A developer isn’t giving up its battle to demolish three Downtown buildings on Market Street, including the old Froggy’s restaurant, to clear the path for a new 30-story office and residential tower.

Troiani Group has filed an appeal in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court seeking to reverse a July decision by the city’s planning commission that rejected the demolition request.

In addition, Troiani — in a separate Common Pleas Court action — is contesting a ruling by the city board of appeals within the department of permits, licenses and inspections that also rebuffed its request to raze the buildings.

Troiani tried to get an emergency permit from the board less than two weeks after the planning commission acted, claiming that the Market Street structures had to be removed before it could tear down an adjacent six-story building at 209 First Ave. in danger of collapsing.

Advertise with us

The developer had received permission from the board of appeals earlier in the summer to raze the First Avenue structure.

In an interview Wednesday, Michael Troiani, president of Troiani Group, said he took his fight to the courts because of his concerns about the state of the buildings.

‘I’m afraid for the public safety. I am responsible for the title for the properties and they are a public safety risk. The planning commission ruled not on the professional opinions of multiple engineers, but on the idea of nostalgia,” he said.

In its appeals, Troiani is claiming that both the planning commission and the board of appeals abused their discretion in denying the demolition requests.

It accused the planning commission of “capriciously disregarding substantial evidence that established that the Market Street structures [were] not economically or physically viable.”

Advertise with us

In making its decision, commission members questioned Troiani’s contentions that the Market Street buildings were beyond repair and that it was financially infeasible to try to salvage them as part of the new office and residential tower.

Commission Chairwoman Christine Mondor also noted at the time that the buildings were part of the Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

But in its appeal, Troiani took issue with such sentiments.

While the three buildings at 100-102, 104 and 106-108 Market were identified as “contributing” structures to the historic district when it was expanded in 2013, they have not been nominated or designated as historic under city historic designation requirements, it noted.

Dating to the 1860s, the structures, vacant since the early 2000s, “have no architectural significance” and, because of interior changes and renovations made over the years, “little historic fabric remains to connect the structures to any historic association or use.”

Advertise with us

Troiani also maintained that it was able to demonstrate through expert reports and testimony that the structures posed a safety hazard, were in danger of collapsing and were no longer physically or economically viable.

However, during the July hearing, local preservationists testified that Troiani could build the kind of office and residential tower it wanted by incorporating the Market Street buildings into the design.

A study commissioned by the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation advanced about eight different options for either using all or parts of the structures as part of the broader development.

The foundation also stated that it had saved buildings on the other end of Market Street that were in far worse condition than those Troiani wanted to tear down.

Nonetheless, in its appeal, Troiani accused opponents of the demolitions of presenting “only speculative opinions” while failing to provide any expert evidence or testimony regarding the physical state of the buildings.

Advertise with us

It also maintained that the commission itself relied “on speculative evidence” in denying the demolition request.

In its other appeal, Troiani stated that it approached the city with an emergency demolition plan to raze the Market Street structures after two structural engineers and a demolition expert concluded that the only way to safely remove the First Avenue building was to take down the Market Street ones first.

Nonetheless, the board of appeals, after hearing from city officials and Troiani representatives, voted unanimously to deny the request.

Troiani claims in its appeal of that decision that the board disregarded the “substantial evidence” provided by its experts while failing to “identify any substantial evidence in support of its decision.”

It is asking the court to reverse the ruling and allow for the immediate demolition of the buildings.

Advertise with us

Tim McNulty, spokesman for Mayor Bill Peduto, declined comment on the Troiani appeals. Ms. Mondor could not be reached for comment.

Troiani wants to take down the structures to clear the site bordering Market, First and the Boulevard of the Allies for the new development, which would feature 200,000 square feet of office space, 151 residences, 300 parking spaces and two floors of retail.

In denying the demolitions, the planning commission left room for Troiani to return again with the same request as long as it was coupled with a formal project development plan for the site.

But Mr. Troiani maintained Wednesday that it’s impossible to create such a plan without knowing what the footprint for the development will be. “It’s an unreasonable and absurd ask,” he said.

The Market Street buildings at the center of the dispute include one at the corner that housed the old Froggy’s nightspot, a popular haunt for celebrities and locals before its closing in 2003.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.