When it comes to building a big hotel attached to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center, Craig Davis may be the lone voice crying out in the wilderness.
That’s particularly true given the hotel building boom in and near Downtown that has added nearly 1,500 rooms in the last five years.

There appears to be little appetite among hoteliers and even the convention center owner to erect a 500- to 600-room hotel that likely would require heavy financial subsidies.
Two years ago, even Mr. Davis, president and CEO of tourism group VisitPittsburgh, was in that camp, conceding the long-cherished hotel was on the back burner. “Right now the marketplace is somewhat strained,” he said at the time.
But Mr. Davis is of a different frame of mind these days. Statistics show growth in demand for hotel rooms Downtown once again is outpacing the increase in supply — 6.8% to 3.1% last year.
“I acknowledge that it’s a tough sell. That doesn’t stop us from reporting to the county or our stakeholders that if we follow our competitive cities and what they’re doing, it would make sense for us to have more large convention hotels in the future,” he said.
Read More
He might get an argument from Tim Zugger, general manager of the Doubletree by Hilton Hotel & Suites Downtown and past president of the Greater Pittsburgh Hotel Association.
“There definitely are benefits to having a convention center hotel. But now, with all of the smaller hotels that have been built, the room nights aren’t there to support a convention center hotel,” he said.
Likewise, Mary Conturo, executive director of the Pittsburgh-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority, which owns the land on which a hotel next to the convention center would be built, said such a project doesn’t make sense right now.
“There’s a significant number of hotel rooms being built privately so we don’t think it’s time for us to be looking to develop another hotel,” she said.
The SEA, the convention center owner, last sought proposals from developers interested in building such a hotel in 2015. But the project was never pursued, largely because of the big public subsidies that developers wanted.
Mark Popovich, senior managing director of real estate brokerage HFF, said a full-service convention center hotel costs about $350,000 to $400,000 a room to build.
That would mean a 600-room hotel could cost upwards of $240 million. “That would have to be heavily subsidized,” he said.
Since the SEA last requested proposals, hundreds of new hotel rooms have opened in or near Downtown, including a 248-room Hotel Monaco; a 225-room Embassy Suites; a 197-room Hilton Garden Inn; and a 200-room Drury Inn and Suites.
In the Golden Triangle, the average daily room rate dropped from $156.78 in 2015 to $150.72 in 2017 before rebounding slightly to $152.58 last year, according to STR, a global hospitality benchmarking company based in Hendersonville, Tenn.
Occupancy plunged from 70.3% in 2014 to 66.3% in 2016 before climbing again to 69% last year.
The impact also showed up in age-old terms of supply and demand. In Downtown and the fringe, the increase in supply outpaced the jump in demand 12.3% versus 8.2% in 2016, according to VisitPittsburgh.

‘A point of recovery’
As Mr. Davis indicated, the tide has turned the last two years — with the increase in demand topping the rise in supply at 5.6% versus 4.5% in 2017 and 6.8% versus 3.1% last year.
Despite those encouraging signs, Mr. Popovich described the Downtown and suburban markets as at “a point of recovery.” He sees both as saturated, particularly in the suburbs, which was hard hit by the downturn in the Marcellus Shale industry several years ago.
“Right now we’re not taking on and not being asked to take on new hotel construction financing,” he said. “Most banks are unwilling to lend [for hotels] or have too much exposure already.”
Paul Griffith, senior managing director of Newmark Knight Frank valuation and advisory for Pittsburgh, believes the Downtown and fringe market will continue to be “pretty healthy” long term as long as developers keep building office and entertainment projects.
But like others, he questioned the need for a convention center hotel.
“I can’t imagine without some significant state funding that it would be viable,” he said.
Currently, there are 353 rooms under construction in Downtown and the fringe, according to VisitPittsburgh. The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership estimates that there are 1,122 rooms in the pipeline in or near the Golden Triangle.
“I think that what we’re at already is too much for current business levels,” Mr. Zugger said.
The peak year for the local hotel industry was 2015, he said. In terms of room nights, the Doubletree is still off about 10% from where it was that year.

Filling more beds
It’s up to the local industry and VisitPittsburgh, Mr. Zugger said he believes, to try to find ways to bring more business Downtown.
Mr. Davis doesn’t disagree.
“That’s our job,” he said. “We are well aware that there is increasing supply and we are also well aware that we have a responsibility to help fill [that].”
If you take the 4,107 new rooms that have opened in the last five years in the region and multiply that by 365 days, there are 1.5 million additional rooms to be filled to reach full occupancy, Mr. Davis said.

“Those are staggering,” he said. “There’s no question that VisitPittsburgh has to lead the charge on that.”
The agency has eight sales people whose job it is to bring in hotel business. It has put together a “very aggressive” leisure campaign that has gone international with the arrival of nonstop flights to London and Frankfurt, Germany.
VisitPittsburgh also sees potential in generating more sports-related business. In 2017, the NCAA awarded 22 championship events to Pittsburgh for the years 2018 through 2021, the most of any city.
All of that is beyond the convention business, which generated about $210 million in direct revenue last year.

Attracting conventions
The top-selling night for hotels in the region is Saturday, Mr. Davis said. That, he added, is a sign of a strong leisure market — one VisitPittsburgh has worked hard to cultivate.
But now Mr. Davis believes it is time once again to turn the attention to the business side.
The average hotel built in recent years has been in the 100-room range, he said. While that is good for leisure travel, “It does not help us bring in new conventions,” he said.
“Our customers constantly tell us that if they want to bring large conventions into cities they want to put as many people in as few hotels as possible,” he said. “All the people that are delegates to the convention want to be together.”
Mr. Davis said the lack of another large hotel attached to the convention center to supplement the current 616-room Westin still ranks as the number one or number two reason groups bypass Pittsburgh.
He conceded that it would have been an “insult” to existing hotels to lobby for such a grandiose project when supply was outstripping demand.
“So now that we have effectively eaten up that supply, I would be very much in favor of an investment in a large convention center hotel,” he said.
Even if Mr. Davis can’t convince the powers that be of the need, he still sees a promising future ahead for the local hotel market.
“I’m very bullish about our future even if I don’t get a convention center hotel,” he said. “We’re going to sell what we have in the city.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.