Two days after a preservation group lost a bid to block its demolition, a Shadyside church is coming down.

Beatrice Icon LLC, the owner of the church at 241 Shady Avenue, began tearing down the 133-year-old structure Thursday.

It moved ahead with the work after Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg denied a request by the East Liberty Valley Historical Society and other plaintiffs for a temporary restraining order to stop the demolition.

The judge also denied the group’s requests for a suspension of the demolition permit issued by the city and to direct the city’s Historic Review Commission to place on its agenda the church’s historic nomination, which, if approved, would have prevented the razing.

Advertise with us

“We abided by the court order and delayed our work for weeks to allow this matter to be adjudicated. Since it was adjudicated in our favor, we had every right to proceed [with demolition],” said Jonathan Kamin, Beatrice Icon attorney.

Mr. Kamin said he expects the work to take a couple of weeks.

Caroline Mitchell, attorney for East Liberty Valley Historical Society and the other plaintiffs, was not surprised to hear the demolition had started.

“When a judge says he is reinstating the demo permit, they have a demo permit and they are permitted to demolish it. Basically, that’s what’s going on,” she said.

In the court case, the plaintiffs contended that they had no idea that the church was in danger because “no placard of intent to demolish” was seen posted at the property from April 17 until June 8.

Advertise with us

Such a posting is required under the city’s building code after an application has been submitted, they said.

They also accused Beatrice Icon of not posting the demolition permit once it was issued by the city on May 19.

However, Jason Lardo, a Beatrice representative, said that everything was posted properly. He also said his intent was to reuse the church because his grandmother worshiped there but that it was too structurally unsound to save.

According to the East Liberty Valley Historical Society, the church debuted in 1890 as the Shady Avenue Cumberland Presbyterian Church. It was built at a cost of $20,000. The design was inspired in part by Henry Hobson Richardson’s Allegheny County Jail.

A church addition was built in 1911. In 1964, the property was sold to the Italian Christian Church of Pittsburgh. It worshiped there until 2015 when the building was sold to Beatrice Icon.

Advertise with us

Once the demolition is completed, a bank is expected to take over the space.

Emma Kim contributed. Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com