Since moving out of its Pittsburgh Mills location in late 2023, the character masks, costumes, props, and plywood from ScareHouse have been sitting in a storage locker. The local haunted attraction will not open for the 2024 season.
However, ScareHouse hopes to emerge from the shadows once again, and continues its search for a new home. When ScareHouse does make its return, “we just want to make sure that we bring that high-quality experience that we're known for and we just want to make the best show possible,” makeup manager and scenic artist Mollie Himes said.
Pittsburgh Magazine reported on Monday that ScareHouse co-owner Scott Simmons announced the news last week in a private Facebook group comprised of company employees.
ScareHouse closed its last location after Pittsburgh Mills owner, Namdar Realty Group, narrowly avoided a sheriff's sale after paying $11.5 million in delinquent taxes. Prior to its move to Pittsburgh Mills in 2020, the haunted house operated out of an old building in Etna.
ScareHouse began looking for alternate facilities and needed to begin preparations for the Halloween season by March, Himes said. In July, the casting process would have started.
“It just got to the point where a location wasn't able to be found. We would have run out of time because we want to make sure that, whenever we do come back, that we want to make a big impact that ScareHouse is known for,” Himes said.
Attempts to reach ScareHouse co-owners Scott and Wayne Simmons for further information were not returned by press time.
Himes is one of approximately 100 cast and crew members that return each fall to put on the haunted house. She gets goosebumps when she thinks about ScareHouse’s classic attractions like “The Basement” – she’s terrified of haunted houses.
Nevertheless, her love for the job has kept her coming back each fall since 2011 when she applied to be a makeup artist after seeing an advertisement on Craigslist. For the past few years, she has even commuted between State College, where she currently lives, and Pittsburgh on fall weekends to work for ScareHouse.
“It's very much a family and I'm glad to be a part of it,” Himes said.
At the Pittsburgh Mills location, ScareHouse benefited from the other stores around it to create an “indoor shopping experience” where customers could grab dinner, see a movie and shop before going to the haunted house, Himes explained.
Even when neighboring stores started closing amid financial and mall management concerns, Himes said that ScareHouse guests could still pack the mall. “It was crazy to see the mall come to life, even though it was just maybe on that side,” she said.
As ScareHouse continues to explore new locations, they are keeping options open. “We just feel like Pittsburgh is our home and we'd like to stay close to that,” Himes said.
According to Himes, customers are looking for facilities that offer parking, which is more convenient at a location outside of Pittsburgh’s downtown area. Undead Productions, the entity behind ScareHouse, is also behind Bold Escape Rooms in the Strip District.
Despite this season’s closing, ScareHouse’s message to Pittsburghers is hopeful: “I say we'll be back,” said Himes.
“And we're not going away. It's just a ‘See you soon.’”
Elena Eisenstadt: eeisenstadt@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.