Walking through the desolate Pittsburgh Mills mall last week, Ashley Walker remembered what it was like going there with friends when the complex just opened in 2005.

She was a teenager and the mall was the place to be on weekends. “We would go shopping, hit the arcade and play mini golf,” Ms. Walker, who lives in nearby Springdale Township, recalled.

As she got older, Ms. Walker would bring her daughter to the indoor playground.

That’s not the atmosphere these days at the Frazer Township mall. Cars are sparse in the parking lot and overgrown weeds poke through cracks and potholes in the pavement. More than half of the storefronts are empty and the food court is completely vacant — a “ghost town,” said Ms. Walker.

Advertise with us

The impact of the mall’s descent has rippled across the community.

Foodcourt at the Pittsburgh Mills Mall on August 22, 2023. (Ciara McEneany / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Namdar Realty Group, the building’s New York-based owner, is now facing a flood of legal action from local officials and companies trying to recover mounting debts. The company has racked up more than $11 million in unpaid property taxes, arousing the ire of township supervisors. Officials have pursued three cases against the building’s owners since 2021 for tax delinquency, but the company has yet to make payments. If it doesn’t, the property is slated to go to sheriff’s sale in October.

A representative for Namdar said the company is “committed to revitalizing the mall’s tenant mix and creating a vibrant shopping environment.”

“We are actively engaged in discussion with potential new and exciting tenants, and we remain confident in our ability to attract diverse businesses that will enhance the mall’s appeal to the community,” the representative said in an e-mail to the Post-Gazette.

Officials on the ground see a different picture.

Advertise with us

“You have a mall owned by an absentee landlord that is neglecting their financial responsibility, their building and the roads around the entire complex,” said Lori Ziencik, the township’s secretary and treasurer.

Private companies have also piled on.

Vacant JCPenney at the Pittsburgh Mills Mall on August 22, 2023. (Ciara McEneany / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Last year, Colliers Real Estate sued Namdar for failure to pay commission for helping the mall sign a lease with a tenant. A Common Pleas judge instructed Namdar to pay Colliers $290,000.

In June, the Macy’s department store chain sued the mall’s owner for allegedly breaking a longstanding financing agreement. Last week the parties agreed to settle the dispute for $2 million.

Pittsburgh Mills is far from the only struggling mall. Retail centers across the country have weathered a barrage of blows due to the rise of online shopping and closures caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Advertise with us

Floris Van Dijkum, senior research analyst at Compass Point Research in Washington, D.C., said in a report earlier this year that the mall sector is experiencing rising vacancy levels and declining supply as ‘C’ rated malls continue to die slow deaths.

Elsewhere in Allegheny County, Century III Mall — once known for being the third largest shopping center in the world — closed permanently in 2019. After facing a fire, multiple code violations and possible condemnation, the mall is now seen by local officials as a menace to West Mifflin community members and first responders. The mall’s owner, Century III Mall PA LLC, has failed to make repairs even when slapped with hefty fines.

Pittsburgh Mills isn’t abandoned. Shoppers like West Mifflin locals Madison and Charles Haines can still be found there — even on a weekday afternoon.

The couple first came to the mall in 2012, when it had a lot more to offer.

“There were more stores, more people, more everything,” said Mr. Haines.

Advertise with us
The Pittsburgh Mills Mall on August 22, 2023. (Ciara McEneany / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Pittsburgh Mills still has some big name brands such as Bath and Body Works, Macy’s, Dick’s Sporting Goods, Joann Fabrics and Mac Discount. Three phone stores and a collection of smaller retailers selling things like furniture, comic books, and jewelry, round out the shopping options.

Following the trend of other malls, the property has also diversified into non-retail businesses — a gym, a church, and a nursing school all operate out of Pittsburgh Mills.

TJ Buffet and Panera Bread are the only restaurants left.

The Haineses believe the blame for the mall’s condition lies with its management.

When Namdar purchased the mall in 2018, it knew it wasn’t buying a gem. The complex had been struggling financially for years. Namdar paid $11.35 million for the 1.1 million-square-foot building and some vacant commercial land surrounding it. At the time of the purchase, the mall had a 30% vacancy rate.

Advertise with us

Since acquiring the space, the owners have leased over 250,000 square feet that has “contributed to an increase in the overall occupancy rate,” said a representative from Namdar, in an email to the Post-Gazette.

Namdar declined to provide the mall’s current vacancy rate. According to the mall’s website, it now holds fewer than 15 retail stores.

Some of Namdar’s other properties across the state have seen similar hardships. The company owns eight malls in Pennsylvania.

The Chambersburg Mall, located in Franklin County, closed permanently last month after the final tenant moved out.

Namdar decided to close that mall because it had been struggling for a long time, said Michael Ross, president of Franklin County Area Development Corp. The company plans to redevelop the space, he said.

Advertise with us

Namdar is “having conversations with different developers and has sought to engage in master planning to try to develop what we think will be a viable concept plan that would attract investors,” Mr. Ross said.

At the North Hanover Mall in York County, a fire tore through the vacant JCPenney last month. Officials later determined that it was caused by a malfunction in the store’s HVAC system, said Margaret Lewis, Hanover borough manager. The fire lasted three hours, but the space has since been demolished.

“A large portion of the mall has been removed,” she said. As here, renters are few and far between.

Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com; Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com

Correction, posted May 28, 2025: In an earlier version of this story, the owner of the Century III Mall was identified incorrectly.