In the wake of a ridiculous 31-28 loss to the Chicago Bears and their decimated junior varsity defense, Mike Tomlin did not hesitate when asked if quarterback Aaron Rodgers will be ready for the Buffalo Bills next Sunday.
“I anticipate him being ready,” Tomlin said.
Really? No “leave the lights on” and see how the week plays out? No pause whatsoever? Rodgers will just be “ready” in seven measly days? That kind of begs a question:
WHY DIDN’T HE PLAY SUNDAY?
I’m thinking Rodgers, even though he wasn’t sharp over his past two appearances and had a fracture in his left wrist, would have riddled a Bears defense that had only five starters on the field for much of the second half.
The Bears aren’t good defensively when healthy, let alone when all of their linebackers, plus a backup or two, plus a good chunk of their secondary, are missing. They were begging to give up 40 points. The Steelers had 13 yards in the third quarter and only 21 offensive points.
Read More
Mason Rudolph was mediocre at best. He completed bunches of minuscule passes, but almost nothing down the field. He was 3-for-10 on passes that traveled at least 10 yards in the air.
The Steelers might as well have called conventional running plays on every down. They likely would have won. They rushed for 186 yards. But offensive coordinator Arthur Smith couldn’t help himself. There was Rudolph getting sacked on a first-down pass play on the first possession of the third quarter.
Why pass on first down? Why pass at all?
“Mason is a starting-caliber quarterback,” KDKA analyst Chris Hoke said.
I don’t think this performance was evidence of that.
Ben Skowronek had the Steelers’ longest reception at 21 yards. Rudolph was strip-sacked on a play that led to a Bears touchdown and threw an interception. He would have had two if Roman Wilson hadn’t knocked the ball out of a Chicago defender’s hands. Rudolph’s final pass was deflected at the line but didn’t seem to have much of a chance of reaching intended target DK Metcalf.
I’m quite certain Rodgers would have completed a million 2-yard throws, as well, and maybe some longer ones (not that he’s been beating defenses over the top much).
Thing is, Rodgers doesn’t play defense, and the Steelers defense was awful, allowing a touchdown in every quarter. They also allowed the Bears to convert a 3rd-and-9 near midfield late in the first half, leading to a last-second field goal that ultimately provided the margin of victory.
Yet, Tomlin still trusted that defense when he punted on 4th-and-9 with 2:01 left.
“I was holding all three [timeouts],” Tomlin told reporters, “And as you can see, we got the ball back.”
Yes, well, there’s a bit more to that story. Tomlin will see on tape — if he didn’t know already — that he only “got the ball back” because Bears running back Kyle Monangai slipped on a play where he might have not just gained a game-clinching first down but scored.
Tomlin’s $170 million defense stinks. It mounted zero second-half pass rush against Bears quarterback Caleb Williams, who finished with three touchdowns, no interceptions and a 104.3 rating.
Ben Johnson absolutely destroyed Tomlin in the matchup of offensive and defensive coordinators (Tomlin is the Steelers’ de facto coordinator, in case you didn’t know). If Williams wasn’t so erratic in missing open receivers, he might have thrown for 350 yards.
The Bears improved to 8-3. The Steelers fell to second place in the AFC North at 6-5 and now face a titanic struggle to reach the postseason.
How big was the loss?
Consider this: Since 1990, teams that start the season 7-4 go to the playoffs 72.3% of the time, while teams that start 6-5 go 43.5% of the time.
After this debacle, I’m guessing Bears fans are glad their team didn’t trade for Tomlin in the offseason.
Meanwhile ...
• I would have sprinted the field-goal unit on with time running down in regulation and let Chris Boswell try a 64-yard field goal before I watched Rudolph try another minuscule pass.
• It sure looked like T.J. Watt was headed for a monster game early in his matchup with Bears tackle Darnell Wright. On the Bears’ third series, Wright held Watt — who’d beaten him badly to the inside — and put his team back 10 yards. That led to Watt shedding Wright and strip-sacking Williams in the end zone. Nick Herbig recovered the fumble for a touchdown.
And with that, T.J. passed older brother J.J. Watt for the all-time family record at 115 career sacks.
“If he’s gonna pass my record,” J.J. said on the television broadcast, “that’s one hell of a way to do it.”
T.J. also passed Dallas Cowboys great Harvey Martin on that sack. Strangely, though, he disappeared after that — and J.J. never mentioned it.
• Watt sure didn’t seem pleased afterward. Maybe it’s sinking in that he could go yet another season without making anything resembling a playoff run. He is becoming this generation’s Dick Butkus — a Hall of Famer who never won a playoff game.
“We need to get better,” Watt told reporters. “And we need to get better quick.”
• Maybe instead of going crazy trying to punch the ball out on every single play, the Steelers should focus more on tackling people. And covering people. And getting a second-half pass rush. And not blowing coverages to allow silly, wide-open touchdowns.
• Connor Heyward appeared to secure a first down on a tush push that was ruled short. Yet another example of the joke that is the NFL replay system failing to fix the obvious. On the flip side, the taunting call on DJ Moore was laughable. He lightly flipped the ball at James Pierre out of bounds. So what?
• It’s maddening that the Steelers refuse to use the middle of the field and that tight end Pat Freiermuth is such a small part of the offense. He was targeted just three times — and caught all three for 19 yards and a touchdown.
Did I mention that all of the Bears starting linebackers did not play and that one of the reserves was injured in the game. How can you not take advantage of that? Why is it such a recurring issue that other teams riddle the Steelers over the middle, and the Steelers hardly attack that area at all?
“We’ve been talking about this for several years now, and it just tells me they’re not interested in going over the middle of the field,” Hoke said. “I’m not sure why. I’m not sure if they’re just not confident going over the middle and go outside because there’s a lower percentage of something bad happening. ... I’m not exactly sure, but they’ve got to clear that up. It makes it very, very difficult to move the football.”
• Sunday’s game against the Buffalo Bills is shaping up as a de facto playoff game for the Steelers. They’ll be gifted with another opponent’s terrible defense. Let’s see if they can exploit this one.
• In a related matter, the Steelers went a 60th consecutive game without scoring more than seven points in the first quarter. A CBS graphic showed it was the second-longest streak in the NFL since 1950.
Said play-by-play man Ian Eagle: “At some point, you figure, we’ll stumble into some points.”
You’d figure.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.