As Sherman Hostetter Jr. talks to crowds at lightning speed, it's hard to imagine the man with the gavel once was an introvert, a teenager more interested in playing golf professionally than becoming an auctioneer.

But it was true, at least until circumstances after college and a heart-to-heart talk with his dad suggesting he “get a real job” brought him back into the family business decades ago.

(Click to read more)

The younger Hostetter, now 66, says it proved to be a good fit. "It gets in your blood."

For three generations and counting, Hostetter Auctioneers in Beaver Falls has brought together buyers and sellers in the Pittsburgh region and beyond. It's a colorful line of work increasingly conducted online, though at its heart, it’s still about communicating effectively, understanding the art of the sale and building trust, family members say.

Advertise with us

A Hostetter has held an auctioneer's gavel since 1955, the same year Gunsmoke debuted on TV, the federal minimum wage increased to $1 and a baseball team then called the Brooklyn Dodgers took the World Series over the New York Yankees.

The enterprise began with his father, Sherman Sr. and his wife, Doris. It continues through Sherman Jr., the company’s president and CEO, and his own children: Matt, 37, Kylee, 35, and Paige, 32.

The Hostetters handle roughly 150 auctions a year, including estate, real estate, and business liquidations. Even before the pandemic, consumer demand had shifted away from in-person bidding, so the company shifted to online auctions as needed almost 15 years ago, becoming one of the region’s first.

“Knock on wood, it’s one of the best things we ever did,” Matt Hostetter says.

Fundraisers are down in particular right now due to COVID-19. Sadly, business liquidations are rising as things like COVID-19 restrictions and worker shortages have forced some owners to turn off the lights.

Advertise with us

"Everything from machine shops, restaurants, gyms," Sherman Jr,. said. "Take a restaurant — if they can only do 20% or 30% of what they normally would do, if it’s all you can get in the door, how do you handle that?

An auctioneer’s rapid, repetitive chant,  “... I’m bid $50. Will you give $60? $60? ….$60 bidder? Will you give $60?...” is intended to fuel urgency among the crowd. It’s also a must if an auctioneer is to move, say, 180 cars, in an hour.

For those behind the mike, the challenge and reward is that "it's true capitalism," says Sherman Jr. How lucrative an event is on any given day depends on the merchandise itself, and getting the best, honest price possible.

Empathy is a must, too.

That’s because while some sellers are happy to get belongings off their hands, many others are watching strangers bid on cherished items long a part of their lives.

Advertise with us

"The way we've always approached it is that this is a service that people need," Mr. Hostetter said. “Typically, they're going through some transition of life. Could be they lost a job; they could be downsizing; there could be a death in the family, bankruptcy. Somebody is moving for a job. They're going from Pennsylvania to Florida, or whatever, retiring. We're helping them get through it."

Kylee, who is raising six children, is among few female auctioneers and on YouTube videos has been described as perhaps the fastest in the world.

Four years ago, she appeared on ABC's game show “To Tell the Truth" in a segment intended to separate a real auctioneer from imposters, and in doing so, fool celebrity guests.

Her auctioneer’s chant delivered unscripted on national TV did not disappoint.

Like her sibling, Matt, she picked up the skill in part from hearing her father, Sherman Jr., who made a daily habit of perfecting his chant when they were young.

Advertise with us

“He’d be walking around the house, or in the shower, getting ready for dinner," she said. “He’d always just be auctioning. It was kind of ingrained in us.”

If you’re wondering what the dinner table talk is like in a family of auctioneers, you’re hardly alone.

In fact, said Matt Hostetter, “Every time people find out they say, ‘Oh, you’re auctioneers. I’ll bet it’s crazy around the table.’ So we’re going to film a commercial that has all of us and all of our kids, my dad and all the generations.”

Even if their conversations are like those of any other family, “We’re going to pretend,” he said.

Like any experienced auctioneer, Kylee is trained to spot little-noticed signs in some crowds — a wink, or a raised pinkie from bidders subtly trying to keep competitors from detecting their interest and driving up the price.

Advertise with us

"If they are looking at me, they still want to bid,” she said. “If they turn their head away, they don’t want to bid any more.”

Often, businesses are spawned by a personal interest or passion. That is true of the 67-year-old Hostetter enterprise. A barber's chair and an Ohio farm that just happened to be up for sale played a role, too.

According to the company’s web site, Sherman Sr. was fascinated by auctions growing up in Ohio and attended them with his father, William. Years later, Sherman Sr. and his wife were operating a barber/beauty shop when a farmer stopped in for a haircut.

He told Sherman that he wanted to sell his farm, and a few days later, another man sitting in the same barber chair said he was interested in buying a farm. Sherman connected the two.

Not expecting anything, a few months later, Sherman received a check in the mail for $500, according to the website

Advertise with us

Sherman Sr. told Doris they should use the money to start an auction business, and by 1955, they were at it full time.

Some auctions call for a tuxedo. At others, a flannel shirt and jeans make more sense. On a recent Friday, Sherman Jr. chose a blue blazer and white turtleneck at a company Christmas party, where he mingled with relatives, friends and those who have been associated with the company, gathered around folding chairs inside the company’s modest headquarters on Big Beaver Boulevard.

Sherman Jr’s office is adorned with mementos and awards from four decades in auctioneering.

But there is also this: A plaque that reads, “A bad day golfing is better than a good day at work.” — a playful nod to his days just after graduating from Penn State University with a degree in insurance and real estate, supported by a golfing scholarship.

It’s right below another plaque celebrating a hole in one, one of six he logged, the earliest at age 11, as he golfed professionally for a while.

Advertise with us

Sherman Jr. said that with his career not progressing the way he had envisioned, his father suggested it was time to come home and get “a real job.” His son, Matt, expressed a similar hope that the company will enter a fourth generation. He said the family has preserved its good name.

“I have four small kids,” he said. “I’m hoping they pick up the torch and carry it.”’

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter @Bschackner