A preservation group’s attempt to block the demolition of a former church in Shadyside was denied on Tuesday.
Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg denied all three requests of the East Liberty Valley Historical Society and other plaintiffs after seven hours of testimony over two days.
The defendants in the case were Beatrice Icon LLC, owner of the building, and the city of Pittsburgh.
“We appreciate the deliberate and thoughtful approach that the judge took to the case and believe his decision was correct,” said Jonathan Kamin, one of the lawyers for the defense.
The plaintiffs asked for a temporary restraining order to stop the building from being torn down, a suspension of a demolition permit issued by the city and to direct the city’s Historic Review Commission to place the church’s historic nomination on the agenda — which would prevent demolition if granted.
The plaintiffs claimed in their 32-page lawsuit that they had no idea that the church was in danger because no “placard of intent to demolish” was seen posted at the property from April 17 until June 8.
Read More
In addition, their lawsuit claimed that staff of the Historic Review Commission “unjustifiably delayed and have ‘pocket vetoed’ ” its application for the historic nomination.
According to the East Liberty Valley Historical Society, the church was built in 1890 as the Shady Avenue Cumberland Presbyterian Church at a cost of $20,000. The architect, Thomas Cox McKee, was inspired in part by the design of Henry Hobson Richardson’s Allegheny County Courthouse.
In 1911, an addition to the church was erected after the congregation outgrew the original building. In 1964, after membership declined, the building was sold to the Italian Christian Church of Pittsburgh.
It worshiped there until 2015, when it sold the building for $350,000 to Beatrice Icon.
In an interview with the Post-Gazette last month, Jason Lardo, head of Beatrice Icon, denied the plaintiffs’ allegations and said that everything was posted properly. Mr. Lardo said he tried to find other uses for the building, but nothing worked out.
“The goal was always to save it, but it’s too damaged to save,” Mr. Lardo said.
Caroline Mitchell, the plaintiff’s attorney and a civil rights attorney for over 40 years, said she was “saddened by the city’s conduct in this case.”
“We are not getting due process from our government when they refuse to talk to us.”
Ms. Mitchell said that the city refused to respond to reasonable requests for weeks on end and also did not agree to binding arbitration, which Ms. Mitchell said would have saved both sides thousands of dollars in legal fees and the many hours spent in court.
This story was updated at 5:55 p.m. on Wednesday to include comments from the plaintiffs’ attorney.
Mark Belko contributed. Emma Kim: ekim@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.