Owners of the Pittsburgh Mills mall in Frazer were charged with creating a public nuisance Wednesday, weeks after the District Attorney’s Office began looking into the realty group’s alleged failure to take care of massive swaths of dangerous potholes throughout the property.
The single count of making a public nuisance is filed against Pitt Galleria Realty, the limited liability company listed as the direct owners of the property. The LLC is owned by parent company Namdar Realty, which bought the property in 2018 for $11.35 million.
No one answered a phone number listed for Namdar, and the voicemail was full on Wednesday. An email sent to the address listed on Namdar’s website bounced back with a message that the address doesn’t exist.
Allegheny County Councilman Nicholas Futules, whose district includes Frazer, sent a letter to the realty group in February imploring ownership to fix the worsening road situation. The DA’s office became involved after Mr. Futules’ letter went unanswered.
District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.’s office noted Wednesday that “recent events indicate the [company] had the ability to remediate earlier but declined to do so.”
That’s likely in reference to patch work that began last week, work that only started after Mr. Zappala opened an investigation into the property owners, to whom businesses in the mall complex pay a monthly fee that is supposed to go toward road upkeep.
Read More
For example, according to the criminal complaint, Eat’n Park owners pay more than $500 monthly into the fund — more than $41,000 since 2018. Officials with Lowe’s, too, said they pay a monthly fee for road maintenance — about $1,430, detectives wrote.
Township officials have tried in vain to push the company to take care of the roads surrounding the property, ultimately suing the realty group in 2024 and alleging owners weren’t meeting their contractual obligation to maintain the road.
The township estimated it would cost the municipality more than $4 million to repair the problems themselves.
Officials have also taken the company to court three times for millions in unpaid taxes, and the mall was slated to go to a sheriff’s sale in 2023 before Namdar made good on the delinquent taxes at the last minute.
The criminal complaint included testimony from Frazer police Officer Cole Berg, who patrols the Mills property. He said the crater-like potholes cause drivers to swerve in and out of lanes or, sometimes, come to a complete stop amid flowing traffic.
Officer Berg said that since 2021, Frazer police have taken nearly 40 reports about the road conditions, including some 30 flat tires and nine damaged rims. At least nine vehicles required a tow truck, and one motorcycle rider nearly crashed after hitting what the rider described as a 10-inch pothole.
He said the potholes have the potential to damage police cruisers, which would cause a chain reaction of headaches.
“In the event a police patrol vehicle obtains a flat tire from any pothole, not only will our response time be increased, the vehicle will be taken out of service,” Officer Berg wrote, noting that such a scenario diverts officers’ time and attention away from public service.
Ryan Sleminski, chief of Frazer Fire Department 2, said the road conditions have drastically affected their response times to 911 calls at the Mills. He wrote that trucks must often take alternate routes to stay off of the worst of the roads.
“Navigating around these potholes has become increasingly dangerous,” he wrote, “especially when it requires us entering oncoming traffic.”
Mr. Zappala this week said his office had many complaints about the conditions on the roads and concerns about emergency response time were high.
“I got the firefighters out there. They called, you know, they called a lot, and they're like, ‘Hey, man, we can't get into the building’. You know, this is really serious stuff. So the detectives went out. We took a look at it,” he said. “And the emergency guys really have problems responding. Say, somebody has a heart attack or something. It's like time is of the essence, right? They were pretty passionate about that.”
The problem became so bad that the Walmart on Village Center Drive brought in its own contractors last month to fix the section of Pittsburgh Mills Circle that runs behind the adjacent Aldi, according to Mr. Futules, the county councilman representing the area.
“Their delivery people were complaining that there was no way to get up there without tractor trailers going over [the potholes],” he said last week. “They have no way of avoiding them and can’t swerve back and forth like cars. They complained to the point where Walmart was concerned about their deliveries.”
Namdar, according to the complaint, has hired a company called Patch Management to begin repairing the roadway using “the … ‘pothole killer’ hot asphalt spray injection system.” Police Chief Aaron Scott, however, wrote in the complaint that he has seen a “Pothole Jet Patcher” truck in action and suspects it will do little to solve the underlying problem.
“Although I am not an expert on how this … truck operates, it appears to just be spraying stone and tar/oil into these potholes,” he wrote. “Some of the potholes filled … have continued to deteriorate and the potholes continue to expand.
“This stone and tar/oil that the special vehicle is filling into the potholes may fill them for a moment,” he wrote, “but it is not a permanent fix which is necessary for safe travel.”
—Stephana Ocneanu contributed






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.