“American Rust” fans have likely been eagerly anticipating another season of television set in and around the fictional town of Buell, Pa., since the Western Pennsylvania-shot crime drama was unexpectedly resurrected from the great TV beyond almost two years ago.

They weren’t alone.

“It’s always great to return to characters that you already know,” Jeff Daniels, who plays now-former Buell police Chief Del Harris, told the Post-Gazette. “‘Newsroom’ was like that. It was nice to also find out what happened!”

Daniels was referring to the Aaron Sorkin-created drama that ran from 2012-14 on HBO. in which he starred as cynical news anchor Will McAvoy. Unlike “The Newsroom,” it wasn’t a given that he or anyone else would ever find out how the Buell crew’s lives were affected by the game-changing events in season 1’s finale.

Advertise with us

On Thursday, Prime Video will release all 10 episodes of the show’s locally made second season that it decided to slightly rebrand as “American Rust: Broken Justice.” The Post-Gazette caught up with Daniels, series co-lead Maura Tierney and the shows’ creators to discuss what it took to bring this improbable sophomore outing from the Showtime scrap heap to one of Hollywood’s most prominent streaming services.

‘Don’t get too comfortable’

The first season of “American Rust” was supposed to begin shooting around the Pittsburgh area right before the COVID-19 pandemic shut down all Hollywood film production for a large chunk of 2020. Cameras began rolling a year later, and that initial season — which was based on Philipp Meyer’s 2009 (and Western Pennsylvania-set) novel of the same name — premiered on Showtime in September 2021.

Showtime canceled “American Rust” a few months later. “Broken Justice” co-showrunner Dan Futterman attributed that verdict to the changes going on at Showtime as parent company Paramount Global was transitioning the premium cable network over to its current status as “Paramount+ with Showtime.”

“I think what happened at Showtime was not the fault of the executives we were working with there,” he said. “They were gobbled up by a bigger monster and the big corporation, and I think these decisions were no longer theirs.”

Prior to that disappointment, Futterman and co-showrunner Adam Rapp convened an early season 2 writers room to begin developing future plot points. Futterman always felt like they “had a good story to tell” and appreciated Daniels’ commitment to “talking up his support” for their work.

Advertise with us

The show’s brain trust had at least partially fleshed out quite a few ideas when Amazon Freevee came calling in June 2022. Earlier this year, Amazon announced that both “Broken Justice” and “American Rust” season 1 will instead debut simultaneously on Prime Video.

Tierney genuinely “thought the show was over” after Showtime axed it, but was also down for another go-around as Grace, a Buell-based agitator and Del’s paramour.

Daniels said he was given a general outline of where “Broken Justice” was headed. Futterman and Rapp still managed to constantly defy his expectations with how they built on the show’s previously established relationships and story beats.

“Don’t get too comfortable!” Daniels recalled Rapp warning him regarding Del’s arc. “It’s about to get worse for you.”

Crew members set up for a scene on Mount Washington while filming the Western Pennsylvania-set Prime Video series "American Rust: Broken Justice." (Kelley Van Dilla)

‘They’re real people’

With no more source material to draw from for, Futterman, Rapp and company had to craft a totally original story for “Broken Justice.” They ended up having Maura Tierney’s Grace Poe anchor much of the show’s Buell action while moving Daniels’ Del back into his previous role as a detective with the Pittsburgh Police Department.

Advertise with us

Just like season 1, Buell is an amalgamation of rural locales cobbled together from shoots that took place in areas like Aspinwall, Duquesne, Charleroi, Monessen and Brownsville. In “Broken Justice,” way more filming and storylines occur within the Pittsburgh city limits.

While Futterman was the driving creative force behind season 1, he and Rapp split “Broken Justice” showrunning duties more evenly. Rapp spent more time in Pittsburgh this season and was more heavily involved in location scouting and set decoration. He credited “Broken Justice” production designer Eric Weiler for creating “an authentic, amazingly detailed” Pittsburgh PD headquarters in the Strip District.

Rapp also praised the many Pittsburghers who barely flinched as they filmed an intricately choreographed scene in which hidden cameras captured Daniels having a frantic conversation while walking along Penn Avenue Downtown.

“It looked like a scene out of ‘The Conversation’ or something ...,” Rapp said, referring to director Francis Ford Coppola’s 1974 thriller. “I think some of them knew it was Jeff Daniels. Some of them could see people with walkies. But they were just in the flow of it. They’re not really wowed by much there. They’re real people.”

Everyone involved remains impressed by the diversity inherent in this region’s topography. Daniels stayed on Mount Washington while filming “Broken Justice,” and Tierney teased him during a joint Zoom interview about once saying that the view from up there is “like looking down on Paris.”

Advertise with us

Futterman brought up Del’s cabin, which season 1 production designer Lester Cohen constructed by a sound stage in Churchill.

“You’d come down that hill from a parking lot and it really looked like you had gone down a very big back road, and here’s this old cabin up on this hill that had been there for a decade that Del Harris had built,” he said. “The authenticity with which that was done was so beautiful.”

Maura Tierney as Grace Poe in "American Rust: Broken Justice." (Dennis Mong / Prime Video)

‘I hope it worked’

Futterman and Rapp focused on setting up “Broken Justice” storylines that felt both organic and lived up to Futterman’s assertion that “surprising things happen in dire situations.” Rapp said the “Broken Justice” writing staff was interested in achieving “dramatic extremes” and inventing clever ways to “reveal these turns and twists.”

Tierney felt that the “Broken Justice” writers “sort of really switched it up with my character,” mainly through the bank account boost Grace receives after becoming the latest ambassador for shady fracking outfit Landwill Energy.

“Fracking is reality for a lot of this part of the country, and it brings with it a great deal of opportunity, peril and possible downsides,” Futterman said. “We did not want to take a political stance on this. We wanted to understand what Grace could get out of it and what her character felt that she was owed from an entire life of struggle.”

Advertise with us

After filming two seasons of television here, the New York-based Tierney still believes that Pittsburgh can be “a challenging city” — especially for out-of-town drivers. Still, she recognizes how the Steel City “contributes so much to the quality and authenticity of the show” and relished the opportunity to embody a more fully realized (and financially stable) version of Grace.

“The show’s serious, the writing’s serous,” Tierney said. “The difference for me in season 2 was, I tried to give her a little more of a sense of humor. I hope it worked.”

Another choice that the whole “Broken Justice” team hopes will work: Amazon opting to drop all 10 episodes at once on Prime Video. Ideally, the streamer’s gambit will result in increased viewership and a green light for another “American Rust” season. When asked if he was up for another Buell adventure, Daniels simply said, “Sure.”

“I generally do what Jeff does,” Tierney quipped. “We’ll see!”

Rapp already has some “ideas story-wise” for a potential third season, though nothing concrete. Both he and Futterman are aware that it would be borderline sacrilegious at this point to make a season of “American Rust” outside the region in which it’s set.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know why we would go anywhere else,” Rapp said. “It’s such a great place, and we’ve established so many of our shooting and production relationships there. It’s a great place to shoot and a pleasure to be there.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and X @jaxelburgh.