One in a series
It’s that time of year when many Americans cozy up for a heartwarming story about community banking.
Yes, you could watch “It's a Wonderful Life” again. But better would be to head to Centre Avenue and talk to Richard Witherspoon, the longtime CEO of the Hill District Federal Credit Union, which has helped community members build savings, pay bills, start businesses and get small loans for 51 years.

The credit union opened in 1970 and primarily serves people who live, work or worship in the Hill District, although anyone who joins an organization that gives economic assistance in the neighborhood can open an account.
It is one of a handful of Black-owned and operated financial institutions in Pennsylvania.
Mr. Witherspoon traces the credit union’s roots to the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr., when business districts in Black neighborhoods were burned during riots over racial injustice. Conventional financial institutions fled and didn’t return.
Read More
The credit union’s founder, Mary Walker, decided if no bank would agree to serve the neighborhood, the neighborhood would start its own.
“She went door to door in this community, asking residents for 25 cents to open up an account here in the credit union,” he said.
Some of those initial 25-cent depositors are still members.
“Account number 332 — she still comes in,” he said, without pausing or needing to look it up.
Now, the credit union includes about 3,600 members and has about $10 million in assets. Most members still learn about it by talking to family or neighbors. Grandchildren join on their grandmother’s recommendation.
“Our main focus and the cornerstone of our mission is to improve the financial health of the people who live in this community,” he said.
Mr. Witherspoon said as a member-owned nonprofit, the credit union is not market sensitive. Its interest and dividend rates aren’t influenced by the ups and downs of the larger economy.
“Our products are geared toward people that don't have much,” he said. “If you go into a bank, they will not write you a personal loan for less than $20,000 or $50,000. You can still get a personal loan here at a reasonable rate for $500 to get your car fixed to get back and forth to work.”
The credit union’s interest rate for a used car loan is 8%, which matches the current national average according to Experian. That rate applies to members with a credit score as low as 550, who normally would face interest rates twice as high.
“The fruit of that is a loyalty you can't buy,” he said. “We have not had to repossess a car in over five years.”
He said even bank auditors ask how the credit union manages to balance the institution’s viability with serving a financially vulnerable population. The median income of the credit union’s members is less than $20,000.
His first answer is, “by the grace of God.” His second one is community spirit.
“When people think that you care about their wellbeing, they go that extra mile to keep things going, especially when they know that their savings goes to the next guy. It's a cooperative effort. It feeds longevity. It feeds sustainability.”
Each member’s savings boosts opportunities for others: To get a car loan or take out a line of credit, members must have 10% of the financed amount in their account so the credit union has money to lend to other members.
“That gives them a sense of buying in, a sense of investing in the community,” he said.
Trouble and turnaround
The credit union’s viability wasn’t always so assured. In the 1990s, it nearly collapsed.
''I've had so many people talk to me about failure that I thought my middle name was failure,” Ms. Walker told the Post-Gazette in 1995 on the credit union’s 25th anniversary.
In 1992, the credit union had more out in loans than it had in savings, its delinquency rate was around 18% and federal regulators gave it a year to get things in order or be shut down.
That was also the year that Ms. Walker retired after more than two decades as manager and Mr. Witherspoon, who had joined the credit union as a teller in 1988, took the reins.
He and the board cut staff, put a temporary moratorium on issuing loans, solicited deposits from other financial institutions to shore up reserves and curbed delinquency.
“I worked here by myself for about a year and a half,” Mr. Witherspoon said. “I did everything. For a long period of time I was working seven days a week to keep it going.”
The credit union exited the corrective action program in four months. Mr. Witherspoon vowed to create a rainy day fund and, over years, built up reserves equal to 15% of total assets — well above the ratio required for federally insured credit unions.
“As long as I’m breathing, we won't get into that trouble again,” he said.
The credit union now has a staff of four, including Mr. Witherspoon’s daughter, Erica, the office manager, and two tellers. During the pandemic and the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement, it has had some of its strongest years ever. Its total assets have doubled since 2019. Last year, members opened 600 new accounts.
The credit union, which owns its building at 2021 Centre Ave. after buying it for $14,000 at a sheriff’s sale in 1989, is currently raising funds to put apartments upstairs and expand into the storefront next door.
It is also setting aside about $3 million in federal COVID relief funds in addition to $5 million of its capital with the aim of starting a mortgage program for the first time. Mr. Witherspoon said his goal, as with all of the credit union’s offerings, is to design a program that will give its members easier access to mortgages and at reasonable cost.
Homes and hubs
The credit union also counsels members how to build savings and improve their creditworthiness.
Trina Kyte-Simmons, 45, a credit union member since 1998, said she is a homeowner thanks to the Witherspoons. They guided her through the process of taking out a $1,500 secured loan and paying it back over a year to improve her credit score. They helped connect her with a real estate agent and a loan officer.
In 2019, she purchased her first home, a brick house in Carrick that she and her family have renovated to open up and modernize the kitchen and dining room.
In October, she got married at the house, using the steps as the aisle to walk down to join her new husband.
“I’m on cloud nine knowing that people in your neighborhood are rooting for you, helping you, motivating you and just love you,” she said. “That’s what Richard is to me, our community, the Hill District, anybody that’s a part of that credit union.”
Erica Witherspoon said denials are part of the business, but at the credit union they are not the end of the conversation.
“We don't like saying: no, period,” she said. “We say: no, comma.”
Once, they had to turn down a member looking for a $5,000 car loan because her credit was too poor to qualify. But they spent hours with her going through her credit report and helping her make plans to pay off each item. For two years, the member would visit regularly with payoff letters from collection agencies to show her progress.
When she was ready for the car loan, her credit score had improved by almost 200 points and Ms. Witherspoon encouraged her to start saving for a down payment for a house. She signed a mortgage in a year with payments that were half what she had been paying in rent.
“It’s the whole team that really provides that support system for our members, because they can do it. It’s just nobody ever told them that they could,” Ms. Witherspoon said.
Mr. Witherspoon, 67, has no plans to retire but he’s working to ensure the transition will be smooth when he does. Over the last several years, he said, he has recruited new board members in their 30s and 40s who are skilled and dedicated to putting in time to making sure the credit union thrives.
“A financial institution in a business district is like a hub of a wheel,” he said. Deposits spur new spokes.
Sometimes, the catalyst is an investment of thousands of dollars. Sometimes, it’s one quarter at a time.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.