The Steelers, like most of the NFL, made big moves to retool their roster with the opening of the “legal tampering window” Monday in advance of the official start of free agency Wednesday.

In trading for wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. and signing cornerback Jamel Dean, the Steelers added two starters in a matter of hours. Running back Rico Dowdle, another free-agent signee, will replace team MVP Kenneth Gainwell, who signed with Tampa Bay, in the backfield rotation.

So were these big moves the right moves? Here’s a sampling of reaction from observers around the league:

Jamel Dean

• Landing Dean from Tampa Bay earns the Steelers a “B” grade from cbssports.com at a reported three years, $36.75 million, according to the Post-Gazette. “For now I like it, but I am proceeding with caution,” writes CBS’ Zachary Pereles, noting Dean allowed a 34.7 passer rating as the primary defender, tops among qualifying corners in the NFL. Pereles expresses concern, however, with Dean’s age (29) and injury history.

Advertise with us

• Pro Football Focus (PFF) gives the signing a “good” grade, citing Dean’s 80.6 PFF overall grade and 47.7 passer rating when targeted when it says Dean had the best year of his career in 2025. “He should form a formidable perimeter duo next to the ascending Joey Porter Jr.,” PFF writes.

• Dean’s signing gets a lower grade from Bleacher Report with a “C+.” Kristopher Knox says while Dean played at a “high level” in 2025, he’ll turn 30 in October, and Knox questions whether that will still be the case in 2027 or 2028.

Rico Dowdle

• The Athletic gave the Steelers an “A” for getting a “big, physical” back coming off back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons, noting his pass-catching ability and connection to new coach Mike McCarthy from their shared time in Dallas.

• PFF gives the Dowdle signing an “average” grade, noting his 3.12 average yards after contact ranked 12th among qualified running backs last year.

• Bleacher Report grades the move as a “C+,” praising his production in Dallas and Carolina. “The 27-year-old should be firmly in his prime,” writes Knox, while questioning where the signing leaves Kaleb Johnson, a third-round pick in 2025, in the Steelers’ backfield rotation.

Advertise with us

Michael Pittman Jr.

• Fox Sports gives the Steelers an “A” for the Pittman trade. Ben Arthur likes Pittman’s fit in Pittsburgh as a physical receiver who racks up yards after the catch, as well as his reliability in having missed just three games since 2021. “The Steelers desperately needed wide receiver help alongside DK Metcalf and got that in Pittman, a two-time 1,000-yard receiver,” Arthur writes.

• Bleacher Report liked the trade, too, grading it as a “B+” and also saying the Steelers “desperately” needed help for Metcalf. Pittman is a proven veteran, writes Knox, who was made expendable in Indianapolis by the emergence of Alec Pierce. “The Steelers now have a legitimate secondary threat at wide receiver,” Knox says.

• The lowest grade (C) came from theScore.com, which notes that Pittman’s 784 yards receiving last year represented his lowest total since he was a rookie in 2020. “In that sense, this feels like yet another Band-Aid move by an organization that remains in denial of the obvious need to rebuild. The grade has to reflect that,” writes Dan Wilkins.