There’s something captivating about Laufey’s singing voice. It’s velvet-smooth and a touch smoky in an old-timey, jazzy sort of manner and has catapulted her to social media fame and hundreds of millions of streams in recent years.

That fame has translated to screaming crowds at her live tour stops — lots of young women accompanied by patient-looking dates — including a pair of performances this week in the Steel City with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra.

On Monday, Laufey (pronounced LAY-vay) wafted onto the Heinz Hall stage to the sound of a brass chorus schmaltzing its way through the opening of her 2023 hit, “Dreamer,” joining in to thread her voice through the punch and sting of orchestral jazz accompaniment.

This first tune established the evening’s pattern: First came a brief orchestral accompaniment featuring an instrument like the flute or bassoon or cello before Laufey, a 25-year-old Icelandic Chinese singer-songwriter, began spinning lyrics about first loves and innocent romances atop orchestral textures.

Advertise with us

Songs largely kept to the same ambling tempo and began blurring into one another after a time. If they were a little repetitive in theme and mood, they were at least poetic and pleasant: “One more kiss, wine-stained lips, I don’t want to go to sleep yet...”

Instrumentals

Laufey has spoken in interviews about her love for classical music and orchestras and providing an entry point to orchestral music and jazz for her generation. Heinz Hall was indeed packed with first-timers on Monday, and Tuesday’s reprisal show also sold out, a rarity at most orchestral shows today. She’s sharing a passion for another kind of music and deserves all credit for sharing that success with the orchestras she’s performed with, including the Icelandic Philharmonic and the Los Angeles Philharmonic.

Her stage presence is quirky and cute and unvarnished in an endearing way. (“Did anyone notice I forgot the lyrics to ‘Magnolia?’ Yeah I just started humming,” she said with a laugh.)

Still, her arrangements fall into the same trap I hear most orchestral pop arrangements fall into — purely accompanying rather than taking advantage of more of the abundant talent onstage.

Jazz is improvisation and give and take and sharing the spotlight for moments of pure creativity. Even in classical music, some of the great operas of history include what are called “obligato” lines, or prominent instrumental lines in duet with the voice. (Budding opera nerds should check out “Parto, ma tu ben mio” from Mozart’s opera “La Clemenza di Tito” on Spotify or YouTube for an example.)

Advertise with us

Backing Laufey

The point is, involving the orchestra more in some of the solo lines or spotlighting different instruments in duet with the voice could help provide more distinguishing features to each song. There were little moments of this, true, especially in larger numbers like “California and Me,” but they were cursory and still too subservient to the solo voice.

After all, as unique as Laufey’s voice is, there isn’t much dynamic variety or emotional nuance in the way she’s using it. (Sudden shifts to a whisper work much better in a sound studio than on a stage, where it merely sounded like the mixing was off in those moments.)

There were flashes of character from the musicians in the bossa nova-inspired “From the Start” or “Falling Behind” or the more pop-like “Lovesick,” but under the baton of associate conductor Moon Doh the orchestra was largely relegated to providing ambience and rhythm.

If one of the world’s great orchestras like the Pittsburgh Symphony isn’t going to do much more than serve as a backup band, why have them there at all?

Jazz ghost

For Laufey’s fans, the show’s homogeneity and singular focus isn’t a bad thing — they know what they’re getting and seem to quite enjoy it. For those newer to her work, like me, it’s tough not to compare her to other singer/songwriters and entertainers that bring a more deliberate emotional arc to a show or more variety in song topic and mood. (Actually, I found myself listening to old Edith Piaf records afterward.)

Advertise with us

To bring the show to a close, she sang an arrangement of “Misty,” a jazz standard by a Pittsburgher. The composer in question, Erroll Garner, was a fantastic pianist as famous for the joy in his playing as for sitting atop a pair of phone books to reach the keys more comfortably.

Pittsburgh was once a great city for jazz, as all the greats passed through clubs here on tours from New York to Chicago and the West Coast and back. That scene has made something of a comeback in recent years.

Yet even this famously well-known tune sounded largely like the rest of her set list, subsumed by the same style of singing as the rest of the show.

Well-known tunes are new for everyone at one time. It's always wonderful to see so many new faces at the symphony, and any orchestra would be lucky to have Laufey appear and introduce them to a portion of the public they struggle to reach on their own. The next orchestra on her tour schedule is the Chicago Philharmonic at Lollapalooza in August.

Still, every act can use refinement. Hers is no exception.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.