Last in a series

Like many older cities, Pittsburgh is littered with the names of iconic, home-grown businesses that aren’t around anymore — Kaufmann’s, Joseph Horne Co., J&L Steel, National Record Mart, Duquesne Brewing Co., The Pittsburgh Press to name a few.

Across a range of industries, those businesses enjoyed outsized success for decades — only to eventually go bust or be bought out.

The boom-to-bust phenomenon isn’t unique to Pittsburgh. Among the companies on the Fortune 500 list in the mid-1950s, only about 12 percent are still in business. Other statistics indicate it’s been getting harder over the years to stay on top.

Advertise with us

The Survivors

A series examining Pittsburgh-area businesses that have beaten the odds and made it past the half-century mark.

First in a series: Most companies don’t last 50 years, but these Pittsburgh businesses have

Second in a series: Mt. Lebanon Office Furniture & Interiors started out repairing typewriters

Third in a series: After a frightening start, brothers found their feet and kept insurance company growing

Advertise with us

Fourth in a series: Brighton Heights butcher's sharp skills build an enduring neighborhood business

Fifth in a series: Real estate brokers Beynon & Co. have moved a lot of property over the decades

Sixth in a series: Close family ties, and a secret recipe, keep business going

Seventh in a series: Seven decades of success: Dorsey's Record Shop has evolved with the times

Eighth in a series: A high school dream turns into a family legacy at Bethel Bakery

Advertise with us

Ninth in a series: Rothman Awning weathers time, and a few changes, over 95 years

Tenth in a series: Cummings Candy & Coffee serving up sweet treats for more than 110 years

In the 1920s, companies on the S&P 500 could expect to remain in the index for 67 years. The average fell to 33 years by 1965 and to 20 years by 1990. In 2016, the average is projected to be just 14 years.

What typically goes wrong after so much success? James Craft, a business professor at the University of Pittsburgh, cites what research literature refers to as corporate gravity.

“We’re talking about a company that is a market leader, and a dominant force in the industry. It now becomes complacent and focused on what made it successful in the past,” he said.

Advertise with us

As a result, businesses end up being blindsided by rapid changes in the marketplace, including changes in technology, regulations, international competition and consumer tastes. Companies must react to those changes or face extinction, he said.

“Companies have to think about reinventing themselves from time to time. Just because they’ve been in business for many years doesn’t guarantee future success,” said Stephen Gurgovits, managing partner at Tecum Capital, a private equity fund in Pine that invests in mid-sized companies.

He advises managers to conduct strategic planning sessions at least once a year to better understand the competitive and economic threats to their businesses.

“Sometimes people are too busy putting out fires of the day-to-day challenges and forget to look at the big picture,” Mr. Gurgovits said.

Investments in technology often can help companies stay ahead of competitors, he said.

Advertise with us

He cited an example of a home health care company he worked with that devoted significant resources to building a priority software package that allowed it to more efficiently track nurses and patient visits. The software also allowed the company to better track reimbursements from private insurance and Medicare.

“That allowed them to run their business more efficiently and made them overall a better business,” Mr. Gurgovits said.

Companies often fail because they stop reinvesting to keep the business up to date, he said.

Mr. Craft said the most successful companies pay close attention to their customers’ needs. For example, the consumer electronics chain Best Buy uses teams of workers who interact with customers to find out what types of technology they use, he said.

It’s important for senior management in any company to solicit input from employees throughout the organization, he said.

Advertise with us

“Ask for ideas on what can be done better. Ask: ‘What do you think? What do you see? What are the customers asking for? What technology is being used?’

“If you look at a lot of organizations that were successful and then went out of business or were bought out, they didn’t see change” coming, he said. “Based on corporate gravity, they always kept doing the same things.”

Companies good at reinventing themselves often are good at promoting self-initiative in the work force, said Jack Mason, director of the entrepreneurship program at Duquesne University’s business school.

“It’s important to hire, promote and develop employees who can think for themselves and understand the big picture,” he said.

“Have information gatekeepers in your organization to know what is going on with technology and customer needs, so you understand the needs and can innovate.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Craft cited a recent study that estimated 86 percent of the value of corporations today is based on human capital.

“People are the key resource of capital creation today,” he said.

“Plants and machines, they don’t change. People can see things. They are the key to the future.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.