Beth Hoffman, an assistant professor in Pitt’s School of Public Health, knows the power of television to influence medical decisions. In February 2023, after her sister, Emily, was gravely injured when she was hit by a car while walking home in Point Breeze, her family felt at peace removing her from life support and donating her organs – not only because the organ donation box was checked on her driver’s license but because Emily had discussed the issue with her sister while watching an episode of “ER.”
Now, a new medical show is making an impact on public health — the Pittsburgh-set HBO Max production “The Pitt.” A study released this week by the University of Southern California’s Norman Lear Center found that viewers of the show were significantly more likely than nonviewers to seek out and share information about organ donation and end-of-life decision making.
For Ms. Hoffman and several other Pittsburgh experts who connected with the writing staff of “The Pitt,” it’s gratifying to see results from a show that spent so much time trying to portray Pittsburgh health care accurately.
“There’s often a, ‘We can either be realistic or we can be popular,” said Ms. Hoffman. “‘The Pitt’ has shown you can make an impact and be an Emmy-winning show and have a lot of viewers.”
“The Pitt,” which was partially filmed on location at Allegheny General Hospital on the North Side, follows emergency room staff during one 15-hour shift at the fictional Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center. By the end of its first season, which premiered in January, it averaged 10 million viewers per episode, telling complex stories about some of the most pressing issues in medicine.
With all those eyeballs on the show, researchers at USC set out to investigate if it was having an impact in health care.
Read More
The study looked at two of the most developed and emotional storylines on “The Pitt”: one a mother and father grappling with whether to donate the organs of their college-aged son who died from a fentanyl overdose, the other a brother and sister trying to reconcile their ailing father’s expressed wishes for a do-not-intubate order with their desire to keep him alive.
Researchers conducted an online survey of 1,409 HBO Max viewers, about half of whom had seen at least three episodes of “The Pitt.” Those who had seen either the organ donation or the end-of-life storyline were two to three times more likely to have searched for information or shared information about those topics than those who did not watch the show.
Nearly 40% of people who watched one or more episodes about the end of life storyline sought information about end-of-life planning, according to the study, and just over 15% of them shared information about it.
Of those who watched the organ donation storyline, nearly 27% searched for information and just over 17% shared information on social media.
The power of “The Pitt” is in its realism, with visuals and medical terminology not sanitized or simplified for viewers.
“There’s tons of research going back many decades showing that entertainment does have the power to move audiences. The conventional wisdom is that you really have to bury the educational component in the entertainment component,” said Erica Rosenthal, director of research at the USC Annenberg Norman Lear Center. “‘The Pitt’ really challenges that notion. A show can lean into accuracy, really prioritize that up front, really engage with these systemic challenges, and that doesn’t need to involve a trade-off in terms of entertainment value.”
The writing staff of “The Pitt” had several doctors on board, led by “ER” veteran Joe Sachs, a practicing emergency room physician and television writer and producer.
But they turned to local professionals for Pittsburgh flavor.
“They knew how to take care of an emergency, but how would it be taken care of in Pittsburgh?,” said Ronald Roth, an emeritus professor in emergency medicine at Pitt and retired city of Pittsburgh medical director, describing his conversations with Dr. Sachs. “They knew what paramedics did, but what would the Pittsburgh paramedics do? What would happen during a mass disaster in Pittsburgh — how would they respond?”
Ms. Hoffman, in Pitt’s public health department, had previously worked with the Hollywood, Health & Society program at USC’s Norman Lear Center, which connects medical television writers and producers to experts in the health care field. When “The Pitt” reached out to her looking for Pittsburgh experts, she connected them with Sylvia Owusu-Ansah, an emergency medicine physician at UPMC Children’s Hospital who studies health care disparities.
First on a two-hour Zoom call from Pittsburgh and then in a meeting in the writer’s room in Los Angeles, Dr. Owusu-Ansah shared her expertise. Numerous details that she provided made it onto the show, from the severe pain experienced by sickle cell patients in crisis to the story of the Freedom House ambulance service to the Nepali immigrants that have made Pittsburgh home.
She told them one story of a Black family in the emergency room that was so excited to be seen by a Black doctor that the child’s mother referred to Dr. Owusu-Ansah as “my queen” – a line that a “The Pitt” writer asked if she could use verbatim on the show.
While in Los Angeles, Dr. Owusu-Ansah also told the “The Pitt” and “ER” star Noah Wyle about Emily Hoffman’s family’s confidence in donating her organs because of their discussions watching “ER” and had him sign her memorial card.
Since the show debuted, Dr. Owusu-Ansah has heard from longtime friends who never realized the workload and emotional strain for emergency room staff. She knows that people even in her own family have thought more about end-of-life care and decisions. And she’s been flooded on social media with medical professionals wanting to get their own ideas into the hands of the show’s writers.
She believes that, in part because of the awareness raised on the show, she and others are finally getting traction in their efforts to get a Congressional Gold Medal for the Freedom House Ambulance Service, a predominantly Black cohort of paramedics that served the Hill District in the 1960s and ’70s and paved the way for modern EMS care.
“You can slice it so many ways with so many of these stories in how it’s impacted people’s lives already,” she said.
Dr. Owusu-Ansah even noticed herself being more assertive recently with the mother of a patient whose child had accidentally ingested cannabis, after getting so much feedback about the scope of the problem from doctors around the country after a similar storyline was portrayed on “The Pitt.”
“I feel like I was more vocal now that it was on ‘The Pitt,’” she said, “more willing to educate and advocate.”
The influence of the show has also been a positive for staff at AGH, which provided the inspiration for the look and feel of the show’s Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center.
“When ‘The Pitt’’s producers approached us two years ago about participating in a show set at a fictional hospital inspired by AGH, they told us they’d be taking a hard look at many of the daily, real-life issues that affect patients, families and health care workers,” said Dr. Imran Qadeer, president of AGH. “It’s no surprise that some of the show’s storylines have encouraged viewers to think more positively about organ donation, more critically about end-of-life care issues, and more sympathetically toward caregivers. We’re glad to see that viewers have been moved to action as a result.”
To develop the organ donation plotline, which spanned several episodes, writers of “The Pitt” spent hours interviewing staff at the O’Hara-based Center for Organ Recovery & Education. CORE hasn’t heard from any families who decided to donate their loved one’s organs specifically from watching the show, but is grateful for the awareness raised by the episodes and the care shown with the storyline.
“Early in their writing process, they met with our clinical staff to understand what families experience when faced with the decision to give the gift of life,” said Susan Stuart, president and CEO of CORE. “The resulting show reminded viewers of what we already know to be true: The real heroes of donation are the donors and their families, who CORE is privileged to serve every day, and also proved that the real-life stories of donor families choosing generosity in their darkest hours, when told with care and honesty, move people in a way fiction never could.”
Ms. Hoffman has been involved in several conversations with people who watched “The Pitt” and had questions about her family’s experience with donating her sister’s organs. A couple of people asked about the “honor walk,” a ceremony poignantly portrayed on the show.
Ms. Hoffman was also tracking other impacts of “The Pitt” through exercises for undergraduate students in her “Entertainment Media and Health” class. They watched Reddit posts after the show aired on Thursday nights and saw people mention how they had donated blood or wonder about end-of-life planning. They also saw health care professionals talk about how the show made them feel, a subject also explored in the Normal Lear Center report.
In interviews with 25 medical professionals, researchers found that the show made them feel validated and appreciated its emphasis on systemic health care challenges and the hidden toll on providers.
It’s something that Sheila Roth, a Pittsburgh social worker who also consulted with writers of the show, has noticed as well. Ms. Roth, who was an emergency room social worker at Mercy Hospital in the 1980s and ’90s, and then a professor of social work at Carlow University, now has a private therapy practice working with health care workers.
She consulted via video call with the show’s writers, who provided her with about 15 different scenarios and asked how they would play out from the perspective of a Pittsburgh emergency room social worker. She begged the producers not to portray their social worker as a frumpy old woman with a bun, and was happy to see the on screen depiction of the recurring social worker character.
“I was just thrilled with how they demonstrated the variety and the scope of the practice,” she said. “The overarching thing I feel is appreciation — there’s just a lot of people who say, ‘Oh my gosh it was so refreshing to see the reality of our role.’”
As the show developed its storyline on a fictional mass shooting, she introduced the writers to her husband, Dr. Roth, who had decades of experience in Pittsburgh emergency medicine. He shared with the writers some lessons that Pittsburgh has learned from major events such as the Tree of Life synagogue shooting. He also told the writers that Pittsburgh was in the process of implementing an EMS medic supervisor’s “genius” idea to use slap bracelets to triage patients in mass casualty incidents. Those slap bracelets were portrayed on the show, and have since been implemented in real life in Pittsburgh, he said.
Dr. Roth retired as a practicing emergency doctor in 2023. When he watched the show, he was struck by the way that it put him right back in the emergency department.
“It’s very realistic, and I think what’s unique and different is the emotions of the workers — the residents, the attendings. I’ve felt all that,” he said. “Watching an episode was so stressful for me. I loved it but, you know, I don’t work in the ED anymore and when I stopped, I felt a 1,000-pound weight get off my shoulders. Every time I watched it, the 1,000 pound weight came back.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.