Editor’s note: This is the 160th anniversary of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s memorable and haunting poem, “Christmas Bells.” To commemorate the poem and to celebrate the holiday, the Post-Gazette asked two local writers to respond to Longfellow’s verses.
It’s impossible to consider Longfellow’s opening fatalistic perception of the Civil War and not recognize a similar pattern for folks concerned about the relentless warmongering we are experiencing today in the name of power and right to exploitation.
It makes sense that the song ringing out would have felt mocking to him, if not incredibly injurious. Longfellow was a man who knew suffering, loss and grief.
The poem reads like the type of honest conversation people are afraid to have with themselves today. Admissions about the nature of the despair and hatred we observe and maybe even feel at times go by us. The bells and chimes we take in are more often calls to stories and scrolls on our screens — fleeting and unattached to the empathy they should inspire. Longfellow’s “Christmas Bells” sits with those feelings.
The poem swings through its aching mood and allows a reversal of the cheerful veneer we so often insist on during this season before returning to a sense of hope, faith and relief. It is at once a defiance and celebration of holiness, noting the irony of such rampant lack of peace and good will.
As with much of his work, it would be fair to characterize his sentiment here as brave and sobering: a moment wherein the poet uses the occasion and his platform to call attention to hypocrisy, tragedy and a social responsibility to do better. His own son was returning from the Civil War injured. There is quite an emotional pay off to thinking about the beauty of his creativity in this way.
Read More
The influence of his Bostonian forebear, Phillis Wheatley, shines through in the cadence of the work. Her tone and seriousness about God and patriotic duty lilt through Longfellow’s signature lyricism. And just as I get to work thinking about how impressed folks must have been with the contribution he was making, I remember that his son, Charles Longfellow, perhaps influenced by this same sense of bravery and parrhesia, had actually left to fight in the war without telling his father.
Learning of the very real threat of losing his son, via a post-enlistment letter, was likely soul-stirring for the elder Longfellow. That Charles survived was indeed a cause for the poet to dip his pen in a well of spiritual gratitude, while indicting a social system that would rather continue the centuries old tide of murder and oppression than commit to fair labor and racial equity — a canon of cannons.
As this poem approaches its 160th birthday, what can it ring into our current time of goodwill and cheer? What do you hear under the carols of today? Is there a place where you can find Longfellow’s gratitude and sense of hope in your own life? Whose survival has inspired you? And, perhaps more importantly, how can you honor the Charleses in your life?
This is a heavy question for all those with power — from the media to politicians. One must wonder if the hypocrisy of singing about peace and goodwill this holiday season has crossed the minds of the people who can ease the oppression of the workers and soldiers in their midst now.
Of course, most of today’s injustices are not equivalent to the fight against American chattel slavery. Yet still there are so many deserving of the poet’s gaze, like that which Longfellow offers when he “pealed the bells more loud and deep” to find hope beyond despair.
On this anniversary, let’s do that. The years between Longfellow’s pen and ours are not as distant as we may think. Many of us have great-grandparents who were alive during his time. Many of the issues that drove his will for wrong to fail and right to prevail are foundations under the ones we face here and now.
So whether a caroler or someone just contemplating meter and verse, Longfellow’s “Christmas Bells” does and should echo. The poem necessarily calls to us to ask, “What goodwill? What peace on Earth?” Just as it calls us to pray our comrades who fight for justice somehow make it home alive as Charles did. May their work, whether they be journalists or soldiers, move us from being forlorn to being inspired and renewed.
Bernice McDaniels is an artist from Pittsburgh who writes about love.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.