When it comes to building a headquarters hotel next to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center, Downtown, local officials are finding there’s no such thing as a free ride.

The developers that have expressed an interest want to be subsidized in some way despite efforts by the Pittsburgh-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority to minimize the level of public participation in the project.

State Sen. Wayne Fontana, SEA board chairman, said he believes all five of the firms that responded to a request for qualifications in February to build the hotel or another “signature” development on two parcels adjacent to the center were seeking some level of subsidy.

“Everybody’s looking for a subsidy,” he said. “That’s not what we were hoping to see.”

Advertise with us

Although Mr. Fontana could not remember the exact amounts being sought, “I guess they all were in the $10 million” area and up, he said.

The good news, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald said, is that the amounts being requested are lower than they were in the past, when developers wanted more than $50 million in public help to build the hotel.

And not all of what is being asked for involves straight cash grants, he said. Tax increment financing or tax abatements could be in the mix as well, he noted.

“There are different creative financing ways being put forward,” he said. “We’re going to evaluate what makes sense.”

While the SEA had hoped to avoid demands for subsidies in trying to resurrect the hotel that has been on the drawing board for more than a decade, the fact they are being requested does not mean the project has hit another dead end, Mr. Fitzgerald said.

Advertise with us

“We’re still evaluating and still talking. I’m sure we’re going to continue to do so and hopefully come up with one plan that makes sense for Downtown and the economic growth of the industry,” he said.

Mr. Fontana said the effort to revive the hotel was put on the back burner over the summer as the SEA negotiated a new contract with SMG to manage the convention center and hired a new firm to lease retail space at the facility and authority-owned garages.

He expects the effort to pick up again in the fall. The SEA, he said, will have to evaluate “what was sent to us and then decide if and when we want to go back to these folks.” One possibility may be to ask the firms to tweak or change their proposals.

Those responding were two local firms Oxford Development Co. and McKnight Realty Partners, as well as Flaherty & Collins Properties of Indianapolis, Swerdling & Associates of Denver, and Starwood Hotels & Resorts.

Another potential complication is that the developers so far are proposing “way less” than the 500 or more rooms the SEA has been looking for in a headquarters hotel, Mr. Fontana said.

Advertise with us

“That’s part of this. If someone says, I’ll give you 125 rooms, is that worth doing?” he asked.

In the request for qualifications, the authority did give developers some flexibility, saying it not only wanted to hear from those interested in building a full-service hotel with 500 rooms or more, but also those who had different ideas for the property at Penn Avenue and 10th Street.

That, the SEA said, could include retail, office, residential, restaurant, outdoor public spaces or other commercial uses “that are economically viable,” either apart from or with a hotel.

Mr. Fitzgerald saw the situation as similar to the 3 PNC Plaza development, Downtown, which includes the 185-room Fairmont Hotel, offices, condos, and restaurant and retail space.

Whether any subsidies are justified, Mr. Fitzgerald said, depends on what the project would return to taxpayers in terms of jobs, economic growth and hotel rooms.

Advertise with us

“That’s the evaluation we’re all trying to make. It’s not like we want to give out subsidies. That’s the last thing we want to do,” he said.

VisitPittsburgh, the local tourism agency, has long championed the need for a headquarters hotel attached to the center to supplement the existing 616-room Westin Convention Center Hotel.

But given the recent hotel boom Downtown — with 1,500 rooms under construction or in the pipeline — it is taking a wait-and-see attitude.

“Right now, we want to see what effect the new supply will have on demand and make sure we’re making the best business decision,” said Craig Davis, CEO and president.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.