Steelers insider Ray Fittipaldo grades each aspect of the Steelers’ 30-6 loss against the Houston Texans in the wild-card round of the NFL playoffs:
Quarterback
If this was the final game of Aaron Rodgers’ illustrious career, it was one to forget. After leading the Steelers to a thrilling comeback win over the Ravens to get into the playoffs, Rodgers could not solve the top-ranked Texans defense. He was 17 for 33 for 146 yards and could not lead the Steelers to a touchdown. He was able to hit some throws early, but as soon as the Steelers fell behind, the Texans were able to unleash their pass rushers upon him. Rodgers was the victim of a few drops, but he had to find a way to score a touchdown after one of those turnovers when the game was still within reach.
Grade: F
Running backs
The Steelers had to abandon the running game when they fell behind, so Jaylen Warren and Kenneth Gainwell could not make an impact on the game. Warren ripped off a 10-yard run on his first carry of the game, but he only had 33 yards on his final 11 carries. Gainwell had 20 yards rushing and 26 receiving, well below his season averages in both categories. It’s not that they played terribly, but the offense’s ineffectiveness overall did not allow them to make many plays in this game.
Grade: C
Receivers
DK Metcalf’s drop late in the first quarter was a huge play in the game. Had he caught the pass, the Steelers would have been in Houston territory with a chance to go up 6-0 or 10-0. Instead, the Steelers had to punt two plays later. The Texans took advantage of the miscue and drove 92 yards to take a 7-3 lead. Metcalf, who missed the final two games of the regular season while serving an NFL suspension, also missed a block on first down after a Houston turnover. The Steelers went backward and had to settle for a field goal. Metcalf, who is on the books for a $31 million cap hit next season, seems more like a No. 2 than a No. 1 receiver, which makes landing a running mate for him high in the draft a top priority in a few months. The offense is desperate for playmakers.
Read More
Grade: F
Offensive line
The tackles were put in some difficult positions, having to protect in long downs and distances, but Dylan Cook and Troy Fautanu each gave up big sacks. Will Anderson Jr.’s strip sack, when he zoomed past Cook with an outside move, led to a Sheldon Rankins fumble return for a touchdown that put the game on ice.
Grade: C-
Defensive line
Keeanu Benton and Derrick Harmon registered sacks and Yahya Black recovered a fumble, but the run defense wasn’t up to snuff. The line has to take some responsibility for that. Cam Heyward had a terrific season, but he only had three tackles.
Harmon and Black injected some life into this unit, but the coaches have to figure out over the offseason if the run-defense issues are rooted in scheme or players getting out of position. You’re not going to have a good defense if you can’t stop the run, especially in the playoffs.
Grade: C
Linebackers
Jack Sawyer had a strip sack of C.J. Stroud early in the game, but that was the only sack from a Steelers outside linebacker. T.J. Watt did have six tackles and a fumble recovery, but Alex Highsmith was quiet and only recorded one tackle. Inside linebacker Patrick Queen led the Steelers with 10 tackles, but the Texans had way too many successful runs in the middle of the defense.
Grade: C-
Secondary
The Achilles’ heel for the defense this season was giving up big plays. Receivers running wide open 5 yards behind safeties became the norm late in the season. Losing DeShon Elliott in October certainly hurt the secondary, but one player should not cause the defense to fall apart. Christian Kirk had eight catches for 144 yards, including a 46-yarder on 3rd-and-15 that was the tipping point in the game. If receiver is the No. 1 need for the Steelers in the draft, help for the defensive backfield isn’t far behind. The Steelers need better safeties and corners if they’re going to return to being a top defense. Joey Porter Jr. was the only defensive back to have a good season and he played well again against the Texans.
Grade: D
Special teams
Chris Boswell kicked two field goals to improve to 19 for 19 in the playoffs in his career. Corliss Waitman was excellent, too, pinning the Texans inside their 20-yard line on four occasions. Gainwell had four returns for 100 yards, as well. The special teams did their job. The only thing they could have done better was score because the offense wasn’t going to against the Houston defense.
Grade: B
Coaching
The Texans have the best defense in the NFL, but offensive coordinator Arthur Smith had to do a better job of calling plays, especially after the turnovers. What ever happened to going for the jugular after a turnover? After the Black fumble recovery near midfield, Smith called for a Warren run that went for no gain. After the Watt fumble recovery at the Houston 21, he called for a Gainwell run that lost 3 yards.
Tight end Pat Freiermuth might be the second-best receiving option on the roster and he was ignored until the game was well out of hand. Smith and Rodgers not targeting Freiermuth or involving him in the game plans is one of the biggest head scratchers of the season. And for what? To get Jonnu Smith involved? That was as bad as force feeding Cordarrelle Patterson into the offense last season.
As for the defensive play calling, Teryl Austin and Mike Tomlin never did figure out why the Steelers gave up so many 3rd-and-longs all season. It was a problem early in the year and it remained a problem on Monday night. The Texans converted a 3rd-and-15 with a 49-yard pass to Kirk early in the fourth quarter to set up a 51-yard field goal that gave them a 10-6 lead. The Texans converted 10 of 15 third downs, while the Steelers were 2 for 14. That’s the game right there.
Grade: F





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.