CLEVELAND — There were some moments when it appeared the Steelers’ nightmare along Lake Erie would end.

Like when Aaron Rodgers kept hitting deep passes of 48, 28 and 22 yards to DK Metcalf in the fourth quarter.

Like when Rodgers threw for 154 of his 299 yards and two touchdowns in the fourth quarter after the Steelers trailed 21-10.

And like when he threw a 3-yard touchdown to tight end Pat Freiermuth and then did the unthinkable — sneak 1 yard for a two-point conversion — to appear to send the game to overtime.

Advertise with us

But, after all those heroics, after waking up a Thursday night television audience that might have fallen asleep, the Steelers fell prey to the same annoying frustration that accompanies them all too often to Cleveland.

After staging a dramatic rally behind their 42-year-old quarterback, the Steelers still lost to the Cleveland Browns 27-24 when kicker Andre Szmyt kicked a 56-yard field goal with 10 seconds remaining.

“We were one play short,” coach Mike McCarthy said.

And that should come as no surprise.

It was the Steelers’ fifth consecutive loss at Huntington Bank Field and dropped their record in Cleveland to an embarrassing 1-7-1 since 2018.

Advertise with us

What’s more, it continued their doldrums on Thursday nights, where the Steelers have now lost 10 consecutive games against AFC North opponents.

“I thought our guys battled playing from behind,” McCarthy said. “It was a back-and-forth division game, which is what you would expect.”

It has been a series of embarrassments for the Steelers in their personal house of horrors.

Deshaun Watson, who threw for 181 of his 268 yards in the first half, is the fifth different quarterback to beat the Steelers during their five-game losing streak in Cleveland.

But, all by himself, Rodgers almost prevented what always seems to be inevitable on the road against the Browns.

Advertise with us

And he had some help from his favorite — and sometimes beleaguered — target.

Metcalf made any number of big-time catches in the fourth quarter, starting with a 43-yarder that set up a 21-yard touchdown to tight end Darnell Washington.

Two series later, Metcalf caught a perfect 28-yard throw from Rodgers down the left sideline to the Browns 11. That set up the touchdown to Freiermuth and the 1-yard two-point conversion sneak by Rodgers to tie the game with 1:42 remaining.

Metcalf finished with five catches for 115 yards and likely silenced some of the grumblings after his dropped passes and penalties in the first three games.

“Aaron was hitting open receivers, setting us up,” Freiermuth said.

Advertise with us

The offensive display came just in time because the Steelers had done little after scoring on the opening possession for the second game in a row. And they did it in impressive fashion, using 17 plays and nearly 10 minutes off the clock to get a 12-yard touchdown from Roman Wilson on a bump pass from Rodgers.

“That’s the way we need to set the tone on offense and not have the highs and lows,” Freiermuth said. “We made it exciting.”

“That’s the NFL,” McCarthy said. “I thought the environment tonight was outstanding. It’s the best environment I’ve played in in this stadium in my time in the league.”

But, as always, there were the obligatory mistakes by the lake, too.

Rookie cornerback Daylen Everette stepped on the field and immediately got beat for a 61-yard completion, which led to the second touchdown.

Advertise with us

Of all things, kicker Chris Boswell missed his third field goal this season when he hooked a 48-yard attempt that the Browns turned into another touchdown and a 21-7 lead.

But, even though it was early, the game seemed to turn on one play — Rodgers’ first career interception against the Browns on the second possession.

After that, it was an uphill battle in a stadium that has not been kind to the Steelers.