When he describes the state of the Allegheny County Courthouse, Judge Jeffrey A. Manning is blunt.

“It’s a tragedy what this building looks like, and it is because of 40 years of complete neglect by county government,” he said, adding that he tried his first case there in 1973 as a prosecutor with the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office.

For 127 years, attorneys, judges, jurors, witnesses, family members, sheriffs’ deputies and county employees have passed through the building’s doors and sat on its quarter-sawn oak chairs.

There have been improvements, specifically the“ creation of an inviting outdoor courtyard and fountain in 1977, a painstaking restoration of a third-floor courtroom in 1988 and some work on the roof 20 years ago. But ”virtually nothing else has been rehabilitated or brought up to speed with what is necessary in courtrooms,“ Judge Manning said.

Advertise with us

Only two of 15 courtrooms are equipped for audio visual presentations with monitors for jurors “rather than handing jurors a piece of paper,” he said. To deliberate, jurors climb narrow, winding staircases to cramped rooms. In one of two jury rooms above Judge Donna Jo McDaniels’ chambers, the toilet is a former utility closet, complete with a slop sink.

“Citizens come to serve as jurors. I’ve heard dozens of jurors say, ‘This place is a dump,’” Judge Manning said.

Tom Foerster, the late Allegheny County commissioner, hated to spend money on the courts, Judge Manning said, recalling that President Judge Robert E. Dauer twice sued the county and Mr. Foerster just to obtain funding to keep the local justice system operating.

Now, Judge Manning has an ally in county Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald who, he said, “has a real interest in making this place better. He is the only county executive or commissioner in all these years that ever bothered to care.”

Stone arches frame the Vincent Nesbert murals at the Allegheny County Courthouse. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
In the Allegheny County Courthouse, laminated particle board covers the original woodwork behind the bench of Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Last year, Allegheny County hired the local architectural firm of Perfido, Weiskopf Wagstaff + Goettel to survey the building and list its needs in order of priority.

Advertise with us

But you don’t need an architecture degree to see worn woodwork, damaged plaster and cracked ceilings. Holes in the steeply pitched ceramic tile roof allow rain and snow to leak into the building, causing water damage in courtrooms and other spaces, including the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office.

“The rain just comes through,” Judge Manning said. “We have the one courtroom up in the corner that continues to leak water. Every other month there was a leak that made the courtroom unusable for days.”

Consequently, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jill Rangos moved out of courtroom 533 and into courtroom 327.

In her former courtroom, Judge Rangos said, “The concrete pillar behind the bench was so saturated with water that when you poked it with a finger, you could feel the squishiness.”

Freezing temperatures cause icicles to form near the building’s cooling towers; when they melt, water leaks onto lower floors.

Advertise with us

Last October, “a huge leak on the fifth floor went down and inundated the district attorney’s office. The ceiling on the fourth floor came down because of the leak on the fifth floor. They were dragging computers out of the D.A.’s office. It was a disgrace,” Judge Manning said.

Last month, an old toilet on the sixth floor froze, cracked and began leaking water into a fifth-floor jury room, said Harry Lorenzi, the court manager. In the summer, when large windows are open, bats fly through the halls.

Heating and cooling the offices and courtrooms is difficult.

“In the summer, the air conditioning doesn’t work. In the winter, the heat is so noisy you have to turn it off so the jury can hear,” said Judge Manning, who still presides over trials in a third-floor courtroom.

Over the years, the courthouse has been altered in ways that disregard the building’s national historic landmark status, a designation it acquired in 1973.

Advertise with us

One of the worst examples occurred in the 1960s when Judge Samuel Strauss redesigned his third-floor courtroom so that jurors sit in a semi-circle opposite the judge’s bench, rather than beside it. This theater-in-the-round design forces lawyers to turn their backs either to the judge or the jury.

Now, Judge Randal Todd presides in this courtroom, where tall wooden bookcases block off one corner because spectators once sat there and heckled witnesses while they testified. A wall trimmed with wooden slats prevents Judge Todd from seeing who is entering his courtroom, and for him, that is a security concern.

Retired Judge Raymond Novak, now of Pompano Beach, Fla., also heard cases in the theater-in-the-round courtroom.

“It’s a totally modernistic courtroom. I consider it a rape of the facility,” Judge Novak said in a telephone interview.

Later in his career, Judge Novak presided in Courtroom 321, which was restored in 1988 at a cost of $450,000.

Advertise with us
In 1988, Courtroom 321 in the Allegheny County Courthouse was restored at a cost of $450,000, one of the few successful projects in the building, which opened in 1888. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
President Judge Jeffrey Manning looks over the cramped jury deliberation room over the chambers of Judge Donna Jo McDaniel at the Allegheny County Courthouse. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“The beauty and the majesty of that room had an effect on the trial process that was positive. When people walk into that room, they behave differently. They are more quiet. Lawyers tend to act more respectfully to one another,” Judge Novak said.

Judge Manning noted that on the fifth floor, much of Judge Edward Borkowski’s courtroom is lined in the laminated particle board used to remodel game rooms during the 1970s. Behind the particle board is original woodwork. Filled with file cabinets and large water bottles, the courtroom is cramped and has ripped and stained carpeting.

The county courthouse is home to 15 judges. Just a few blocks away on Grant Street stands the U.S. District Courthouse and Post Office, which houses 10 federal judges and was renovated at a cost of $87 million.

“They have Italian marble. I’m not looking for Italian marble. But something better than laminated particle board would be good,” Judge Manning said.

Philadelphia built a criminal justice center and a new juvenile justice center, which, Judge Manning said, “cost the state close to half a billion dollars for those two buildings. Allegheny County, the second largest judicial district, didn’t get a dime.”

“We would be better off with a new building for the courts” that would house criminal, civil and orphans’ court. We really need an entirely new building. We need adequate facilities that will give us the ability to properly do what we need to do. And we don’t have that,” Judge Manning said.