Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Bill in SF: I'm still intrigued by what I'm seeing, and not seeing, from Kaleb Johnson. He got more touches yesterday, but other than the one 10 yard run, he seemed tentative. I didn't watch much Iowa football last year., so I'm curious as to what they thought they were getting with that 3rd round pick vs. what he's showing so far. RB seems like a position where the learning curve isn't that steep for a rookie.
Brian: Kaleb Johnson is still very intriguing as a third-rounder. He came in with high expectations, including some who thought he’d eclipse Jaylen Warren by now, so you hope he didn’t let those narratives go to his head in any way.
As for Sunday, I didn’t think he ran tentatively at all. I thought he did a good job picking the hole, getting north-south, falling forward and taking what was there. Now, did he go the extra mile and get more than what was blocked like some elite backs might? Not necessarily, but he’s a rookie who’s being eased in with six carries in back-to-back games after just two through the first three.
The Steelers thought they were getting a big-bodied, pro-style ball-carrier with breakaway speed. They probably didn’t see enough of the little things from him in training camp and the preseason, which put him firmly behind Jaylen Warren and Kenneth Gainwell. And, obviously, neither of those two have slipped up. If anything, they’ve been better than anticipated, giving the coaches every reason to keep them out there and the young guy on the bench. Who do you think Aaron Rodgers trusts more as a pass-catcher and pass-protector, those two veterans or a rookie?
Mike Tomlin acknowledged this Monday, but it’s worth noting that equating Johnson’s kickoff calamity with his progress (or lack thereof) as a running back isn’t entirely fair. While the lack of detail and focus in his work certainly didn’t help his cause, that’s a different job than what he was focused on for the majority of his time in college.
Read More
This would be an especially intriguing week for Johnson to get more snaps as a rusher. Johnson was born and raised in the Cincinnati area and will get his first AFC North homecoming.
Dan in Atlanta: With Mike Tomlin allegedly telling his defense in 2024 not to knock Anthony Richardson out of the game so Joe Flacco would not replace Richardson and Tomlin now ripping Browns GM Andrew Berry for trading Flacco to the Bengals, is Tomlin living in his fears with regard to Joe Flacco?
Brian: Tomlin, I’m assuming, is not afraid of Joe Flacco. But he’d much rather face Jake Browning than Joe Flacco. And who wouldn't?
Browning is an undrafted quarterback who went on a little bit of a heater a couple years ago when Joe Burrow went down. But he was horrific in his three starts this season, and the Steelers dominated him twice in that 2023 campaign. He went 4-3 as the starter in place of Burrow the first time around, and two of those losses were to the Steelers.
Basically, he thought he was getting another punching bag like Dillon Gabriel. Then the Browns threw the Bengals a lifeline. And being the competitor that he is, with the reverence he has for the AFC North, Tomlin would never play that game of phone-a-friend.
Jim K: Is the Steelers organization cheap? They can't seem to maintain a field or call in an expert consultant to help them and their coaching staff payroll is very low beyond Cliché compared to other organizations. I know they spend on players, but hearing things about facilities and coaching staff can also factor into the success or lack of during any season.
Brian: I don’t know enough to weigh in on how much they do or do not spend on field maintenance relative to the rest of the league. What I can tell you is that there’s one grounds crew that handles both Acrisure Stadium and UPMC Rooney Sports Complex.
The Eagles have separate crews to handle their practice facility and Lincoln Financial Field, where Temple also plays a half-dozen games each season. The Ravens have separate crews for their complex and home venue even without a college team involved.
On your other point, how about Brian Callahan or Bill Callahan as a midseason hire — or both? Just last year, the Packers brought in defensive-minded Robert Saleh as an offensive consultant two weeks after he was fired by the Jets. The Callahans know the AFC North as well as anyone and are both unemployed now that the Titans moved on.
Steve in Iowa: In today’s atmosphere, we, as a people, need to show more empathy towards others. I would like to take a step towards that by trying to understand what it is like to be a die-hard-life-long Browns or Jets fan. Can you shed some light on how this must feel to be a fan of these teams that seem to be mired in continuously dismal football play? Please use real-world interactions.
Brian: I agree wholeheartedly, Steve. When I think about the Browns, I always recall a conversation I had at a wedding with the now-husband of one of my wife’s college friends from Cleveland. It was the summer of 2019, coming off of Baker Mayfield’s rookie year, and the Browns hype train was rolling.
This guy wasn’t naive enough to believe in all that. But he told me he was just hoping that no matter how that season played out, whether they broke through or not, all he wanted to see was Mayfield show he’d be the franchise quarterback for a long time. Alas ...
And the Jets? Two of my best friends are Jets fans, and I’m pretty sure they have zero desire to pass that on to their young children. That tells you all you need to know about that.
@sunbuc21: Bengals will wear all white uniforms Thursday. Will the Steelers wear their color rush?
Brian: Not that I know of, but that would be cool. Even in the Steelers’ normal jerseys, this will be a good uniform matchup that pops off the field and screen.
On that note, this will be the last time you see the Steelers before they unveil their new throwback alternates next Sunday night against the Packers. So, yeah, soak it in, I suppose.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.