It’s becoming the biblical Lazarus of Downtown projects.

Left for dead a year ago, and several times before that, a plan to build a 500-room hotel attached to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center is being resurrected by top political leaders.

Mayor Bill Peduto said Thursday that he and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald have asked the Sports & Exhibition Authority to gauge the interest in and to study the feasibility of the proposed hotel, which would be built in a parking lot next to the convention center.

The full-service hotel, Mr. Peduto said, always was meant to be “the final part” of the convention center and to serve as its front entrance. “The building’s never been completed,” he said. “The hotel was supposed to be done.”

Advertise with us

If the SEA finds interest in the project, it could lead to a formal request for proposals from developers, although Mr. Peduto stressed that it isn’t close to happening yet.

The proposed hotel, which has been on the drawing board for more than a decade, has been in limbo for some time. It would supplement the existing 616-room Westin Convention Center Hotel located next to the convention center and connected by a sky bridge.

Three hotel companies, including Hyatt Hotels Corp. of Chicago and Omni Hotels & Resorts of Irving, Texas, were finalists in a request for proposals for the hotel put out by the SEA in 2010.

But no deal was reached, in part because of the lack of public subsidies for the project. Forest City Enterprises originally was selected to build the hotel in 2003 but never got it off the ground — even with the help of $34 million in state funding, money that has since been reallocated for other projects.

In the last request for proposals, developers wanted public help totaling more than $50 million, said state Sen. Wayne Fontana, chairman of the SEA board. As construction costs go up, full-service hotels are becoming very expensive to build, he said.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Peduto believes it may be time to try again.

“It’s much more different than it was several years ago. We just landed the National League of Cities conference. We’re looking at trying to pick up the women’s Final Four in basketball. It’s really a seller’s market. I meet on a weekly basis with national planners who are looking at Pittsburgh,” he said.

“Our tourist industry is growing, but at the same time so is our economy and people are coming to Pittsburgh and looking for spaces.”

Mr. Fitzgerald could not be reached for comment.

The plan is being resurrected amid a hotel boom Downtown. A 225-room Embassy Suites Hotel is being built on the top 10 floors of the Henry W. Oliver Building on Smithfield Street, a 248-room Hotel Monaco is close to opening in the former James Reed Building on Sixth Avenue, and a Drury Inn and Suites is being built in the former Federal Reserve Building on Grant Street.

Advertise with us

Nonetheless, Mr. Peduto believes there’s room for more.

“We don’t have over-capacity in our hotels, but we certainly have area for growth within our hotels. Even our major hotels that have been part of Downtown for years are looking at upgrading and expanding,” he said.

Mr. Fontana said one of the problems with the convention center hotel in the past was that developers tried to reduce the number of rooms to cut the cost. But if the hotel doesn’t have at least 500 rooms, “it’s not worth doing. That’s part of the balance you have to try to figure out,” he said.

Despite the problems, it may be worth taking another look at the hotel, Mr. Fontana said. With Pittsburgh growing and other hotels being proposed, developers may be willing to try it without much in the way of public subsidies, he said.

“I think it’s probably worth taking a shot. I think attitudes have changed. Pittsburgh’s hot right now, and I think that’s why [Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald] are thinking about doing it,” he said. “You don’t know until you try. I guess that’s my philosophy.”

Advertise with us

Asked about possible subsidies for the development, the mayor replied, “I wouldn’t speculate on that until we had an opportunity to have the SEA give us some feasibility with it. Then there’s really a due diligence to go fishing and see what’s out there and then we can go from that point.”

Local tourism group VisitPittsburgh long has championed a new hotel attached to the convention center, arguing that it’s a key weapon in competing for convention business, particularly when other cities such as Cleveland and Boston are adding large hotels.

The interest in the project comes at the same time that local political and foundation leaders also are exploring the possibility of adding a hotel to the August Wilson Center for African American Culture a block away as a means of generating revenue to sustain the arts facility in the future.

New York developer 980 Liberty Partners had proposed erecting a 200-room luxury hotel above the center as part of a $9.5 million bid to buy the building to satisfy a delinquent mortgage and other debts. But it backed out in the settlement reached this week under which three local foundations, aided by the city and the county, will buy the building for $8.49 million and keep it as an African-American arts and culture center.