Mike McCarthy comes to the Steelers with 24 years of coaching experience — 18 of those years as a head coach. After coming up as a quarterbacks coach for the Kansas City Chiefs in the 1990s and an offensive coordinator for the New Orleans Saints and the San Francisco 49ers in the early 2000s, he built his legacy coaching franchise quarterbacks to statistical success and a Super Bowl title in 2011.

The impact of his offensive background is highlighted by the four seasons — two each with the Packers and Cowboys — where his offense ranked No. 1 in points scored and the 10 seasons his team had a top-five scoring offense in the NFL.

But in each of his destinations, McCarthy inherited a franchise quarterback — or two. He took over the Packers in 2006 when Brett Favre was in the twilight of his career but still a Pro Bowl quarterback, while Aaron Rodgers was his backup and eventually became the superstar quarterback who’d lead most of McCarthy’s teams.

Even if Rodgers returns to the Steelers for a 22nd season when he’d turn 43 years old, it wouldn’t be the same as having one of the top quarterbacks in his prime the way McCarthy’s had every season he’s been a head coach and 244 of his 288 games as a head coach.

Advertise with us

And in those 44 other contests, McCarthy’s teams went 19-24-1 — a winning percentage of .443. The Steelers under Mike Tomlin went 57-44-1 without Ben Roethlisberger for a winning percentage of .558.

While McCarthy will most certainly be part of the Steelers’ search for a franchise quarterback, he’ll need to make due for at least a year — and maybe more — as the Steelers continue that search.

Here’s a look back at the years McCarthy had to survive time without one of his franchise quarterbacks.

2010 (0-1)

On Dec. 19, 2010, the 8-5 Packers went to Gillette Stadium to face the 11-2 New England Patriots with Aaron Rodgers out because of a concussion from the week before. In stepped Matt Flynn — a seventh-round pick from the 2008 NFL Draft in his third season. He delivered with 251 passing yards, three touchdowns and an interception while also losing a fumble as the Packers lost a close game against one of the top teams in the NFL.

Tom Brady threw a game-winning touchdown to Aaron Hernandez with 7:19 left in the game before the Packers had two drives to retake the lead. Flynn led the Packers to the Patriots’ 15 before he was sacked and turned it over on a fumble.

Advertise with us

The Packers would go on to beat the Steelers in Super Bowl 45 later that season behind an MVP performance from Rodgers.

2011 (1-0)

Flynn got his second start in the regular season finale when McCarthy rested Rodgers with the Packers’ 14-1 record. The Packers won a 45-41 shootout against the Detroit Lions where Flynn threw for six touchdowns — more than Matt Stafford’s five touchdown passes that game — with the last of those being a Jermichael Finley score with 1:10 left in the game.

That would be Flynn’s last start of his first stint with the Packers before he’d be signed away in free agency by the Seattle Seahawks, where he’d eventually be benched for Russell Wilson. But he went out with a bang and secured a three-year, $19.5 million contract.

2013 (2-4-1)

Flynn lost the job to Wilson and was traded from the Seahawks to the Raiders in 2013 before he’d eventually be cut and temporarily signed by the Buffalo Bills. But he ultimately ended up back on the Packers’ roster as a backup in 2013, where he made four starts in place of Scott Tolzein — who had replaced an injured Rodgers.

Before Tolzein, Seneca Wallace filled in for an injured Rodgers and got hurt early in a 27-13 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles. That’s where Tolzein came in and couldn’t lead a comeback win.

Advertise with us

Tolzein lost his first start, 13-27, to the Giants where he threw for 339 passing yards but had no touchdown passes and three interceptions. He’d be benched for Flynn the next game against the Minnesota Vikings where he completed just 7 of 17 passes for 98 yards and had no touchdowns or interceptions.

Flynn stepped into the game down, 20-7, in the third quarter, threw a touchdown pass and helped the Packers come back to end the game in a 26-all tie. He’d make the next four starts and go 2-2 during that stretch, including a 38-31 loss to the Steelers where Cortez Allen returned an interception for a touchdown.

Rodgers would return for the regular-season finale and a 33-28 win against the Chicago Bears to finish the season 8-7-1 and win the NFC North before they lost to the 49ers, 23-20, in the wild-card round of the playoffs.

2017 (3-6)

This would be McCarthy’s second losing season of his career — the first came in Rodgers’ first year as the Packers’ starter in 2008. But in 2017, the Packers fell apart after a 4-1 start. Rodgers suffered an injury that sidelined him for months in Week 6, which led to Brett Hundley making nine starts that season.

Hundley struggled on the season with just nine passing touchdowns and 12 interceptions. His best performance came in a 31-28 loss against the Steelers where he threw three touchdowns and no interceptions.

Advertise with us

Rodgers would return for a game when he lost to the Panthers before he was shut down for the season as the Packers fell to 7-7 and locked out of winning the division because of the losses sustained in his absence.

Hundley returned to lose the final two games of the season when he threw just one touchdown and four interceptions as the Packers finished 7-9.

The next year, the Packers finished 6-9-1 with a full year of Rodgers as the starter. McCarthy was fired after a Week 13 loss while the team was 4-7-1.

2020 (4-7)

McCarthy started his new stint with the Cowboys after taking a year off. But his new job had a rocky start as the franchise quarterback he inherited in Dak Prescott started off with a 2-3 record and was knocked out of a 37-34 win against the New York Giants in Week 5.

In went Andy Dalton, where he finished with a 4-5 record as a starter. His best games came in two contests when he threw three touchdowns each time in a 31-28 road win against the Vikings and a 37-17 win against the Eagles.

Advertise with us

But Dalton also suffered injuries and needed to be replaced midseason. One of those games led to a seventh-year backup in Garrett Gilbert filling in for a start against the Steelers. He’d complete just 55.3% of his passes with a touchdown pass and an interception before the Steelers won 24-19.

Another start was by rookie Ben DiNucci — of Pine-Richland High School — who came to the league with college experience from Pitt and James Madison. DiNucci completed just 52.5% of his passes in a 23-9 loss to the Eagles with just 180 passing yards and no touchdowns.

Dalton returned and led the Cowboys to win three of their final four games, throwing multiple touchdowns in each of those wins before the team’s season ended at 6-10.

2021 (1-0)

McCarthy got a year where he had Prescott healthy for all but one game, which led to Cooper Rush’s first career start. The undrafted fourth-year veteran filled in for a 20-16 comeback win, where he threw a game-winning 5-yard touchdown pass to Amari Cooper with 51 seconds left in the game.

Prescott would return, and the Cowboys finished 12-5 before they were eliminated by the 49ers in the wild-card round.

Advertise with us

2022 (4-1)

This was McCarthy’s best year where he had a backup quarterback play multiple starts. Rush stuck with the Cowboys and had to fill in right away as Prescott was knocked out of the season opener. Though the Cowboys lost that game, Rush rattled off four straight wins where he threw four touchdowns and no interceptions.

He wasn’t asked to do too much in those games as he never threw for more than 235 passing yards or led the offense to score more than 25 points, but he made enough plays and avoided big mistakes.

Rush lost his last start that season in a 26-17 defeat to the Eagles where he three threw interceptions the week before Prescott returned.

But Rush’s effort under McCarthy bought time for Prescott’s return and paved the way for the Cowboys to complete a second straight 12-5 season. They didn’t win the division behind the 14-3 Eagles, but they did beat the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, 31-14, in the playoffs before their season ended again at the hands of the 49ers, 19-12, in the divisional round.

2024 (4-5)

McCarthy enjoyed a third consecutive 12-5 season in 2023 with Prescott not missing a game. But that streak came to a crashing halt as Prescott started the season 3-5 as a starter before he suffered a season-ending injury.

Advertise with us

Prescott did lead the Cowboys to a 20-17 win against the Steelers that included a game-winning touchdown pass to Jalen Tolbert with 20 seconds left in the game.

But after Prescott’s season ended, Rush stepped in again to start eight games, finishing with a 4-4 record. He finished with 12 touchdown passes and five interceptions during the season. But with the season out of reach at 6-10, the Cowboys sat Rush in the regular-season finale — a decision that cost him a $500,000 playing time incentive in his contract — and started the former third overall pick of the 2021 NFL Draft — Trey Lance.

Lance finished the regular season with a 23-19 loss to the Washington Commanders, where he completed 58.8% of his passes for 244 yards, no touchdowns and no interceptions.

The Cowboys finished 7-10 — their second season with double-digit losses under McCarthy — and Jerry Jones fired him after the season.

Finding his guy

McCarthy’s record with backup quarterbacks never includes a player his team drafted with the purpose to be the future franchise quarterback. That’s an important factor that will be unique for the Steelers in 2026 in McCarthy’s first season.

Advertise with us

If the Steelers make an effort to draft a quarterback like Alabama’s Ty Simpson, it would give McCarthy the first quarterback he’d be part of drafting and developing into the NFL. But if the Steelers deem this to not be the year to take an early shot at quarterback in the NFL Draft, McCarthy will need to win with Mason Rudolph, Will Howard, and/or another free agent or rookie selected in the later rounds of the draft.

The former means McCarthy gets a say in who he can try to make the fourth franchise quarterback he’s coached in what will be his 19th season as a head coach. The latter means it will be the first year McCarthy hasn’t had such a signal-caller on his roster, and he’ll have to survive with backups for a whole season.

Out of the years McCarthy had to coach multiple games without a franchise quarterback, only his 2022 season with the Cowboys ended with a winning record during those games. In four of his five seasons when he didn’t get to double-digit wins — 2013, 2017, 2020 and 2024 — his losing records with his backup quarterbacks all played big factors.