new decision based on the existing record evidence consistent with this opinion.”

The board did so this week, but the outcome didn’t change.

Advertise with us

Troiani feared that demolishing the six-story First Avenue structure without first razing the Market Street buildings could trigger a catastrophic collapse of the Market Street ones depending on how parts of the First Avenue building fell.

However, the board of appeals argued that Troian’s own reports and testimony “make clear” that demolishing the Market Street properties first “may itself cause the same catastrophic collapse scenario they seek to prevent, which would thus endanger the adjacent right-of-way and the buildings across Market Street just the same.”

It concluded that the safety measures required by the Department of Permits, Licenses, and Inspections were sufficient to mitigate potential problems.

They involved the closing of Market Street and First Avenue, including sidewalks, until the First Avenue building was demolished to a level no higher than the adjacent structures and the boarding of windows and doors of properties on the side of Market opposite Froggy’s.

“Troiani asserts that these protection measures are infeasible, but the board does not find this assertion credible. Buildings have been demolished in challenging urban locations many times before without demolishing adjacent structures as a protective measure,” it stated.

Advertise with us

“The board concludes that the pre-emptive demolition of the Market Street buildings will not meaningfully impact the safety of the First Avenue building demolition.”

Clifford Levine, Troiani’s attorney, said the developer is evaluating its options in response to the latest ruling, including another possible appeal to Common Pleas Court.

“We’re disappointed in the ruling. We think the Commonwealth Court was clear in indicating that there should have been more appropriate consideration of the need to take down the three Market Street buildings,” he said.

“In the end, the board of appeals didn’t offer a better solution. They weren’t convinced that the Troiani plan was the only solution but they never came up with another plan.”

Michael Troiani, president of Troiani Group, called the board’s decision a “pretty stark act of defiance” given the Commonwealth Court ruling only a few weeks ago.

Advertise with us

“I’m really not surprised by anything at this point. The state [court] ordered the board to rehear the case. Instead, they just restated their opinion,” he said.

Mr. Troiani noted that at the same time the appeals board denied his bid to raze the Market Street buildings, the city has condemned them as unsafe and ordered corrective action, one possibility being demolition with planning commission approval.

However, the commission last year denied Troiani’s request to take down the buildings, a decision that is still under appeal before the Commonwealth Court.

Mr. Troiani maintained that the city’s refusal to allow him to demolish the building amounts to an illegal taking and is putting the public at risk.

The developer received permission from the board of appeals last year to take down the First Avenue structure after arguing that it was in danger of falling down.

Advertise with us

Troiani wants to remove it and the Market Street properties to clear the site for a proposed 30-story development that would feature 200,000 square feet of office space, 151 residences, 300 parking spaces, and two floors of retail.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.