Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Sean M: Hello Brian. Hope is not a strategy. I think the Khan Artist and HC Mike Tomlin took a big gamble when they built the 2025 version of the Steelers and knew it. Throw “all in” on a bunch of older “pedigree guys” to fill the huge holes in your roster and hope it comes together for at least one playoff win. In the end, a hastily and poorly constructed roster simply isn’t matching up with the good teams in the league. It isn’t meshing. Bad attitudes, selfish play, finger-pointing, etc. Can this group of coaches and players forget about the “Steelers Mystique,” admit their problems and find some answers? Or is hope all they have at this point?
Brian: Hey Sean. First of all, I never agreed with the outside notion that Omar Khan, Mike Tomlin and Co. were “all in” on the 2025 season. Not with the way they handled free agency (sit out the frenzy and sign players who were cut) or the ensuing months (trading Minkah Fitzpatrick, not making a trade to replace George Pickens).
But that doesn’t necessarily mean they made good evaluations within the parameters of their approach. Darius Slay and Juan Thornhill were cut from their previous teams, and it didn’t take long to see why. Robert Woods was a complete nothing signing, in between the draft and trading Pickens.
Tomlin was asked about the Slay signing at league meetings in March and acknowledged that they’ve done short-term business at cornerback before with older players, which made them comfortable. Why? Patrick Peterson was not an example to follow in that regard.
As for Woods, when Tomlin described him early in training camp, he called him a professional whose “resume speaks for itself.” That’s basically what he continually said about Aaron Rodgers, too, upon the starting quarterback’s arrival.
Read More
The back of a player’s trading card and the accolades section of his Wikipedia page are fun to peruse, but they can’t be the primary factors in an acquisition. At least not if you want to be a forward-thinking team, and no one has accused the Steelers of being that in quite some time.
Lastly, though, I’ll address Sean’s allegation of bad attitudes, selfish play and finger-pointing. Bad attitudes? Maybe with us in the media sometimes, but I don’t know about that in team settings (unless, of course, Rodgers was specifically accusing one or more pass-catchers of skipping meetings and film sessions). Selfish play? No, not when the likes of DK Metcalf, Pat Freiermuth, Jonnu Smith and others are suffering through career-worst seasons but avoiding Pickens-esque crash-outs on the sideline. Finger-pointing? Yeah, now that one, you could say there’s been some of that.
Bruce B: I like Mike Tomlin as a coach, and have defended him repeatedly over the years. However, is it possible that he is a good head coach, but that the NFL has become so specialized in most position groups/formations/plays, etc. that he can no longer effectively wear so many hats? He needs to hire people with expertise in those specialized areas and empower them to do their jobs. He might still be the smartest person in the room, but that does not equate to being the most knowledgeable in every area.
Brian: You might be on to something, Bruce. Because we can talk until we’re blue in the face — fans, writers, former players, anyone — about whether Tomlin should be fired. It’s a reasonable discussion. But none of us are making that decision.
The next step there is exploring what the Steelers should do or how they should proceed if Tomlin does return, unthinkable as that may be to many. I’ve gotten into this in my chat on several occasions, but your question drills down to the crux of the idea. In a nice way, take some responsibilities off of his plate. In a ruthless way, strip him of some power.
Now that doesn’t mean making him a figurehead. But look at John Harbaugh in Baltimore. What’s his specialty? He’s not an offensive or defensive guy by trade. He was a special teams coordinator who now delegates just about everything while being the CEO-type head coach. Same goes for his brother Jim, who has a venerable offensive coordinator in Greg Roman and an up-and-coming defensive coordinator in Jesse Minter.
Sure, Tomlin has two veterans in Arthur Smith and Teryl Austin. The former is effectively the head coach for the offense. The latter, though, is coaching within the framework of Tomlin’s defensive philosophy. Perhaps it’s time to completely revamp that side of the ball, hire whomever it takes to do that and let that person bring in as many assistants as it takes — with Tomlin taking a step back. Of course, then you’ll have the readers who write in and say Tomlin does nothing during the games, so we often end up going around in circles on these subjects.
Andy M: I know the rhetoric - the Steelers would NEVER fire Mike Tomlin, etc. etc. — but help me understand why he has this lifetime pass with the team. He won a Super Bowl almost 20 years ago, went to another 15 years ago, and the team has significantly underachieved in the interim (no playoffs in 2009, 2012, 2013, 2018, 2019, 2022, one and done in 2007, 2011, 2014, 2017, 2020, 2021, 2023, 2024). I think we now have a very clear perspective on those early teams being Cowher's coaches and players, and obviously Tomlin has an inability to bring in quality coaches or an unwillingness to let them succeed. Yes, he won a superbowl...so did Brian Billick and Doug Pederson, and they were swiftly shown the door after a modicum of the mediocre years that Tomlin has had. Help me make sense of it beyond "that's how the Rooney's operate".
Brian: Well, that is how this organization operates, so there’s not a ton of depth to it beyond that to make sense of, Andy. But if we want to try, Brian Billick won six and five games in two his last three seasons. Doug Pederson went 4-11-1 in his final year in Philadelphia.
Say what you will about the current state of the Steelers at 6-6. They simply haven’t bottomed-out to that degree under Tomlin, which doesn’t exactly move the meter as far as high-end success, but it could explain the exceeding patience from his bosses and the length of his tenure.
Also, I just never get down with the criticism of winning with Bill Cowher’s players and coaches. Tomlin didn’t hire or sign a lot of them. That’s a fact, and surely there’s nuance to that conversation. But do you want to trade in that Super Bowl XLIII victory and the memories of it because the man who presided over it got the absolute most out of a foundation he inherited? Tomlin still had to coach, lead, set the agenda and steer the ship through some tumultuous times back then.
Joel C: It seems to me the Steelers have two urgent needs that are incompatible: using draft capital to trade up in the 2026 draft to get a legit quarterback with QB1 potential and using the multiple picks they have accumulated to completely revamp the roster. Given the dismal state of the team, which approach should they take? Thanks to you and your colleagues for all your great work on the Steelers.
Brian: This is sort of the same kind of competing logic as wanting the coach to do more but also less. If the talent is so bad, then maybe it’s not so much a coaching problem. Maybe it’s a roster-building problem.
The dilemma Joel brings up is basically the one that arises for the league’s worst teams year in and year out at draft time. So, in a word — or two words — it depends. To me, if you think there’s a quarterback prospect too good to pass up and you’re within range of drafting him, you do it.
I still believe this upcoming draft has that potential. The pool is whittled down a bit from what we expected, but different names have popped up in an encouraging way. And keep in mind, not every quarterback prospect needs to be a great fit for the Steelers, specifically, but the more options there are for other teams, the better. That can work out in the Steelers’ favor, too, so that it’s not every franchise trying to furiously trade up for one promising quarterback.
Andrew G: So, it's Armageddon Week in the Steel City. As I write this, you'll be dreading your upcoming Steelers chat, and the inevitable firehose of 'Fire Tomlin' questions. But from this vantage point in far-away Australia (where I admittedly can't access the kind of granular Steelers info a local gets) the problem goes deeper than that. I know a certain family is untouchable in the eyes of many, but I pose one question: would Dan Rooney (as opposed to Art II and, yes, The Chief back in the bad old days) have let it sink to this point? Would Matt Canada have lasted as long as he did, would locker room malcontents have been allowed to linger, would seemingly unilateral drafting decisions (by a head coach whose talent evaluation record is patchy at best) have gone ahead, seemingly unchecked?
Again, I'm just a fan from the other side of the planet. Am I on the money, or close to it? If I'm wrong, please point out where. It took the Steelers 40 barren years (1933-72) to emerge as a powerhouse. I fear another dark age of about the same length is upon us.
On a brighter note, love your work.
Brian: Had to pare down Andrew’s note a little, but I can’t let a letter from Australia go unprinted. He put too much Vegemite into that rant to ignore.
And I actually just kicked this around with the great Ed Bouchette on Chipped Ham & Football this week. If you want to hear Ed’s perspective, check it out.
From my point of view, there are areas in which you can criticize Art Rooney II, and I have. The size of the coaching staff, and thus their ability to do their jobs (in my opinion) is a big one. There’s no salary cap on coaches. The players themselves have spoken loud and clear via the NFLPA report cards, which aren’t the be-all end-all, but I subscribe to the theory that good working conditions can have a positive impact on any team. The Tomlin situation is different because the Steelers are paying him good money. It’s not as if they’re keeping him around because he’s cheap. That they still have faith in him to do the job at a relatively high level is more of questionable decision-making than blatant malaise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.