Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent contest. These grades reflect the impact the players made on the game. While all players are considered for grades, players not named are considered to have neutral grades, where they either didn’t make a major impact on the result of the game or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.
The Steelers’ 26-7 loss to the Bills on Sunday at Acrisure Stadium saw little go right for the team outside of its pass defense, with some of the worst grades for some of the team’s highest-pedigree players:
⭐⭐⭐ (Elite performance)
None
⭐⭐ (Exceptionally good game — or multiple vital plays)
CB Brandin Echols
Not only did Echols record an early interception when he baited Josh Allen into a bad throw, but he was targeted five times — most on the team — and only allowed a single 4-yard reception. He also broke up a pass on third down. The Steelers defense got shredded on the ground, but it did limit Allen to just 15 completions on 23 attempts for 123 passing yards.
⭐ (Solid performance — or made a big play without a costly play)
RBs Jaylen Warren, Kenneth Gainwell
Read More
Gainwell averaged the most yards per carry on the team, with five rushes for 20 yards, and his one-handed reception that led to a 17-yard catch and run was one of the best plays of the game for the offense. It also set up Warren’s 1-yard touchdown run that gave the Steelers a 7-0 lead in the second quarter.
WR DK Metcalf
When actually given a chance, Metcalf made the plays he could. Three catches on five targets for 32 yards isn’t anything special, but he also got open several times and needed more targets on those opportunities.
TE Darnell Washington
Washington led the team with 45 yards on two receptions. His 26-yard leaping catch over the middle was the longest play of the game for the offense and another sign he needs to get more targets in the offense.
OL Isaac Seumalo
Seumalo was the best of the Steelers offensive line in an up-and-down day. The pass protection held up for the most part outside of the one sack it allowed, but that wasn’t on Seumalo. He was also the team’s best run blocker on the day.
LBs Nick Herbig, Patrick Queen
Herbig led the team with three pressures and had two tackles for loss, one of which was a forced fumble that set up the offense’s only touchdown drive. Queen recovered the fumble and had six tackles before he left the game due to injury. Two of his tackles were important stops on swing passes to James Cook in space that kept the Bills’ drives in check. After Queen left the game, the Bills scored all 19 of their offensive points.
CB Joey Porter Jr.
Porter allowed two receptions on three targets for just 17 yards and consistently took the Bills’ top receiving options away from Allen. He could’ve been better against the run, but his work in coverage has made impressive progress over the past two months.
K Chris Boswell
Made his only extra point and put all of his kickoffs in position. Nothing spectacular, but his consistency to put kickoffs in the landing zone at an advantageous spot is notable.
Notable neutrals
These are players who aren’t given a star or a skull because they either didn’t impact the game in a significantly good or bad way — or they did but in a way that balanced out the good with the bad. Here, I’ll note players who classified for the latter category:
OLs Andrus Peat, Zach Frazier, Mason McCormick
Peat wasn’t much of an asset in the run game, but he also allowed zero pressures in his fill-in start for Broderick Jones. Frazier also didn’t allow any pressures but couldn’t get much of a push up the middle for the run game to open up. McCormick did allow the only sack on the day, but it came on a play when he initially blocked Joey Bosa long enough for Aaron Rodgers to get rid of the ball and played well enough on other snaps to balance out his play.
WR Roman Wilson
That Wilson doesn’t lose his cool when he doesn’t get targets or accurately thrown passes his way is a good sign of his character. But that’s not why he’s here. He gets open at a considerable rate. Watch the tape, and you’ll see him beat his man off the line of scrimmage enough that it’s baffling he hasn’t gotten more big-play opportunities from the Steelers quarterbacks. Even when he’s been targeted, the passes have been poorly thrown.
DL Cam Heyward
On a day when the defense got shredded, Heyward was not a culprit on most — if any — of the Bills’ eight explosive runs. He also tied Herbig with two tackles for loss and regularly won his gap against the run. Doesn’t get any points in his favor on a day when the Bills rushed for the most yards of any opponent in Acrisure Stadium history, but it’s important to note he’s not the problem on film.
💀 (Mildly poor performance — or made a key mistake without redemption)
OL Troy Fautanu
Officially tagged with two pressures allowed and on some plays, he let his man get loose, but they didn’t get charted by Pro Football Focus. Wasn’t terrible but wasn’t good either.
WR Calvin Austin III
Austin was blanketed in coverage for most of the night and missed some blocks in the run game that could’ve been helpful. Not a bad game, but he might want to sharpen up soon before Wilson definitively becomes the preferred option over him.
DL Brodric Martin-Rhodes
Defensive tackle elevated from the practice squad was limited to 10 snaps but wasn’t much use in them.
LBs Payton Wilson, Malik Harrison
Not the biggest culprits in the run defense but didn’t make some important tackles that were needed from them in space. Was a noticeable difference with Wilson at the green dot compared to Queen. Harrison missed a tackle and looked out of alignment on several plays.
CB James Pierre
Not terrible in coverage but also was more of a liability against the run game. He missed two tackles and failed to make a single tackle against the run.
💀💀 (Bad overall game — or multiple critical mistakes in costly moments)
P Corliss Waitman
Another bad showing from Waitman, as he averaged just 40.3 yards on four punts. He did have one that went 51 yards but still had some bad punts that put the Steelers defense in tough spots.
💀💀💀 (Terrible performance, major hindrance to team/game plan)
QBs Aaron Rodgers, Mason Rudolph
The Steelers had the game mostly contained 7-3 before their quarterbacks fueled the Bills’ second-half surge. Rodgers failed to get rid of the ball on a play-action pass when he had time to course correct from his initial read, and that led to Bosa’s sack/fumble that was returned for a touchdown. Rodgers also missed several open opportunities, both in his ball placement and in his processing of the field. Metcalf and Roman Wilson especially are getting open and not being rewarded for it. That has to change.
Rudolph was in the game for three passes, one of which was a skipped throw to a wide-open Metcalf, and another was a terribly thrown interception into triple coverage.
TE Jonnu Smith
Smith’s liabilities in the run game have become a major problem as a blocker to the point that it’s becoming a mistake to have him in position to block for Warren or Gainwell in the first place. Not only that, but he’s not gotten open nearly enough or taken advantage of the catchable balls thrown his way to justify him getting snaps over Pat Freiermuth. Several run plays had correct alignments and good blocking across the board — save for Smith either not blocking his man or getting completely blown up.
DLs Keeanu Benton, Yahya Black, Esezi Otomewo
Upon my first review of the game, it was clear these three of the Steelers’ younger defensive linemen got beaten at the point of attack on a regular basis Sunday. But the more you watch, the more you also see that even when they didn’t get blown out of their gaps, they often weren’t occupying the right gaps for the various run fits the Steelers called.
This led to linebackers getting crushed by offensive linemen who got past them clean and wide-open rushing lanes for the Bills. Black and Otomewo make sense as young players, but this was a disappointing showing for Benton, who had arguably played his best month of football for the Steelers in the weeks leading up to this game.
LB T.J. Watt
There have been times when Watt has been double teamed and triple teamed in games and it wasn’t his fault for not being a productive playmaker in the defense. Sunday was not one of those times.
The Bills left Watt in one-on-one matchups on several plays when he didn’t get loose from a block to make a play against the run or pass. Sometimes they ran right at his gap with a single tight end blocking him — something that used to be a guaranteed run stuff — but Watt couldn’t make the play. He even had a play when he was unblocked and had a clean shot at a sack on Allen but whiffed on the opportunity.
Sunday might’ve been the worst we’ve seen Watt play in his nine-year career. If it’s a sign of things to come, it could be a terrible omen for the defense.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.