Daisy Jade is used to reporting on light and fun stories as a “Pittsburgh Today Live” entertainment and lifestyle correspondent. She’s generally not the broadcaster informing her fellow Pittsburghers about the latest grisly murder in their community.
That’s exactly the kind of news Jade was asked to deliver during her brief stint on “American Rust: Broken Justice,” season 2 of the locally shot crime drama that’s debuting Thursday on Prime Video. She mustered all her prior acting experience and local news know-how to properly convey a few horrifying happenings that recently occurred in and around the fictional Western Pennsylvania town of Buell, Pa.
“Typically, real newscasters use a teleprompter to deliver the news,” Jade told the Post-Gazette last week via X. “But I did NOT have that option and had to memorize a lengthy monologue AND deliver it with a serious tone.”
Pittsburghers can watch Jade “tap into my acting mode” when all 10 “American Rust: Broken Justice” installments drop simultaneously on Prime Video later this week. The nine-episode first season of “American Rust” that originally aired on Showtime in fall 2021 will also be made available to stream via Prime Video on Thursday.
In addition to Jade, the Post-Gazette also sat down earlier this month with four returning “American Rust” actors — and one new face — to discuss their individual and collective “Broken Justice” journeys.

‘They have great taste’
It made perfect sense for Prime Video to pair Alex Neustaedter and Mark Pellegrino while scheduling “Broken Justice” interviews. Neustaedter plays Billy Poe, season 1’s main murder suspect who’s trying to move on while still recovering from injuries sustained during a brutal prison beatdown. Pelligrino is back as Virgil Poe, Billy’s charismatic but unreliable father who finds some stability through a new business venture.
Read More
Neustaedter was one of multiple “Broken Justice” actors who expressed how “pleasantly surprised” they were by Western Pennsylvania. Pellegrino believes this region is “totally underrated” and didn’t even realize part of “The Dark Knight Rises” was filmed here while describing how Pittsburgh was “looming up there like Gotham” as he stared down at it from atop Mount Washington.
“Broken Justice” often relies on the gregarious Virgil to lighten up the show’s sometimes somber disposition. Pellegrino appreciated that the season 2 creative team provided plenty of opportunities for Virgil to prove he’s capable of “more than just a 12-pack of beer, a joint and a football game.”
Poor Billy is once again thrust into a series of demanding physical and emotional challenges that he meets with varying degrees of aplomb. Billy is a former high school football standout, and Neustaedter recalled training for six months prior to filming season 1 in order to gain about 30 pounds.
“That was already getting me in the headspace,” he said. “This season, I stripped it all back and lost a bunch of weight. ... It prepared me, almost like a boot camp.”
He and Pelligrino are both down for a theoretical “American Rust” season 3 that co-showrunner Adam Rapp insists would shoot in Western Pennsylvania. Pelligrino would probably love that considering his fondness for local establishments like Stout PGH in the Strip District.
Bonding over martial arts, dogs and sporting events — “what a father and son would do,” as Pellegrino put it — helped him and Neustaedter hone their on-screen chemistry across two seasons of “American Rust.”
Neither actor was sure they would ever get to reprise their roles again after Showtime canceled “American Rust” following its first season. Amazon Freevee scooped it up for a second outing that was eventually moved onto Amazon’s flagship streaming service.
“I think they have great taste,” Pellegrino said of Amazon. “Because I think this show has a great deal of potential, and it realizes all that potential in season 2.”

‘Out of a cannon’
Prime Video also paired series veteran Rob Yang with “American Rust” newcomer Luna Lauren Velez. Yang plays Steve Park, Buell’s new police chief. He assumes that mantle in “Broken Justice” after former Chief Del Harris (Jeff Daniels) joins the Pittsburgh Police Department following a gruesome triple homicide that Steve suspects involved his former boss.
Velez portrays Angelo Burgos, a Pittsburgh PD detective and Del’s partner. She was hesitant to take on another law enforcement role after portraying Florida police Capt. Maria LaGuerta across seven seasons of Showtime’s “Dexter.” Rapp and co-showrunner Dan Futterman ultimately convinced her to join the “American Rust”-verse.
“I loved the setting, I loved all the characters, all the work I saw,” Velez said. “It’s almost like an actor’s dream to do this kind of work, I feel like. I was really happy to be part of it.”
She appreciated how “lovely, family-oriented [and] calm” Pittsburgh was.
Yang didn’t get to explore Western Pennsylvania much while shooting season 1 due to strict COVID-19 protocols, but he made a point to drive his rental car all over the Pittsburgh area while shooting season 2.
“It’s so beautiful and hilly and there’s so much history there,” he said. “It was nice to go back, having gotten familiar with it, but to really go out more now that we didn’t have this pandemic hanging over our heads.”
For Yang, “American Rust” season 2 “launches out of a cannon” and never lets up. That was definitely the case for both Steve and Angela’s relentless quests to uncover the various secrets they’re both convinced Del is harboring.
“I feel like these two people don’t talk to each other that much,” Velez said, referring to Angela and Del’s relationship. “They just understand each other profoundly — until she doesn’t.”
These two avid binge-watchers can’t wait for folks to give “Broken Justice” a shot. Velez and Yang hope viewers will be so enraptured by the show’s rapid pace and filmmaking flourishes that they can’t help but press play on the next episode.
“It’s cinematic,” Yang said. “It’s a thriller, and I think there are enough surprises that you’re going to want to find out what happens.”

‘More drama, more mystery’
The Post-Gazette’s only solo “Broken Justice” interview was with Julia Mayorga, who reprised her season 1 role of aspiring lawyer Lee English. After leaving New York and divorcing her husband, Lee is now living in her late father’s house in Buell with Billy and her brother, Isaac (David Alvarez).
Though Mayorga wasn’t prepared for chilly Pittsburgh winters, she eventually grew to enjoy the region’s food, walkability and vintage shopping. Mayorga knows that shooting “American Rust” here “informs the story,” a notion that Lee exemplifies given that she’s one of the few figures who regularly travels between rural Buell and Pittsburgh’s more urban environments.
Production on “American Rust” season 1 was delayed by about a year due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Mayorga credited all the time she, Neustaedter and Alvarez spent together waiting for filming to resume for the “combative energy” they were able to develop between their characters that’s rooted in their real-life friendship.
For Mayorga, the name of the game in “Broken Justice” was “more drama, more mystery.” That certainly held true for Lee, who’s navigating her feelings for Billy while also using her legal skills to help a few Western Pennsylvanians who are being railroaded by the shady Landwill Energy.
“I feel like she had such a purpose,” Mayorga said. “It gave that pressure of, I need to do this. ... There’s definitely adrenaline and it’s scary, but throughout the season, she sees some goodness coming out of what she’s doing.”
She’s well-acquainted with the sensation of reaching 2 a.m., eyes burning, but still somehow finding the stamina to continue watching a particularly bingeable show. Mayorga has a hunch that the way “Broken Justice” “keeps you on your toes” may compel anyone like her to stay up way past their bedtime.
Like her co-stars, Mayorga felt a combination of “relieved, lucky, excited” after learning “American Rust” had landed at Amazon following its Showtime cancelation.
“It’s a lot of waves of ups and downs,” she said. “That we’re going to continue telling the stories of our characters, it’s nice.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and X @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.