Sometimes, a movie just screams “Academy Awards contender” from start to finish. That can either mean it’s trying way too hard to make its Oscars ambitions known, or it’s just sincerely that good.
Luckily for “Belfast,” out Friday, it fits snugly into the latter category of an Oscars hopeful that genuinely deserves to be winning golden statues in March 2022. It certainly has all the trappings of something Academy voters tend to eat up between its period setting, black-and-white color palette and, most importantly, writer-director Kenneth Branagh’s willingness to explore such a nation-changing historical event through the lens of his own childhood experiences.
That all could have been a recipe for yet another pretentious piece of obvious Oscar bait, but Branagh was clearly too savvy to ever let “Belfast” devolve into anything less than his uncut version of what his formative years were like as he came of age in the backdrop of a bloody conflict in Belfast, Northern Island. His auteur vision resulted in one of the more well-conceived and well-crafted films of the year — and one that earns its Academy Award aspirations.
Set in the late 1960s, “Belfast” is mainly told from the perspective of Buddy (Jude Hill), a young boy whose carefree innocence is tested by the violence brought on during The Troubles, an approximately 30-year span in Northern Ireland where tensions were constantly erupting between mostly Protestant unionists and mostly Catholic nationalists.
Buddy is part of a Protestant family that includes his mother (Caitriona Balfe), father (Jamie Dornan), older brother (Lewis McAskie), grandmother (Judi Dench) and grandfather (Ciaran Hinds). All they want to do is stay out of the conflict and be left alone. Unfortunately, ordinary issues that arise like difficulties paying bills, health scares and even Buddy’s love woes are exacerbated by the increasing danger of just remaining in the only home they’ve ever known.
The most immediately striking thing about “Belfast” is Branagh’s decision to set most of the film entirely in black and white. That choice invites easy comparisons between “Belfast” and “Roma,” Alfonso Cuaron’s similarly semi-autobiographical film about his upbringing in Mexico City. Both films are in black and white, and the decision to drain out all the colors enhances the experience in both cases by ensuring the focus remains squarely on the characters, not the background.
Read More
Branagh mostly keep’s Buddy’s adolescent hijinks front and center while interspersing them with charming snapshots of familial bonding, disturbing instances of domestic discord caused mainly by financial woes, and bursts of violence that leave the entire community shaken and unsure of how to proceed with their lives. The changes in tone are jarring but add up to a complete portrait of what it was like to strive for anything resembling normalcy during that time.
While the “Roma” comparisons are apt in terms of color palette and deeply personal subject matter, “Belfast” has a bigger heart and contains some genuine and necessary laughs to lighten the mood. The humor may sound out of place in war-torn Northern Ireland, but it’s derived from how real this group of performers and Branagh’s script make this family unit feel. They’re in a perpetual state of worry, but they never forget to enjoy themselves when the opportunity arises.
It’s worth mentioning that “Belfast” is a relatively contained story in that it never strays far from the street on which the family lives or Buddy’s various haunts that are basically limited to school, church and the occasional misadventure around his neighborhood. Keeping the action to such a small radius was a smart move by Branagh, as it reduces a macro conflict to the visceral impacts on human lives it really took.
Enough can’t be said about how the young Hill holds the film together with an impressive mix of precociousness and melancholy when forces beyond his control start directly affecting his happy-go-lucky lifestyle. There’s one scene in particular where Hill reacts to a potential huge development that is heartbreaking in its honesty. Credit to Branagh for trusting him enough to carry so much of the film’s weight, and to Hill for pulling off such a powerhouse performance.
In terms of the adults, Balfe steals every scene she’s in as a wife and mother struggling to keep it together as the situation around her continues to deteriorate. She has the most actorly moments that seem designed for an Oscar reel, which makes her the most likely actor to vie for awards in the near future. Dornan, Dench and Hinds also deliver strong turns, with Hinds standing out the most of that bunch with his stirring combination of pathos and comic relief.
Whether “Belfast” actually gets all the awards-season love it should or not, what Branagh accomplished here should be lauded for putting the viewer squarely in his childhood shoes as he tries to navigate his complicated feelings about that era of his life. Chances are good that “Belfast” will end up being one of the year’s best films, thus making it worthy of every cinephile’s time.
Branagh went for broke with this one, and he succeeded brilliantly.
‘Belfast’
3 1/2 out of 4 stars
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.