Steelers coach Mike McCarthy used the first four games of the season to self-scout his offense. It’s an exercise almost every coach does at the quarter point of the season.

The biggest takeaway for McCarthy was the offense’s inability to move the chains on third down. The Steelers have converted just 32% of their third downs, tied for 28th in the NFL.

What puzzles McCarthy most is the Steelers have put themselves in manageable third downs, and they’ve had more trouble converting from shorter distances than longer ones.

“We’re not making the easier ones on third down,” McCarthy lamented. “Third down is our No. 1 focus on offense.”

Advertise with us

And the focus within the focus for the skill position players is winning more against man coverage.

McCarthy noted after last week’s loss in Cleveland that the Browns dictated the terms to the Steelers with their aggressive rush and man coverage across the board.

Steelers wide receivers and tight ends did not win enough of those 1-on-1 opportunities in the first three quarters. Only when Aaron Rodgers heated up and DK Metcalf started to win some of his 1-on-1s in the fourth quarter did the Steelers mount their late comeback.

“We’re not looking at third and 10 or third and 11,” Pat Freiermuth said. “We’re looking at a lot of winnable third-down conversions.”

The tight end said the Steelers just need to “understand and execute our plan.”

Advertise with us

“We’re seeing a lot of man coverage so we have to win our 1-on-1s more consistently for Aaron and be in the right spots,” Freiermuth said. “There is a lot of stuff that is correctable, which is the positive of it.”

Another rookie debut?

Defensive lineman Gabriel Rubio generated a lot of buzz in training camp for his ability as a run stopper. It’s one of the biggest reasons the sixth-round pick out of Notre Dame made the 53-man roster.

On Sunday, he could make his NFL debut with Derrick Harmon out of the lineup.

“I feel very ready,” Rubio said. “I’ve been waiting the past four games for the opportunity to go out there and show out.”

Rubio and fellow rookie Kevin Jobity Jr. have been healthy scratches so far this season. Yahya Black and Sebastian Joseph-Day undoubtedly will have increased roles, but there will be opportunity for Rubio, Jobity or Esezi Otomewo, a veteran who is on the practice squad.

Advertise with us

“We were just told it’s the next-man-up mentality, so we take it to heart,” Rubio said.

Rubio has learned a lot by watching Harmon, Cam Heyward and Keeanu Benton.

“Just from watching, the level of play from the older guys — specifically Cam and Harm — it’s extraordinary how they violently move to the ball all the time,” Rubio said. “That’s something I need to learn from and take after.”

Another CB on the way

Veteran cornerback Terrell Smith was signed off Washington’s practice squad and added to the 53-man roster.

Smith is the second cornerback signed off another team’s practice squad in as many days. Pittsburgh poached veteran Sean Murphy-Bunting from Tampa Bay’s practice squad on Monday.

A fifth-round pick of the Bears in 2023, Smith played in 26 games over his first two NFL seasons in Chicago, with six starts. He suffered a knee injury in training camp last year and did not play in 2025.