Spend enough time on the internet, specifically Twitter, and you’ll find that tribalism is the norm.
There’s a reason certain corners of the website have monikers like “NBA Twitter,” “Film Twitter,” “Politics Twitter,” etc. It’s an easy arena for folks who are passionate about certain topics to engage, debate and maybe even learn something new.
Is that public discourse always handled with respect and civility? No, but on the rare occasions it is, it’s a beautiful thing to behold.
I knew I was doing something right as an entertainment journalist when certain fandoms began finding my tweets without much effort on my end. The increased attention was a little scary at first, but I quickly realized that the vast majority of these folks are genuinely excited when an outsider provides a nugget of new information or just a positive take on their favorite movie, show or celebrity.
As those interactions became more frequent, I started keeping track of the fan bases I came across in the most lovely ways. It’s time to update my list of most sincerely passionate yet slightly terrifying fandoms I've come to know:
1. Harry Styles fans
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) February 14, 2022
2. Dakota Johnson fans
3. “High School Musical: The Musical: The Series” fans
4. Caitriona Balfe fans
5. “Euphoria” fans
Since this week might mark one of the last times I have the pleasure of interacting with one of those groups, I wanted to take a beat and acknowledge all the fun I’ve had with certain Twitter fandoms over the last year-plus.
Read More
‘High School Musical: The Musical: The Series’
My journey into the world of Twitter fandoms really started because I wanted to show I was hip to teenage culture.
It had come to my attention that “High School Musical: The Musical: The Series” on Disney+ was created by Upper St. Clair High School graduate Tim Federle and starred Bethel Park native Joe Serafini. There was so much Pittsburgh in that show that I immediately sought out interviews with our local connections, a quest that culminated in a July 2021 Post-Gazette feature.
During my interview with Federle, he told me that the character of Gina Porter (Sofia Wylie) was named after fellow Pittsburgher Billy Porter. So, I decided to tweet that little nugget out in advance. I had hoped “HSMTMTS” fans would enjoy that factoid, and boy did they.
Just had an awesome chat with @TimFederle, a 1998 Upper St. Clair High graduate and creator of #HighSchoolMusicalTheMusicalTheseries.
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) July 26, 2021
He revealed exclusively to me that the character of Gina Porter, played by Sofia Wylie, is named after none other than "local hero" @theebillyporter
That was my first experience as a full-time pop culture reporter with a fandom flocking to even the smallest morsel of news regarding something they loved. For that, the “HSMTMTS” faithful will always have a special place in my heart.
Harry Styles
This one shouldn’t have surprised me, but I still wasn’t ready for what the Styles faithful had in store for me.
I rarely do music coverage, but I jumped at the chance to review the former One Direction member’s October concert at PPG Paints Arena. I wasn’t well-versed in his discography, so I went on a listening binge one Saturday night prior to the show. The man has an impressive number of bangers, which I tweeted out to the delight of, according to Twitter analytics at least, thousands.
I’m covering the Harry Styles concert at PPG Paints Arena on Thursday, so I just spent the last hour deep-diving into his solo stuff.
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) October 10, 2021
Verdict: Harry Styles kinda rules!!
Just like the “HTMTMTS” crowd, Styles fans seemed to revel in the praise I had heaped on their beloved artist. They came out in droves again earlier this year after I jokingly tweeted about how Styles fans will likely ensure that his upcoming film “Don’t Worry Darling” brings in tons of money.
As someone with some experience with the Harry Styles fandom, I predict #DontWorryDarling will do very well at the box office this fall
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) May 2, 2022
Again, a bunch of tweeters with a shared passion came together to express their appreciation for someone recognizing the object of their affections’ talent. You love to see it.
DC Extended Universe
Some lessons need to be learned the hard way.
Last year, I came across a spoiler for an upcoming Marvel Cinematic Universe film that compelled me to tweet my disdain for anyone who ruins movies before they’re available for public consumption. That tweet contained a mean-spirited joke at the expense of the DCEU film “Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice,” which I immediately regretted after being swarmed by fans who were ready to tear me apart.
It was a situation where I was clearly in the wrong, so I did what I believed to be the responsible thing: I deleted the original tweet and posted a sincere apology. The replies calling for my head almost immediately gave way to ones of admiration for my contrition. It was extremely heartwarming.
Deleted my last tweet because I made a mean joke about a DCEU movie and got rightfully called out for it. Genuinely appreciate the fan bases keeping me honest!
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) October 19, 2021
The DCEU fandom has earned a reputation for being a bit ornery online. As one of them put it in a reply to me: “You don’t have to like our movies. Just have some sort of honest discourse. We got played because of a lot of unfaithful actors. It’s why we lash out.”
Lesson learned: Don’t be a condescending jerk and everything will be OK. That feels like an easy one for all of us to follow — both online and off.
Caitriona Balfe
The catalyst for my original “sincerely passionate yet slightly terrifying fan bases” list was, of all people, “Outlander” and “Belfast” star Caitriona Balfe.
I had just come out of a screening of “Belfast,” the film that went on to earn Kenneth Branagh an Academy Award for best original screenplay and top my list of 2021’s best movies. It clearly resonated with me, and I tweeted about how much I enjoyed it and thought that Balfe’s performance was destined for an Oscar nomination (which she was ultimately robbed of). Her fans, naturally, agreed.
Just saw #Belfast, Kenneth Branagh’s very good and very personal new movie set in 1969 Northern Ireland. It’s basically his “Roma” but with more humor and heart.
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) November 3, 2021
I’m keeping a close eye on this one come Oscars season, especially Caitriona Balfe (“Outlander”) for best actress pic.twitter.com/pdCN2A5sfr
Upon realizing I had just been welcomed with open arms by yet another fandom, I decided to introduce the concept of a passionate yet slightly terrifying fan base to my online audience.
Adding Caitríona Balfe fans to my ever-growing list of most passionate yet slightly terrifying pop-culture fan bases it has been my pleasure to interact with here ????????????
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) November 3, 2021
That experience inspired me to seek out an interview with Balfe, who was the rare celebrity I have gotten to ask directly about their fandoms.
“I sometimes feel like I have a gang of stage moms who are heckling in a very lovely way from the sidelines,” she told me. “It’s a very strange thing but a very lovely thing. It’s really endearing, and they are the loveliest people.”
Can confirm.
Dakota Johnson
If this is where we part, Dakota Johnson fans, it’s been one heck of a ride.
You all have been consistently engaging with my tweets since it was announced last summer that “Cha Cha Real Smooth,” out Friday on AppleTV+, would be filming in the Pittsburgh area. I still sometimes receive notifications on tweets I put out almost a year ago about the former “Fifty Shades of Grey” star.
Whether it was my review of the Johnson-starring Netflix film “The Lost Daughter” or simply tweeting out my initial impressions of “Cha Cha Real Smooth” after I saw it at a JFilm Festival screening in April, the Johnson fandom never missed an opportunity to hang out with me online if I was talking about their queen.
SCOOP: #ChaChaRealSmooth, the Cooper Raiff & Dakota Johnson film that shot in Western PA last summer, will have its Pittsburgh premiere on April 28 as part of @FilmPittsburgh's 2022 JFilm Festival.
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) March 22, 2022
It's about a bar mitzvah party host, so it fits the theme https://t.co/hRkLUBW4Ue
Finally watched “Cha Cha Real Smooth,” writer-director Cooper Raiff’s Pittsburgh-filmed dramedy. Friends: I LOVED IT!!!!!
— Joshua Axelrod (@jaxelburgh) April 29, 2022
It’s what I imagine a modern version of “The Graduate” would be. It’s so sweet, kind & lovely. Dakota Johnson is incredible. It just made me really happy ???? pic.twitter.com/GGJU8U9lWI
As far as I’m concerned, entertainment reporters do what we do for fandoms like this. It’s an honor and a privilege to bring you all one step closer to your favorite person or property, and it’s one I don’t take lightly.
Look out for more “Cha Cha Real Smooth” content later this week, Johnson fans. It’s been a pleasure serving you, and I hope you’ve had as much fun hanging out with me as I have watching you make your girl proud.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.