Heywood Sanders says there’s one other thing as certain as death and taxes: public subsidies for convention center hotels.
If local political leaders think they can persuade a developer to build a 500-room hotel attached to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center without public help, they will be among the lucky few, he said. Pittsburgh and Allegheny County leaders said last week they will explore that route.
“You want to try, be my guest,” said Mr. Sanders, a professor at the University of Texas at San Antonio and author of the book “Convention Center Follies.”
From what Mr. Sanders has seen lately, there’s a much better chance that the public will be ponying up to help defray the cost.
In Washington D.C., for example, the $520 million, 1,175-room Marriott Marquis convention center headquarters hotel that opened in May was built with the help of $206 million in public funds.
The public is picking up the entire tab for the $272 million, 600-room convention center hotel being built in Cleveland. Cuyahoga County decided to go that route after developers expressed little interest in building it.
Read More
A 1,200-room hotel being built in Chicago also is being subsidized with hotel taxes and tax increment financing.
“It’s the same everywhere,” Mr. Sanders said.
In Pittsburgh, Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald are thinking about resurrecting a plan to build a full-service hotel in the parking lot next to the convention center.
Mr. Peduto said such a hotel was always meant to serve as the front door of the convention center but was never built. Local tourism officials have touted the need for such a so-called headquarters hotel to stay competitive with other cities in the battle for tourists.
While there is hope that perhaps such a hotel could be built without huge subsidies, particularly given Pittsburgh’s resurgence in recent years, history has not borne that out.
The last time the city-county Sports & Exhibition Authority did a request for proposals for the hotel in 2010, developers wanted at least $50 million in public subsidies to built it. Forest City Enterprises, which was chosen in 2003 to erect a hotel, never could reach a deal to start construction, even with $34 million in state subsidies available.
The hotel would supplement the 616-room Westin Convention Center Hotel that is next to the convention center and connected by a sky bridge.
While Downtown is in the midst of a hotel building boom, that involves smaller hotels being retrofitted into existing buildings. Mr. Sanders said such limited-service hotels don’t cost nearly as much as a full-service high-rise built from the ground up.
“The economics of those [smaller] developments work reasonably well. There’s not much risk to them. It doesn’t cost as much to build them, to operate them,” he said. “When you talk about big hotels, developers shy away from them.”
The sad thing is that convention center hotels rarely make a big difference in attracting conventions, given the hyper-competitive tourism market, and sometimes end up in trouble themselves, Mr. Sanders said.
In Baltimore, for instance, the city-owned Hilton has lost more than $50 million since opening six years ago as it struggles to fill rooms and make payments on $301 million in tax-exempt municipal revenue bonds.
The results should not be surprising, given that cities across the country are building bigger hotels and more convention center space in hopes of attracting the same limited pool of convention goers.
“When you do a hotel deal like this in a convention market as competitive as the one we have, when you get the hotel, you don’t get any more business,” Mr. Sanders said.
Mr. Peduto said it might be worth exploring the possibility of a convention center hotel because the city’s tourism industry is growing with its economy.
He noted that Pittsburgh has been able to land the National League of Cities conference in 2016 and is pursuing the NCAA women’s championship round in basketball.
The SEA will gauge interest from developers before officials decide to seek formal proposals.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.