Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to start in just a few minutes, so get ready....
Gerry Dulac: Here we go...
Hondo17: Just saw that the Titans released Tyler Lockett…. Maybe the Steelers should sign him ?
Gerry Dulac: You mean, like Mike Williams last year? And, given what you've seen from the usage of WRs, where and when are they gonna play him??
Rj: Hi Gerry, year in and year out this defense has proven the same. When players come out and say “we knew the Steelers would be in that coverage because they never change,” this is an indictment of having no answers. Do you really believe Tomlin and his hand puppets have any clue how to fix this over paid defense ?
Gerry Dulac: Well, the plan was to have Jalen Ramsey and Darius Slay join Joey Porter Jr to stop what the Bengals did Thurs night. Of course the Bengals knew what the Steelers were going to do. Everyone did. It was no secret.
Read More
Duck: Wilson and Feilds both catching strays from Payton and Johnson, your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: That's why lot of people don't like Sean Payton
Chipped Ham Sammich: If you could make one change on each side of the ball to improve the team, what would it be? Personnel changes are excluded in this exercise.
Gerry Dulac: What's the point then?
Timbo: Hi Gerry. Do you think there comes a time when the players stop wanting to play for Tomlin? Do some of the vets, who have experienced the repeated late season meltdowns and missing so many layups, kind of tune out at some point? I realize it's not apples to apples but we saw it happen at Penn State recently. Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I don't think ANYTHING that happened at Penn State is in any way comparable to whatever you think happens here. But your point about a message becoming stale to veteran players has some merit. But, in today's NFL, especially with the Steelers and the amount of turnover each year, how many veterans stick around long enough with one team where they start to tune out a message. You can only name a handful with the Steelers
marty: I agree with Ben. Don't you think it's time for Pitt to get a stadium of their own?
Gerry Dulac: That's an old story from 30 years ago. That ain't happening
Marvin Escalera: Hey Gerry love your work. 2 questions: Why are we giving Chuck Clark soo much playing time versus Jabrill Peppers? I thought Peppers played well against New England and deserved more playing time but he has been used exclusively on special teams I feel. And what’s wrong with Thornhill? Why can’t he play most of the defensive free safety snaps? Clark was out of position all game in Cincy. Any reason why?
Gerry Dulac: Apparently, they think Clark is more effective than Peppers, who didn't get a defensive snap. It's not because Peppers is hurt because he played 25 snaps on special teams. As for Thornhill, part of that is because they will use Ramsey at free safety sometimes in their base defense, which they had to switch to at times because the Bengals were able to run the ball.
Jose: Why do you block people for disagreeing with you instead of being a mature adult?
Gerry Dulac: I don't block people for disagreeing with me. I block people who show disrespect or use vulgarity. I don't care if people agree or disagree with me. All I can do is tell you what's going on. It's up to you if you want to believe it or not. If not, go follow those "insiders" who, when it comes to knowledge, are on the outside. But thanks for asking
Tampa Too: Gerry. I have to admit I was in the camp that wanted the Steelers to keep Fields and not sign Aaron Rodgers. However, much to my surprise I have come to realize that Mike Tomlin and his staff know more about football than me! Please have a nice day!
Gerry Dulac: I hate to tell you TT, even though a lot of people don't think this, they know more than you, me and everyone else.
Josh: Hey Gerry, the miscommunications that we keep hearing about on the defensive side of the ball, how much of that is on the player(s) and how much is that blame fall on the coaching staff? Seems like that’s the weekly excuse when things go badly with the D
Gerry Dulac: And that's what it is, Josh -- an excuse. Under the heading "miscommunication" is don't know the play, can't remember the call, I'm not sure of the defense.
Butcher: Gerry. Thanks for taking the time to chat. I equate the Tomlin haters with your chat haters. Take a deep breath and realize you need to reset your priorities in life. Tomlin is going to the Hall as a coach... And he has certain traits that anger fans (clock management, living in his short yardage fears, unleashing hell in December and entering freefall) Took Andy Reid a LONG time to break himself of a lot of issues and put things in place to mitigate others. Like hiring Spags after his carousel post Jim Johnson years in Philly and letting him run the D... Sound familiar? (Looking at Tomlin and LeBrau...) Am I on the mark?
Gerry Dulac: For a butcher, you cut right to the meat of the issue. Touche
Retire21: I have people coming in for the MNF game with Miami. Is this game in the flex window?
Gerry Dulac: Well, flexing it out of prime time could be a possibility
Jim Bow Dean: Is Trice getting close to returning? I know he’s no Mel Blount, but he can’t be any worse than what we saw last Thursday.
Gerry Dulac: He is but I don't know how much he will play when he returns. So, you've already given up on Ramsey, Porter and Slay after one game, eh??
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: Tomlin once again reiterated his narrative that the run defense, turnovers, and penalties were the main culprits for this loss without once mentioning his 31st ranked pass defense that was by far the biggest problem. He can't really be that clueless, but why is he pushing that false narrative?
Gerry Dulac: Bingo. First off, they committed just two turnovers, both by a QB who had thrown only three all year and one of which wasn't his fault. Also, they are one of just two teams who have not lost a fumble this year. And, as for penalties, they have the second fewest in the league.
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: it was widely covered that Aaron passed Ben for 5th on the NFL's all time passing yards list, but with his 14th TD throw he also passed another Steeler legend and 1st round pick, Kenny Pickett, on the franchise list for career TD passes. Where do you think this ranks on his list of accomplishments, maybe somewhere between the Super Bowl win and his 4 MVPs?
Gerry Dulac: He's here all week, try the veal.
Josh: I hate to see it happen, especially now that we seem to have a decent offense, but this may be Arthur Smith’s last season as OC. I think his work with Fields, Wilson, and now Rodgers is going to get noticed and he may be a front runner to land that Titans spot or another team. What do you think?
Gerry Dulac: I'm not so sure about the last part. I like Arthur and think he does a very good job. And his ability to adapt to different QBs is to his everlasting credit. In his years as an OC and head coach, he has only had one season where the incumbent QB was returning (Ryan Tannehill).
Josh: With the QB carousel being what it is in college right now, and a lot of the top prospects at the beginning of the season starting to fall off, do you think the Steelers will try to coax Rodgers into playing one more season if he continues to play well the rest of the way?
Gerry Dulac: Maybe if they get to the Super Bowl
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: The Steelers will pay TJ Watt $41m per year for his age 32-34 seasons. This is slightly more than the $40.25m that the Bengals will pay JaMarr Chase for his age 25-28 seasons. Doesn't last week's game really show that paying that amount of money to Watt, the leader of the 31st ranked pass defense, is a gross misallocation of cap resources?
Gerry Dulac: I will tell you that was something of which the Steelers were keenly aware. It falls under the category of what's a wise business decision
Raxman263: Without Aaron Rodgers, would the Steelers even have a chance to comeback in games while the defense has played so poorly.
Gerry Dulac: Probably not
TexasT: Good morning Gerry, love your chats and pithiness. I think one of the problems with the defense is it’s too vanilla and predictable. Rarely see any CB blitzes and QBs are feasting with time to throw. Don’t you think CoachT is going to have to get more creative to stay relevant in games?
Gerry Dulac: The only QB who feasted on time to throw was Flacco. Go ask Wentz or Gabriel, who were sacked a combined 12 times and hit 30 times, if they thought they had time to feast. And I recall Ramsey having two sacks against the Browns. The things you are claiming they don't do they are doing
Zamo: Hey Gerry. Who would have thunk after 6 games, the Steelers would be struggling on D and offense looks good. Young O-line rounding into form and ARod looks spry! The defense is still a mess. Yes they still can’t stop the run but it’s the short passing game that kills them and has since Brady and company tore them up 10+ years ago. What’s worse is players on opposing teams chirping they “knew” what Steelers would do defensively? How can this ever get fixed??? Cheers bud
Gerry Dulac: Yeah, the offense has very good. Have responded just about every time they needed to. The other night was a perfect example. But the defense couldn't come up with another stop.
Zamo: If it were me, I would decline option on both Benton/JPJ unless things improve dramatically right?
Gerry Dulac: Wrong
Richie Tenenbaum: Gerry, like many fans I was worried about the Tomlin bravado going into last weeks game against the Bengals, and that our defense was going to be outmatched.
Gerry Dulac: And they were!
TexasT: The Bengals debacle is in the rear view mirror, and while I agree that CoachT was right about the Flacco trade, it just made him come off as afraid. You think CoachT was living in his fears?
Gerry Dulac: I think what was "afraid" was the way the Steelers defended Chase and Higgins. They played scared against them, giving them too much room. Just because you play man coverage doesn't mean it's press man coverage. If you're going to play a QB like Flacco who releases the ball so quickly, get up on the line of scrimmage and don't give his receivers a free release. Disrupt their routes and their timing. If anybody saw of some that, let me know.
Hi Gerry -: Personnel wise, where do you see the Steelers going from here? Ride out the vets for 2025, make a few additions at the trade deadline, or cull the heard next year before free agency and the draft. This supposes they have the same result as recent years, get into the playoffs as a low seed and get beat convincingly in the first round. Thanks
Gerry Dulac: That's going to be a great question after the season, even if they have success. And, if they don't have the success they're seeking, there'll be more changes again
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Do you believe we'll see Cory Trice on the field when and if he's healthy? I haven't seen enough of him to know if he's a physical cornerback (run support) or is he in JPJ's mold?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think so. Don't know where they'll play him. And he hasn't played all year
Hi Gerry -: When I look at the WR room in isolation, I pray nothing happens to DK. In looking at the entire offense, I realize that there is only one ball and a decent group of playmakers with the TE’s and RB’s. That said, isn’t the need for a real #2 critical in the pursuit of more playoff success?
Gerry Dulac: There really be if DK gets hurt
Bill in LA: Do you think the Steelers and other quarterback needy teams screwed up by passing on Jaxson Dart?
Gerry Dulac: It sure looks like it. He is this year's Bo Nix
Bill in LA: You often mention Mike Tomlin as someone who watches more film than anyone else. Why doesn't it help him make better coaching decisions at the end of games?
Gerry Dulac: It helps make him a better coach
Bill in LA: What in your opinion are the top three flaws of Mike Tomlin as a coach?
Gerry Dulac: Tell you what, Bill, I'll let you answer first and then I'll see if I agree with you, OK?
Tony: Hi Gerry. After the latest defensive debacle, do you think the Steelers will rebound with a win vs. Green Bay, or will they be powerless to stop their offense which has become a recurring nightmare?
Gerry Dulac: Tony, they're a 4-2 team that just had a three-game win streak ended and are in first place by two games. I've seen this situation so many times over the years that it wouldn't surprise me if they won 40-0. Don't judge week to week
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Do you believe in the matchup theory? Are there players and teams who just flat out play well against other teams? Tomlin really seems to fear Flacco.
Gerry Dulac: Absolutely. Some teams just match up better than others. Why does Lamar Jackson struggle against the Steelers? Why do the Bengals slice the Steelers defense?
Rinse and Repeat: Gerry, When will it be enough? We have seen the same, tired schemes on defense for years. The talk about moving Watt around is well, talk. Predictable, stale and outdated. We all know on paper that Austin is the DC, but you know Tomlin is calling the shots. When will Rooney wake up and see we aren't on the same level as the top contenders in the league?
Gerry Dulac: I think you need to ask me this after 16 games, not six, not when they're 4-2. Let's wait and see what happens.
Lou: Hey Gerry! Which move do you make to help the Steelers? Trade for WR or maybe more DB or DL help?
Gerry Dulac: Ok, answer me this -- if they trade/sign a wide receiver, after what you've seen, where will they play him? D-line? That's why they drafted Harmon and Black. And DB? Did you see how many they signed or traded for in the offseason.
Bill in LA: When you were in Paris, were you able to figure out why French peiple are so peculiar?
Gerry Dulac: Bill....I'm French
BenMcGee: Tomlin blamed the loss on run defense,penalties and turnovers. You think he really believes that or just wants to deflect blame on the miserable performance of the secondary he blustered about in Latrobe?
Gerry Dulac: It was a bad combo of run defense and poor secondary play. Complete failure
Happy Gilmore: Gerry, does MT live in a bubble or do you think he knows that the vast majority of Steelers nation would like to see him leave the team?
Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure you can speak for the "vast majority," but, either way, I don't think he pays much attention to that. He understands the business -- not everyone is going to like him. Kinda like these chats.
Mike: What do you think are the main reasons with Ramsey's performance lately? Slowing down with age, playing too many positions?
Gerry Dulac: Did you think that after the first five games?
SteelerMark: Mr D long time reader of your work and enjoy your opinions. This season has me thinking that our roster has been poor the last several years and maybe Tomlin has done more with less? What do you think?
Gerry Dulac: Well, that's why so many of the national media applaud him for what he does -- gets more from less. And they are not wrong in that regard
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Is the constant blame for poor communications on defense really a lack of talent and poor coaching? All of which are Tomlin's fault.
Gerry Dulac: It's a lame excuse
itsallmoot: Seems like the fan base is down on Connor Heyward but I don't get it. He's mainly a good special team player who also has some, albeit limited, use as 4th Tight End. That adjustment and catch he made for a TD was a nice play. Seems like fans like Killibrew but is almost the same player but on D. Am I missing something?
Gerry Dulac: They're down on a special teams player who is way down the depth chart? How judgmental can you get
JR: If this is an “elite” defense, I’d hate to see what a bad defense looked like.
Gerry Dulac: It looked like the one in Cincy Thurs night
RAM: Mornin’ Gerry! How many points will the Steelers offense have to score on Sunday night to win considering how bad MT’s defense has been playing? Although I have been a Tomlin fan (the head coach) I’m growing weary of Tomlin the DC. Same problems year in and year out. The defense has been retooled many times and we always hear the same old catch phrases “unleash hell”, “Historic” etc. Will Art Rooney ever come to the conclusion that it’s the coaching?
Gerry Dulac: I think they need at least 34.
Justin C: While the loss in Cincinnati was unnerving, as you look across the league, there are plenty of parallels to the loss. Phi losing to the Giants (Thur prime time/division road opponent). KC loss in JAX (prime time on the road). BUF loss to ATL. Unexpected losses by supposedly good to great teams. Do you feel the same that it’s just another difficult loss or is it more on Tomlin’s historic record of similar losses that is just unacceptable to where they believe they are.
Gerry Dulac: It not only happens every week in the NFL, sometimes it happens two or three times every week. Just like the week you referenced. Yet Steelers fans believe their team is impervious to such happenings
Rocky,: Good morning Gerry, do you think the Steelers will right the defensive ship against the Pack?? Do you think they should be playing Echols more and Slay less? Thanks for your great chats!!
Gerry Dulac: I do and I don't
Rich: Gerry...you would think that When Mr Rooney pays $160 MILLION to a defense that was so hyped in preseason and if it continues to show the same collapse tendencies/communication lapses as last year, that this would give pause to awarding the defensive genius head coach a contract extension this offseason, right? Nevermind stupid question!
Gerry Dulac: Hahaha
John from Toronto: Hi Gerry. Is all this talk of a need for a WR2 overblown? With Austin coming back, a talented pool of TE's and Wilson emerging, do they really need to worry about adding another WR?
Gerry Dulac: Let's just say this, fans and some media have talked about it for two years and all they have to show for it was Mike Williams.
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, have to head to the locker room. Thanx for the questions. See ya next week





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.