It’s easy for regular symphony attendees to become jaded about pieces on the canon. Do we really need to hear another Beethoven symphony, another Mozart concerto or another “Firebird?”
We have to remember: It’s always someone’s first time hearing the work live, a chance for the orchestra to make a sterling, unforgettable first impression. And the percentage of first-time symphony attendees has jumped since the COVID-19 pandemic.
According to the Pittsburgh Symphony, the organization gained more than 9,000 new households last year, a 30% jump over its previous tally of 30,000 households. (There may or may not be more than one person in a “household” — it’s tricky to tabulate these things exactly.)
So even at the symphony’s finale weekend, the Friday performance of Stravinsky’s “Firebird” was likely falling on quite a few pairs of fresh ears. The ominous, muttering of the opening, the whimsical charm of the “Dance of the Princesses,” the shocking explosion that opens the “Infernal Dance” hits differently live than on recordings, and Friday’s performance was an exceptional rendition, even by Pittsburgh’s typically high standards.
The end of the season seems a reasonable time to ponder how the orchestra is fairing in terms of its artistry and its health as an organization, especially given that the orchestra embarks in August on another international tour, where it will represent the Steel City in some of Europe’s fabled music halls.
Let’s dive in.
Read More
Highs and lows
With the orchestra’s music director, Manfred Honeck, at the podium, “Firebird” was indeed the evening’s highlight and evidenced several positive trends I’ve noted this season.
This ensemble’s ability to play both extremely quietly and with utter intensity is one of its great strengths. I’ll add that the first violins have been tightening up over the course of the season, playing more together and crisply than in seasons past. This is perhaps due to leadership roles at the front of the section being filled, including the associate and assistant concertmaster positions (Justine Campagna and Dylan Naroff, respectively).
There’s been definite improvement.
Brass are still too loud at times, but they were effective rather than overbearing in “Firebird.”
During the concert opener, “Fifteen: Symphonic Fantasy on the Art of Andy Warhol,” they indeed overshadowed the other sections at times. That work, by the American composer, Michael Dougherty, premiered here in 2022. Its five movements are sonic takes on the Pittsburgh-born Warhol’s art, and each has a singular idea that is stretched perhaps too thin. (In other words, it’d be more effective if it had been shorter and tighter — even though it’s generally lighthearted, some of the movements meander on a bit.)
This orchestra brings a particular sort of hot-blooded energy to many of its performances. This was absent in the other work on the program, Beethoven’s fourth piano concerto with pianist Yefim Bronfman, who regularly plays with the PSO and who will be going on tour with the orchestra. The opening movement sounded polished to the point of mechanicalness, intimate in character but with an odd lack of communication between piano and orchestra. The later movements increased in drama and cohesion.
I can’t emphasize enough how excellent “Firebird” sounded, however. What an orchestra!
Still, this has become something of a trend in itself — the second half of concerts with Honeck conducting tend to sound noticeably better than the first half. Perhaps it’s a question of priorities or rehearsal allocation? The openers would benefit from similar treatment.
Even though the symphony has been attracting numerous new listeners in recent seasons, their challenge — as at many performing arts organizations around the country — is how to bring those new listeners back. Attendance remains lower than pre-pandemic times and averaged about 1,400 people per concert for the classical series this year.
That’s nothing to sneeze at, and these difficulties aren’t unique to the symphony. Consumer behavior evolved during the pandemic, and arts organizations are still working to rebuild their customer base.
A recent report estimated the symphony’s economic impact at $125 million and may provide an added incentive to donate and preserve the quality of musicianship here.
Next year, the orchestra will explore the idea of performing on different nights and times to follow shifting audience patterns and more flexible subscription offers to tempt some of the new listeners to purchase multiple tickets.
The new name of the game seems to be flexibility and customization, as attendees are becoming increasingly omnivorous in their arts diets.
Still, for a home organization, the symphony is the Steel City’s best ambassador domestically and abroad, and Friday’s performance once again demonstrated why.
The program repeats at 7:30 p.m. Saturday and 2:30 p.m. Sunday at Heinz Hall.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.