Brian Batko: Morning everyone, I'm still in Chicago but ready to chat Steelers-Bears. Good to see you.

Pittfan: Hi Brian. I'm just not a fan of this coaching staff and it all falls on Tomlin. Austin is a puppet and Smith's offense is what got him run out of Atlanta. Smith made his name on the back (and legs) of Derrick Henry and a phenomenal year by Tannehill. I don't dislike Tomlin the person but he's not the right coach for today's NFL. Ben Johnson ran circles around him yesterday. There's really no question in there but I would like your opinion.

Brian Batko: Guess I'll just go point by point. Calling Teryl Austin a puppet is a bit harsh, but yeah, it's not looking good for him either way. Arthur Smith had brutal QBs in Atlanta but the offenses were quite explosive, run and pass, when he was with the Titans. I generally don't knock coordinators for having good players. I praise them for either getting them the ball or helping to put them in good situations.

Land of Nod: This team is quite a dysfunctional group. Week 12, still seeing pre-snap penalties such as illegal formation (no WR covering the tackle). How does that happen at this stage (after HS football, college football, + NFL experiences)? Please tell me they didn’t “practice” an illegal set up? Anyhow, that’s just one play that made me crazy. Jet sweeps to TE’s seem like a great idea… we should do that more (eye roll). Was Connor waiting for 80 to pick him up and carry him forward? Is it just me, or could 88 be a pro bowler elsewhere? He should be begging the front office to trade him to a place that accepts the existence of the area of field Pittsburgh dooms as the “middle”. So it goes another year under the Tomlin regime.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: That illegal formation penalty on Calvin Austin was a major error and a huge mistake. He knows that. But that doesn't change that Austin has been in a rut lately. And Jonnu Smith is a great veteran presence to have around but at this point, the more I see, he needs to be a straight backup to Pat Freiermuth rather than someone rotating with him. He played one more snap again yesterday than Freiermuth.

DB from NC: Two things. First, for the life of me I don't understand why Tomlin did not challenge the spot on the tush push, 4th & 1 call. It was less than yard and Warren easily advanced enough to make it. Spencer Anderson was a wrecking machine as a FB. It was one of the most productive days running that I can remember in a while. But yet we shy away from what's successful. All that to say, it's NOT lack of talent on this team that is holding it back. It's LACK of coaching and it's disheartening to say the least.

Brian Batko: Turnovers on downs are subject to automatic review, so that's why on that. I'm not sure they were THAT dominant on the ground, DB. Sure they finished with 5.2 per carry but 55 of those came on the fake TE sneak, which to me is different than lining up and running it at someone efficiently and effectively. Take out that play (which was a great call and great coaching move) and they rushed for 3.7 yards per carry.

Zamo: Hey BB. Really frustrated bud. Tomlin and mustache absolutely REFUSE to use the middle of the field and it’s been this way for years. It’s an offensive league. Bears were without their entire linebacking crew and yet, we somehow have 4 TE’s that never get schemed open? This offense “lives in their fears”. Hate to say but to

Zamo: second, this defense just cannot get a stop when it matters most. They did get the one at the very end but that was just terrible play calling and decisions by the bears. Hope you have a great thanksgiving!

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: You too Zamo. We've seen Rodgers go over the middle at times, but there's no denying this offense and specifically the passing attack has looked largely the same for the last 3-4 years regardless of QB, OC, etc. I think there are opportunities where guys are open over the middle - not quite DJ Moore-level open, alas - and the QB either doesn't see it or doesn't pull the trigger.

MikeM65 in Florida: I watched the game in a bar and didn't have audio. The tush push (I like Steelers' Steamroll) play where the Steelers didn't make it looked like they did make it from the overhead camera and it looked like the forward progress wasn't stopped. Did a whistle blow? Did they rule forward progress was stopped? Could the spot have been reviewed?

Brian Batko: It's an automatic review now for turnovers on downs, but I agree that it looked like they got it on the second effort. Then again, as someone who's kind of anti-tush push, I don't mind if the refs officiate it in a way where you better get it and get it comfortably if you're gonna rely on that play. Zach Frazier explained postgame that they just weren't in the right rhythm with the setup, snap, etc. on that one.

79 Buccos: Players get evaluated, traded, released or earn another contract. Do the Rooneys evaluate the coaches? I know they must, but we hear nothing about it. Is this common for other owners/teams?

Brian Batko: Well yeah, of course they do. The head man, at least, and then they entrust him with evaluations of his assistants. In some organizations the GM also evaluates the coaches, but we know how coach-centric the Steelers are historically.

Advertise with us

Yates: on last Steelers drive did 14 or 30 get any snaps? Inarguably they are the most explosive pass catchers the Steelers have on team? And why does Mason or Steelers coaches think Metcalf is a good target on 50 50 balls? No evidence of that.

Brian Batko: Yes, Kenny Gainwell was out there. Sometimes lined up out wide, other times in the backfield. Interesting thought on using Warren on that drive though. They've been very rigid with his utilization, and that hurry-up offense situation was no different. As for DK Metcalf, I still view him as an elite receiver, but he's not been great lately. Feels like he was making some contested catches early in the season and then turned into a rich man's Chase Clay pool.

409Joe: BB, thought I'd ask someone with true football knowledge (that would be you) because I honestly don't know the theory or philosophy behind it: who cares if the tackle isn't covered? Like, does it really make a difference to the defense if an WR isn't on the LOS?? I wasn't impressed with my google results.

Brian Batko: Haha I had the same thought actually. It's a very pedantic aspect of football isn't it? But I suppose it's more of a slippery slope thing where you need to enforce certain pre-snap rules to prevent offenses from going way overboard in formations to trick a defense.

Brian Batko: To put it in terms of another sport, I guess it's kind of like asking why does the inbounder really need to have both feet behind the line in basketball when they pass it in? It doesn't make a difference 94 feet from the hoop, but it's a rule to maintain order.

Advertise with us

NY Steel: Why were all the pass plays on the last 2 drives so short? Why not try more plays 10-15 yards down field particularly when teh Bears had injuries in the middle of their defense

Brian Batko: That's not entirely true, NY Steel. There was a deep shot to Roman Wilson incomplete. And then obviously the Bears were trying to keep it in front of them at that point and Rudolph was trying to take what the defense gave him. To me, that's where it's really helpful to have a QB with more mobility and playmaking juice than Rudolph (or even Rodgers at this stage, for that matter).

Takoma Tom: Coach T is Chuck Noll at the end of his tenure.

Brian Batko: Chuck Noll went 7-9, 6-10 and 5-11 in three of his final seven seasons so we'll see about that. Not really right now.

Mike in Virginia: Do you think this defense has such a hard time covering the middle of the field because they don't know teams are legally allowed to throw there?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Touche, Mike.

Maryann: Hi Brian, This rollercoaster of a team is just so frustrating on many levels. Our coaching is old meaning no good scheming , no excitement etc…. Myles Garrett was moved all over the field yesterday but TJ just takes the same stance in the same place. It’s like Tomlin is “ my way or the highway”. We can’t continue this for TJ or Cam to win. We need to revamp in areas so the fans paying can get a good product on the field. Maybe I’ll eat my words when we unleash hell in December….

Brian Batko: Maybe! Nothing would really surprise me with the Steelers as long as it falls between (losing season) and (playoff win). And I beat this drum every so often, but in my mind, a lot of what you refer to or allude to comes back to some of my offseason criticisms of the franchise in becoming stale/stagnant in the coaching realm. Not necessarily firing Mike Tomlin, which I was not calling for after the Ravens debacle. But simply bringing in new people, fresh ideas, expanded positions, things of that nature.

Clarence Snowshoe: Using percentages… who is to blame for yesterday’s loss? Coaches, defense, offense?

Brian Batko: Kind of a weird game because the offense wasn't great, wasn't completely terrible, put up 21 points in the end. The defense wasn't great, wasn't completely terrible, scored a touchdown themselves and got two huge 3-and-outs late. But in the end, both sides of the ball - and special teams, for once - were mediocre enough to result in a loss. It was like a microcosm of Steeler football from 2021 to now.

Advertise with us

Frustrated: Can we just eat their salaries and move on from this entire coaching staff at the end of the year? I don't think I'm overreacting either considering the fan base sees the same things occurring week after week, year after year even with new mix of players. I'd rather be sub-500 in the short term with a new staff in order to start over. There needs to be new ideas in the building. If it's personnel, move our major assets to get draft capital and rebuild with a staff that is ready to move into the 21st century of football.

Brian Batko: I don't envision the Steelers ever firing Mike Tomlin. But as I've written before, if things really go off the rails here (highly unlikely imo) then what kind of conversations start happening behind closed doors? Is there an ultimatum of sorts that if Tomlin stays, he does not get to pick the next defensive coordinator (or even offensive coordinator) and take it or leave it? I genuinely don't know. Just thinking out loud here, Frustrated.

Jim Bow Dean: Why throw contested passes to DK? That’s not who he is.

Brian Batko: He wasn't providing much in terms of YAC yesterday either though when the chances arose. But to be fair to DK, he was getting beat up in that game, and should be commended for playing through all those bumps and bruises.

Happy Gilmore: How do you interpret Patrick Queen's post game comments? He essentially said the defensive scheme makes the job of the ILBs very difficult.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I wonder if somewhere, a bunch of guys were nodding their head. Jon Bostic, Mark Barron, Devin Bush, Avery Williamson, Joe Schobert, Robert Spillane, Myles Jack, am I missing anyone? By and large, as the person asking some of the questions, I certainly interpreted them as highly critical of the coaching staff and defensive scheme. There's not a ton of room for other interpretations there.

TVC15: Was beating Joe Flacco and the Bengals at home in their revenge rematch the Steelers' Super Bowl this year?

Brian Batko: No, no. It was beating the Colts at home.

Steeler Nut: Why can other teams hit 15-20 yard crossing patterns, posts etc with ease...yet, we simply never have anyone wide open? Our personnel isn't horrible. It has to be scheme!? Agree?

Brian Batko: Ehh it's probably some of both. The Bears guys making plays yesterday were all first-round picks. DJ Moore, Colston Loveland, Luther Burden, Rome Odunze. Is Roman Wilson on that level? Is Calvin Austin on that level?

Advertise with us

Les: Hi Brian, if Tomlin’s so called strength with coaching is on the defensive side of the ball then why does there seem to be ZERO adjustments when needed the most?? It’s so frustrating to watch the same thing over and over with their offensive and defensive tendencies. The Elephant in the room is Tomlin and he needs to go. He talks the talk but doesn’t walk the walk. Unfortunately with his 2 years left on his contract he will never be fired before then. This team needs a fresh start. Thoughts?

Brian Batko: I can't really disagree, Les. The primary argument against it is just that Tomlin always stabilizes the organization, turns in a competitive product, and you're taking a leap of faith with any other HC you'd hire in his place. But even those assertions are falling short now when you look at last year's total collapse, the embarrassing losses in the playoffs and the success of new coaches such as Mike Vrabel, Ben Johnson, Mike Macdonald (last year).

Earl.Campbell: What is it going to take to get a clean sweep of the coaching staff?

Brian Batko: The best needle I can try to thread is that earlier suggestion of taking some power away from Tomlin while leaving him installed as the CEO of the team. If this season ends much the same way yet again and they don't want to move on, that's what I see as the only way to exhaust all options.

Adam: Are they so desperate to get something out of Jonnu Smith that they are going to run him now? It’s looking Matt Canada ish. 0-6 yard passes and jet sweeps.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Yeah that was sort of bizarre. I'm all about trying to take advantage of the Bears missing their top three ILBs. No issue with that game plan. But those kind of felt like wasted plays.

Gruff: During practice do the Steelers go over what is and what isn't an illegal formation? How is this so hard? This is covered in midget football & points to a lack of detail on the coaches part. these pre-snap penalties are just ridiculous

Brian Batko: They do. Mistakes still happen even at this level. I'm not saying it's acceptable but it's not exactly the same as the Kaleb Johnson gaffe on kick return Week 2. There are levels to brain farts and attention to detail.

Lou: Brian, it seems that when the D plays better it’s because it was “simplified”. So why not stick to that? As for the O, shouldn’t it also be clear after like 5-6 years of this that this style of play isn’t working out? I don’t get it and most fans don’t either.

Rocky Mtn Yunzer: Deja vu all over again Bats. Mediocre talent, mediocre (at best) coaching, mediocre execution = Mediocre Team. Assuming they can beat The Fish and Da Browns, could this be the year where Tomlin loses his winning record streak?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: It certainly could be just looking at the upcoming games on paper. But I will never predict it. I won't believe it until I see it with my own eyes. They find a way to beat the Bills, Lions or Ravens ... I'm pretty sure.

Chipped Ham Sammich: Given the amount of dead wood and holes in this lineup, is going after the next franchise QB this offseason the right move? Our bigs (OL/DL) are either old or lousy. Can’t win without talent in the trenches…

Brian Batko: Yeah CHS, I imagine that calculus is being revisited each week by the front office who need to take a more 30,000-foot view of this team at all times. But I can't shake the notion of the Steelers insisting upon drafting a QB with the draft here in Pittsburgh. It might feel like backwards logic, but I cannot shake it.

Jana: It feels like the Steelers are wasting a year when KC, and the Bills aren’t what they usually are and Lamar Jackson is obviously hurt in some way. Also the Colts and the Patriots can be beaten. But we can’t seem to take advantage of the situation!! What are your thoughts???

Brian Batko: Doesn't really matter because it's not as if the Steelers were going to get a QB to compete with those teams in a down year anyway. What I'm saying is I'll still be stunned if it's not Mahomes, Allen or Jackson in the Super Bowl from the AFC. Maybe Herbert or Maye if one makes "the leap."

Advertise with us

Lee In SC: Hi Brian,

It’s looking like it will take 10 wins win the North/make the playoffs. This means the Steelers need to win 4 of the next 6 games.

I do not see that happening.

I see 2 nearly certain wins (Cleveland, Miami).

I see 2 almost certain loses (Buffalo, Detroit).

Advertise with us

This means they need to sweep the Raven which we almost never do.

I guess my questions are:

1) How many wins do you see the Steelers getting in the remaining 6 games?

2) If they miss the playoffs or again get in and are one and blown out is it finally time to blow things up and do a rebuild? And I do mean blow it up. The O is in the midst of being rebuilt while the D is aging and not up to the standard.

Your thoughts?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: OK, I'll just put it on record one last time to end today's chat. 1) Three. Which would mean my preseason prediction of 10-7 was WRONG. 2) I need to think about it more. I really do. And while you may interpret that as me being too pro-Tomlin, it's actually me coming around more to the opposite side than ever before.

Brian Batko: Sorry everyone, so many questions I don't have time to get to, but I do appreciate all the readers and interest every week with these. And on the bright side, Ray will be here tomorrow, so don't miss that. Thanks for being here.

Brian Batko: And Happy Thanksgiving!