Once again, “American Rust” is changing homes. This move, though, might be the ultimate show of good faith in its creative and commercial potential going forward.
Amazon Prime Video announced Thursday that it will premiere the entire 10-episode second season of the Western Pennsylvania-shot crime series on March 28. It also revealed that the show’s sophomore outing has officially been dubbed “American Rust: Broken Justice.”
“American Rust” season one originally aired on Showtime in 2021 before the network now known as “Paramount+ with Showtime” canceled it a few months later. The show was resurrected for a second season in June 2022 by Amazon Freevee, which is where it was expected to live until Thursday’s announcement that “Broken Justice” will instead debut on Amazon’s flagship streaming service.
“Cleary, they want to get it out as one of their main titles,” co-showrunner Adam Rapp told the Post-Gazette Thursday morning. “I’m really excited about that.”
Both seasons of “American Rust” are largely set in the fictional town of Buell, Pennsylvania. The series was originally based on Philipp Meyer’s 2009 novel of the same name. It stars Jeff Daniels as Buell Police Chief Del Harris; Maura Tierney as Del’s paramour, Grace Poe; Alex Neustaedter as Grace’s troubled son, Billy Poe; Mark Pellegrino as Grace’s ex, Virgil Poe; and David Alvarez and Julia Mayorga as siblings Isaac and Lee English.
While season one essentially played out the plot of Meyer’s novel, “Broken Justice” has no source material to serve as inspiration. Its narrative was conceived by the “American Rust” production team that includes both Rapp and co-showrunner Dan Futterman.
Read More
“Broken Justice” was shot throughout the Pittsburgh area from November 2022 to April 2023. While a lot of filming took place in areas like Aspinwall and Monessen, Rapp said that a significant portion of “Broken Justice” was made in the Steel City itself.
“I’m so excited for Pittsburghers to see this,” he said. “I think they’re going to see a lot of their hometown in the frame. The bridges, storefronts, streets. We did so much shooting in Pittsburgh proper. It’s such a beautiful city to shoot everywhere you point the camera.”
Amazon Prime Video’s press site helped clarify where each of the characters find themselves after season one’s game-changing conclusion. Del rejoined the Pittsburgh Police Department and is now partnered with Detective Angela Burgos (“Dexter” veteran Luna Lauren Velez). Steve Park (Rob Yang) is now Buell’s police chief and remains curious about how much Del really knows about a grisly season-one crime spree.
Billy apparently recovers enough from what appeared to be life-threatening injuries to help his mother purchase the property on which she lives. Grace in turn “uses this land to give herself new economic/work opportunities,” according to that plot description.
Elsewhere, Billy and Lee try to “figure out their relationship with each other as they navigate their own futures”; Isaac starts a new job and “pursues new romantic situations”; Virgil borrows money from Grace so “he can pursue a new business opportunity”; and, arguably most notably, “the town of Buell is rocked by more murders that [create] chaos in the lives of all of its residents.”
“Even though we have a lot more bodies dropping this season and there’s a lot more mystery, quick storytelling, we have not sacrificed our character development and nuance, which we really loved about season one,” Rapp said.
Bill Camp’s Henry English, Isaac and Lee’s sickly father who seemingly overdosed in the show’s season-one finale, was noticeably absent from Amazon’s synopsis. Rapp confirmed that though Henry’s “presence will be felt” in “Broken Justice,” “he is not going to be there.”
Amazon’s Thursday press release also mentioned a few additions to the season two cast, including Marc Menchaca (“Ozark”) as Vic Walker, Nick Sandow (“Orange Is the New Black”) as Mike Orr, Britian Seibert (“A Murder at the End of the World”) as Cynthia Frazier, Christopher Denham (“Billions”) as Russell Wolff, Amelia Workman (“FBI”) as Rinna Bransford, Leon Addison Brown (“The Knick”) as Chief Bolt and Sara Lindsey (“Concussion”) as Maya Park.
Rapp is still overjoyed that Amazon seems to feel there’s “a great potential for the show to see a wide audience,” as evidenced by its decision to drop all 10 episodes of “Broken Justice” on Prime Video. He thinks season two’s structure will lend itself well to a binge-friendly release strategy.
“I think our story has more narrative muscle in the beginning in terms of the mystery and procedural stuff,” Rapp said. “I feel like there’s a tremendous amount of excitement and story that burns faster. I think it’s going to be addictive.”
Everyone involved with “American Rust” is banking on this plan panning out so swimmingly that Amazon won’t hesitate to order a third “American Rust” season — including Pittsburgh Film Office director Dawn Keezer.
“We fully expect ‘American Rust’ to be back for season three,” Keezer told the Post-Gazette. “We’re excited about the new partnership with Amazon, seeing season two and welcoming ‘American Rust’ back to Pittsburgh as soon as possible.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.