Three years after Covid-19 began its worldwide takeover, we’re still grappling with the hangover. “2020: One City, Seven People, and the Year Everything Changed,” Eric Klinenberg’s biography of that watershed year, won’t cure it.

But in detailing why the pandemic was worse than it might have been, Klinenberg mounts an eloquent plea for reason, a factor conspicuously missing from the efforts many governments mounted to combat the virus.

That was especially true in the United States, where the virus began to run its most destructive course during the reign of Donald J. Trump despite Operation Warp Speed, that administration’s vaccination development program.

New York City is the setting of Klinenberg’s narrative. His meticulously-researched book is an attempt to convey the effects of economics, race, politics and misinformation on how the city where he lives, the state and governments in various countries handled this unprecedented crisis.

Advertise with us

“The numbers leave little doubt that New York City suffered more COVID deaths — at least twenty thousand — than any city in the world during 2020,” Klinenberg writes in a chapter underlining the disparities between affluent Manhattan neighborhoods around and below Central Park and poorer ones in the outer boroughs including the Bronx, the city’s poorest and most Black. New York City was Covid-19’s epicenter.

Subtitled “One City, Seven People, and the Year Everything changed,” this disturbing work is a call for thought and planning — and a shaming. Klinenberg, a researcher and professor of social sciences at New York University, tells a factual story, of course. But the unexpectedly moving trick he pulls off — the way he humanizes statistics alternately chilling and numbing — is by writing profiles of seven New Yorkers grappling with the disease, both at work and at home.

Deaths and excess deaths

These include May Lee, an elementary-school principal in Manhattan’s Chinatown who had to deal with pandemic closings and anti-Asian prejudice; Daniel Presti, a Staten Island bar owner and anti-vaxxer who defied state-mandated closings and became a local hero; Nuala O’Doherty, a prosecutor retired from the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office who became a community organizer in Jackson Heights, a particularly crowded section of Queens; and Brandon English, a Black photographer from Atlanta who moved to New York City “to live more intensely, to take risks, do things he wouldn’t do anywhere else.”

The pandemic — and in several cases, the murder that May 25 of George Floyd by Minneapolis police — radicalized many of Klinenberg’s unusually candid and articulate subjects. So did the realization that “essential workers,” mostly people of color, were more likely to die of the disease than the more wealthy they served.

“What I told myself while I was out there in the streets is that COVID is just another in the long run of invisible assailants, potential assailants, against my body, that at least I could wear a mask for COVID,” English muses as he joins a protest following the Floyd murder.

Advertise with us

While Floyd didn’t die of COVID, one might view his as an “excess death,” which the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention defines as “the difference between the observed numbers of deaths in specific time periods and expected numbers of deaths in the same time periods.” By 2023, the pandemic “was responsible for roughly seven million reported deaths, and 20 million excess deaths, worldwide,” Klinenberg recounts. The respective US numbers were more than one million deaths and 1.7 million excess deaths.

Did this country learn from the pandemic? Klinenberg doesn’t sound optimistic. “No matter how poorly suited the nation’s political leaders were for the challenge … there was at least a chance that the pandemic would help the U.S. rediscover its better, more collective self,” he writes in the powerful epilogue. “That did not happen.”

Carlo Wolff is a freelance writer from Cleveland. He recently published “Invisible Soul,” a book about Cleveland’s soul music scene from doo-wop to disco.