Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

Marvin P: Good morning Brian from iced-in Dallas. I have a couple of questions for you. Mike McCarthy, the supposed quarterback whisperer, has a 44% winning percentage when he doesn’t have a franchise quarterback under center. He inherited Favre, Rodgers and Dak Prescott. Has he drafted or developed anyone who has remotely resembled a franchise QB? My second question is about whether Art Rooney II is not taking accountability for the quarterback quandary the Steelers are in. This paper reported Art prevented Kevin Colbert from releasing Ben after the 2020 season. More importantly, I believe Art, as the Steelers tone-setter, eschewed finding the quarterback of the future and gambled for a championship when they passed on Lamar Jackson when Ben was 36 and Jalen Hurts when Ben was 38. Those gambles forced the Steelers to reach for Pickett in 2022. I hope they don’t reach for Ty Simpson this year.

Brian: Two questions in one for the mailbag? Does Marvin have to pay extra for this? We’ll cut him a deal because of the ice storm. Not that things are much better up here, but I digress.

First off, it’s an easy argument to make that he inherited Aaron Rodgers, an all-time talent, and Dak Prescott in Dallas. But Rodgers was a ball of clay to mold, more or less, when McCarthy arrived in Green Bay. And Prescott had a career season under him in 2023. It might be even more impressive what McCarthy did when Prescott was out with injuries.

Advertise with us

Cooper Rush went 8-5 as a starter between 2022 and 2024, with 16 touchdowns to seven interceptions in those games. This past season, Rush wound up needing to start two games for Baltimore and was horrendous with zero touchdowns and four interceptions. He got benched for Tyler Huntley. So, yeah, tailoring a game plan to Rush and actually going on a little run is a feather in McCarthy’s cap that only looks more impressive now.

To your second question, I’m not sure I’d say that’s purely an ownership matter. Ben Roethlisberger himself said before his final season that it didn’t always feel like Kevin Colbert wanted him back, in case that’s the reporting you’re referencing. Yes, it did strongly imply that Art Rooney II was in his corner. Mike Tomlin had to be involved in that discussion, too.

At any rate, I’d say it’s more of an overarching issue of being competitive to a fault. It’s an organization that is stubbornly committed to trying to contend every season. You can call that admirable or you can call it myopic.

Michael B: Why not just stay with Mason and end all of the drama which is about to come from the departure mess of Mike T?

Brian: Well, it would be pretty boring, I’ll give you that much, Michael. With all due respect to Mason Rudolph, the Steelers know what they have in him. And everyone involved seems to be laying it on pretty thick about Will Howard, from Rooney to McCarthy to Roethlisberger (who never seems to mention Rudolph, by the way, if you happen to be an avid listener of his thoughts).

Advertise with us

The irony of staying with Rudolph, as you put it, is that it would still give the Steelers their sixth consecutive different starting quarterback to open a season. If you listened to McCarthy’s description of the general archetype of a quarterback who fits his offense, it didn’t sound much like Rudolph.

“You want a more athletic player in that position, a man who can extend plays and play to the rhythm and timing and spacing, all the things that go into the offensive system,” McCarthy said.

Scott E: I have nothing in particular against Arthur Smith, but in what universe does Ryan Day reside that he thinks hiring Smith as the OC is the correct move? Or, alternatively, is the fact that this occurred, plus the fact that Smith was in the conversation for several NFL head coaching positions the most damning statement about the end of the Tomlin regime as there could be?

Brian: I actually think Arthur Smith isn’t a bad hire for Ohio State, but I didn’t see it coming, considering he’s been so entrenched in the pro ranks. Maybe his Steelers contract or even his Falcons contract has offset language that still pays him in full if he takes a job outside the NFL.

On a personal level, I wish Smith well. He was rather impervious to our questions, which could often be rather pointed for a play-caller, and seemed to understand we have a job to do. Nonetheless, Smith is now the fourth consecutive Steelers coordinator, dating to Todd Haley, who did not work in the NFL the following year. That also includes Matt Canada, Randy Fichtner and Keith Butler (who retired). It’s actually five if you want to count 2023 de facto interim offensive coordinator Mike Sullivan, who called the plays after Canada’s firing.

Advertise with us

Chris B: Was McCarthy their guy from the start? It seems off that Rooney would use the loophole in his own rule and have 2 fake interviews to satisfy the rule and almost immediately hire the guy he wants after those have concluded.

Brian: The optics of it aren’t great, but we certainly can’t assume the Steelers gave sham interviews to Brian Flores and Anthony Weaver. Perhaps there are specific reasons those two, along with McCarthy, got the chance to fly in and meet with the Steelers braintrust to discuss the job.

If anything greased the skids for the McCarthy hire, it was probably the timing puzzle of it all. Tomlin’s decision to step down coming between the wild-card round and divisional round put the Steelers in an awkward holding pattern with the Broncos and Seahawks assistants, if they had any interest there, and it wasn’t much easier to deal with Rams or Patriots coaches. But yes, their lack of willingness to wait does make it seem like McCarthy was targeted early.

Mark from Cali: Thank you for the chats. Something happened in Ireland with Rodgers that I thought would, a championship mentality vs. a highly conservative one with Tomlin. Longevity breeds complacency, and Tomlin clearly does NOT coach to his narrative of not living in his fears because the Steelers, since Roethlisberger, simply do not have that championship mentality anymore. To win, they need to change their paradigm from the top. It would seem we need Rodgers more than he needs us! Do you think Rodgers can ultimately reboot the mindset of Tomlin as the three examples of the punt, tush push, and the 4th-and-goal scenarios played out? Seems they are getting closer! Thank you.

Brian: Well, Tomlin is no longer the coach. I can only assume that news has made it out to the West Coast by now. But you’re referring to one of the few signs of friction we ever did see between Tomlin and Rodgers, who was animatedly exhorting his coach to go for it on fourth down in Dublin.

Advertise with us

The Steelers went for it 23 times, up five from 2024. It’s hard to say how much of that is Tomlin making a concerted effort to go for it more, the Pittsburgh Plunge discovery to move the chains, or any Rodgers effect. I don’t know how much the presence of Rodgers can shift the mentality within the coaching staff, now led by his old boss McCarthy, but I don’t know about all this “the Steelers need him more than he needs them” stuff. His mentorship for Howard would be a plus. But I’d just as soon suggest they’d be spinning their wheels at the position again to run it back with Rodgers.