Here’s a quick parable: A man creates a technology to do some menial tasks for him, but it spirals out of control and nearly kills him until someone has the sense to pull the plug.

Sound like the cautionary AI trope? This tale is old enough to harken back to a time when unexplainable technology was simply called “magic.” This is the story of the “Sorcerer’s Apprentice,” immortalized in Disney’s “Fantasia” with Mickey Mouse enchanting a broom to carry water.

Now, Mickey’s great and all, but have you heard the music? It’s exceptional. The Pittsburgh Symphony performed it Friday night in Heinz Hall and will repeat the program Sunday.

The French composer Paul Dukas wrote the musical score, with its famous marching bassoons, in 1897, basing it on a poem satirizing the advent of the Industrial Revolution by Goethe, who in turn based it on a bit of Greek satire, which is based on an Egyptian myth about, I kid you not, an enchanter bringing a clay crocodile to life to eat his adulterous wife and her lover.

Advertise with us

(The gator eats him too, of course.)

The moral is simple: Don’t invoke forces you don’t fully understand.

Techno music

AI is upending every industry and already butting heads with the law in the music world, as programmers experiment with feeding recordings and songs into algorithms that can reproduce artists’ voices or songwriting styles. It’s creepy. The record label Sony “signed” an AI artist late last year. Noonoouri’s oddly synthetic top track has more than a million streams already. Plus, as instrumental synthesizers become more and more lifelike, the TV and film industry is increasingly looking to synthesizers to score motion pictures to cut costs.

The broom is starting to march, at least in music production.

Dukas’ score is a particularly colorful take on the fable. It begins with some languid, hazy spell craft, fluttering and flickering as the master practices his art. Soon, the apprentice, left to his own devices, casts the spell amid screaming trills in the winds, and the broom lurches awkwardly to life in that immortal bassoon tune as it carries water to fill a well. Winds caper about, arrogantly cheerful as the broom and music gain steam.

Advertise with us

Soon, however, the apprentice realizes he can’t stop the broom and cleaves it in two with an ax (with a corresponding snickt! snackt! in the percussion). The tune starts slowly, now doubled, with the bassoon and bass clarinet acting as the severed halves, picking themselves up, dusting themselves off and cheerfully flooding the joint. The master returns home and lifts the enchantment. After a timid apology from the apprentice, the master gives him a disciplinary swat.

It's quite a comical finale.

AI anxiety

Under the baton of guest conductor Vasily Petrenko, the Pittsburgh Symphony’s performance was inspired and colorful on Friday, filled with zest and humor. The insolence of the contrabassoon as the broom comes back to life, the mealy mouthed viola apology, the desperate wail of the trumpet as the water overtakes the magician’s house, all standout moments.

My only suggestions: the opening was a bit loud and solid instead of soft and mysterious. Plus, Petrenko held the broom’s march at a stable, stolid gait that seemed more plodding than mischievous. Minor matters of taste.

The remainder of the program featured Hungarian composer Franz Liszt’s first piano concerto, played heroically and sensitively by guest pianist Benjamin Grosvenor. The second half was devoted to Tchaikovsky’s “Manfred” Symphony, another work about a magician, a series of four scenes and an hour of music. This was much more serious and sonorous than “Sorcerer’s Apprentice,” but aside from some startling intonation in the winds and some overplaying by the brass at times, the orchestra delivered the work admirably.

Advertise with us

Human touches

It was also, of course, unique, perhaps the greatest argument for the value of live music over artificially generated music. Around the world, composers are continuing to experiment with AI in creating melodies and art, finishing works like Schubert’s “Unfinished” Symphony or Beethoven’s 10th symphony. There are also plenty of examples of AI generated original compositions populating streaming platforms.

Those that I’ve heard aren’t unpleasant or anything, but they lack spontaneity and inspiration, and generally seem more suitable to background music in a coffee shop than the concert hall. Plus, most of them either require a human editor or a human orchestra to bring them to life. The AI usage seems more about saving time than actual melodic creation, for hopefully obvious artistic reasons.

That’s not a bad thing, really. We’re not ready for that particular broom to march.

This concert repeats Sunday at 2:30 p.m. Tickets begin at $20 at pittsburghsymphony.org.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.