Holly Brubach remembers one local hotel executive telling her that boutique hotels are “for cool people, and cool people don’t come to Pittsburgh.”
She’s setting out to prove him wrong.
Confident that cool people do come to Pittsburgh, Ms. Brubach, a former New York Times style editor, is planning to convert the historic Granite Building Downtown at Sixth Avenue and Wood Street into a 104-room boutique hotel with three bars and a brasserie-style restaurant.
With the help of a $2.5 million state redevelopment assistance capital grant announced Friday, Ms. Brubach, a Pittsburgh native, hopes to break ground on the $38 million project, dubbed the Forbes Hotel, in April and greet the first guests in September 2016.
Ms. Brubach admitted that she at one time shared the hotel executive’s opinion about the Steel City, but after living in Paris, Milan and Manhattan, she not only has come to appreciate her hometown but to celebrate it. She now lives here.
“The premise behind this hotel is Pittsburgh pride, which not that long ago would have been an oxymoron.
Read More
“When I moved back here in 2007, I discovered a city that had changed, and I had changed, too,” she said.
“Living elsewhere had enabled me to appreciate Pittsburgh in ways I never had before — its respect for nature, its ethnic traditions, its grit, its idiosyncrasies, its strong sense of neighborhood identity — all of this at a time when other cities were becoming increasingly homogenized.”
Ms. Brubach purchased the Granite Building, built in 1889-90 to house the German National Bank and serve immigrants, for $925,000 in late 2005 with the intent of converting it into condos during the first wave of residential building in the Golden Triangle.
That project succumbed to the recession, prompting Ms. Brubach to change course. Downtown now is experiencing a hotel boom, with about 1,500 rooms under construction or in the pipeline.
Ms. Brubach said her hotel will be an “alternative to big brand accommodations” and a showcase for Pittsburgh history and culture, one she hopes will attract out-of-town guests and locals.
To help with the new project, Ms. Brubach has acquired a smaller structure next to the Granite Building that once housed an Arby’s restaurant.
That building will be razed and a slender 12-story tower erected in its place and paired with the Granite Building.
With its arches and stone, the Granite Building, located next to the Duquesne Club, looks like a skinny version of the Allegheny County Courthouse — no coincidence given that it was designed in the same Richardsonian Romanesque style.
A facade easement protects the building from any unapproved alterations.
After her condo project collapsed, Ms. Brubach decided to hang on to the property.
Now she has a second chance at developing it.
“I do think it is a beautiful building, and I do think it deserves something good to happen to it,” she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.