Steelers insider Ray Fittipaldo grades each aspect of the Steelers’ 24-21 victory over the Vikings.

Quarterback

Aaron Rodgers was excellent early in the game in staking the Steelers to a big lead. The big plays dried up as the game wore on, but he continued to be efficient and did not make a big mistake. Rodgers finished 18-for-22 for 200 yards and a touchdown. He’s not putting up big numbers, but the Steelers are 3-1 without playing their best football. Rodgers has been really good in situational football in the first four games.

Grade: A-

Running backs

Getting the start for an injured Jaylen Warren, Kenneth Gainwell had 19 carries for 99 yards and scored two touchdowns. He also added six catches for 35 yards. As a runner, Gainwell showed great patience in letting the holes develop. His success on first down was huge because it kept the Steelers in manageable downs and distances against a Vikings defense that likes to pressure on third downs. They were never able to get to their exotic blitz packages because of it. Rookie Kaleb Johnson saw his most extensive playing time and contributed 22 yards on six carries, including a 9-yard run in the fourth quarter.

Advertise with us

Grade: A

Receivers

DK Metcalf was involved early and often. He had 122 of his 126 receiving yards by halftime. His 80-yard catch and run broke the game open. The offense was a bit more conservative in the second half, but Metcalf had nearly as many yards against the Vikings as he did in the first three games combined. There was some bad news. Calvin Austin III injured his shoulder early in the fourth quarter and did not return. The Steelers have an off week to rest their injured players, but if Austin can’t come back for the next game against the Browns, Roman Wilson is going to have to step in and become a bigger contributor. While the Steelers finally got Metcalf involved, they are still searching for ways to get their tight ends into the flow more. Darnell Washington led all tight ends with 20 yards and Pat Freiermuth did not have a catch.

Grade: A-

Offensive line

The answer to the struggling run game, for one game, at least, was big personnel. The Steelers brought in Spencer Anderson as an extra offensive lineman often and utilized tight end Darnell Washington as a blocker to open some bigger holes. The Steelers averaged 4.5 yards per carry, a big improvement over their average in the first three weeks of the season. The run blocking was a big step in the right direction for a unit that had been maligned. Leaky pass protection continues to be an issue at inopportune times. The Steelers had a chance to take a 21-3 lead just before halftime, but on second down, left guard Isaac Seumalo did not block Jalen Redmond, who sacked Rodgers for a loss. The Steelers had to settle for a field goal attempt that was blocked. The guards and center also allowed Redmond a free rush on the first play of the game when he sacked Rodgers.

Grade: B

Advertise with us

Defensive line

Grade: Keeanu Benton had been a lightning rod for criticism in the first three games, but he had his best game of the season by far against the Vikings. He had four tackles and 1.5 sacks to lead the charge up front. Cam Heyward tipped another pass at the line of scrimmage that led to a T.J. Watt interception. He did the same thing last week in New England. The Vikings running game was never a factor in the game. They finished with just 70 yards on 20 carries. It was the first time this season the Steelers held their opponent to under 100 rushing yards.

Grade: B

Linebackers

Give the game ball to Payton Wilson, who had a team-high 13 tackles but none bigger than his shoestring tackle of Jordan Addison late in the fourth quarter that prevented a touchdown. The play forced the Vikings to run a few more plays and a minute off the clock before they scored. It was the biggest play of the game. Patrick Queen was almost as good with 11 tackles and a sack while Watt (1) and Nick Herbig (1.5) also added sacks. Herbig also forced Carson Wentz into an intentional grounding on the Vikings’ final drive. All he does is take advantage of his opportunities when Alex Highsmith is out of the lineup.

Grade: A

Secondary

Give the Steelers credit for closing the game out with a number of their defensive backs injured, but they can’t continue to have the communication errors that have been constants in the first four games of the season. There was another one between Darius Slay Jr. and Chuck Clark late in the game that led to Addison’s 81-yard catch-and-run. This unit has to get healthy during the off week and iron out all of their mental errors.

Advertise with us

Grade: C

Special teams

Pat Freiermuth did not block Isaiah Rodgers off the edge, which led to Chris Boswell’s first field goal attempt to be blocked. Boswell did come back to make a 33-yarder later in the fourth quarter. Corliss Waitman averaged 48 yards per punt, but he should have pinned the Vikings on his final one rather than boot it through the end zone. Austin had a nice 12-yard punt return before he was injured, and the kickoff returners have been much better since Kaleb Johnson was benched. Gainwell and Trey Sermon averaged 25 yards per return against the Vikings.

Grade: B-

Coaching

Mike Tomlin made the final score closer than it had to be and put the game in jeopardy with some questionable late-game decisions. He had a chance to go up by 13 with less than four minutes left, but he kept his offense on the field and Gainwell was stopped on fourth down. If you’re going to go for it there, put the ball in Rodgers’ hands and let him try to make a play. The other questionable decision came when he punted with 1:08 remaining on 4th-and-1 from the Vikings 45-yard line. The defense was able to close the game out, but those two calls will be scrutinized. Offensive coordinator Arthur Smith was on his game early with the right formations to get Metcalf involved. His motion on the 80-yard touchdown gave Rodgers just enough of a crease in the middle of the Minnesota defense to make the big play.

Grade: B-