For about two-thirds of its length, I found R.J. Jacobs’ “This is How We End Things” one of the more engrossing and provocative whodunnits of recent months. It’s a dark mystery thriller with an intriguing and original premise. The author is a practicing psychologist in Nashville, and he has set his latest novel not far away in the fictitious college town of Shepard, N.C.
Six graduate students at Dorrance University are researching the psychology of deception, under the instruction of department chairman Joe Lyons, who has devised a study based on deceiving and pressuring the subject until he or she finds it necessary to lie. The methods are controversial and cruel. The point is to learn the nature of lying. Dangerous territory, as it turns out.
The students include Robert, a mild Clark Kent-type who has become the platonic best friend of divorced single mother Scarlett; Britt, a Goth-type expert in analysis and data integration, and her sidekick and sometime boyfriend Chris, an Ivy-League rich guy who manages the cameras and data transcription; Elizabeth, a Farrah Faucet lookalike who happens to be having an affair with the professor; and a new arrival: the just-out-of-law-school Veronica, whose specialty is managing liability. They have their separate secrets, and they know some of the secrets of their fellow students. Each of these characters is vividly drawn, and the author frames the narrative from a multi-point-of-view perspective.
During the experiment, however, things quickly go awry, and the subject — an unstable young undergrad named Tom — becomes violent, only to be subdued by a punch in the face from Chris. Campus cop Patrick King, complacent and close to retirement, sees the skirmish in the psych lab as a big event for this sleepy college town. The next day, however, one member of the group is found murdered, and King cannot manage alone. Local detective Alana Larson joins him, leading the investigation, while Scarlett’s ex-husband Mark, coming to visit their daughter, stays in town to support and protect his former family.
It’s March, Spring Break time, but winter has come late this year, and a snowstorm makes it impossible for anyone still on campus to leave. Larson and King now have an old-school-style closed-room mystery to solve. But Larson has some issues of her own, which include hiding any trace of her own fears and refusing to ask another person for help, no matter how much she may need it.
So far, so good. Author Jacobs has created a great set-up, and there have been enough unexpected twists to keep the reader turning the pages. The development of the plot loses its way, however, as the secrets and lies start to unfold. The surprises are a bit too formulaic: the storm that creates a closed-room setup, a second violent event midway, some unconvincing red herrings, the arrest of a character who is clearly not the killer and a penultimate scene in which a character’s life is threatened by the perp — even though it’s obvious there will be a last-minute rescue.
Still, despite its flaws and formulas, “This is How We End Things” is a good read, succinctly written and short enough for the reader to maintain interest through the creative rough spots. It’s to the author’s credit that I’m now curious as to what will happen to the surviving protagonists after the final page.
Robert Croan is a former classical music writer and senior editor for the Post-Gazette. He is currently a freelance writer and lecturer in Fort Lauderdale.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.