The NFL draft is finally here, which means the swirling rumors about which teams are truly interested in which prospects will finally be put to the test. Our team of Steelers reporters has been hard at work examining the class from the Steelers' perspective as far as which players will have the best value.
But there's also the value placed in this class from the other 31 teams that factor into who will even be available for the Steelers should they not trade out of their natural first-round pick at 21st overall. Here's a look from Brian Batko and Christopher Carter on how they see the first round of the draft in a no-trades format that highlights where they see certain players' value and how different teams will address their own needs.
While trades are likely to occur, this sets the stage for where certain players might go in the order of picks or what teams might value in the first round should their optimal choice not be available.
1. Titans
Carter: Cam Ward, QB, Miami. Ward is the undisputed best quarterback of this class. It would be baffling if the Titans went in any other direction here.
Batko: Cam Ward, QB, Miami. Maybe next year’s first overall pick will bring some drama.
2. Browns
Carter: Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Colorado. The Browns could use Hunter's talents at either cornerback or wide receiver, as his potential as a franchise game-breaker on either side of the ball would make him a pillar piece for the next decade.
Read More
Batko: Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Colorado. As fun as it would be to see Myles Garrett and another elite edge rusher trying to combat AFC North offenses, Hunter’s got a double-good chance of working out for a franchise that badly needs it.
3. Giants
Carter: Abdul Carter, EDGE, Penn State. Carter is my top player overall in this draft. But his injury and the need for a quarterback bump him out of the top two picks. He'd be a necessary addition to the Giants' defense as a potential game-wrecker off the edge.
Batko: Abdul Carter, EDGE, Penn State. Philly native with uncanny juice to get after the passer pops over to New York (New Jersey).
4. Patriots
Carter: Will Campbell, OT, LSU. Campbell is the best offensive lineman in this draft, and Drake Maye needs protection to survive in New England. Seems like a no-brainer move.
Batko: Will Campbell, OT, LSU. Mike Vrabel starts his tenure with a meat and potatoes pick to protect Drake Maye.
5. Jaguars
Carter: Mason Graham, DT, Michigan. This has been a popularly mocked pick for a month now, even if rumors are starting to swirl that Graham's value could drop him out of the top 10. I think the Jaguars might be creating havoc around the draft so their pick isn't as obvious.
Batko: Mason Graham, DT, Michigan. Ashton Jeanty buzz is buzzing, but I don’t see 34-year-old, analytics-minded general manager James Gladstone going that route.
Jahdae Barron is great, but is the need big enough?
— Post-Gazette Sports (@PGSportsNow) April 24, 2025
Steelers insider @CarterCritiques scouts the top 5 options likely to be available when they pick at No. 21 overall in the NFL draft.
Full draft coverage: https://t.co/g4qjn4hpS5 pic.twitter.com/uQuj8HvrT6
6. Raiders
Carter: Ashton Jeanty, RB, Boise State. The Raiders need a playmaker running back, and Jeanty has the potential to be a generational player. This is almost too perfect of a fit to avoid.
Batko: Will Johnson, CB, Michigan. Another potential landing spot for Jeanty, but Pete Carroll’s defense can never have enough cornerbacks in this division.
7. Jets
Carter: Tyler Warren, TE, Penn State. The Jets need a big target for Justin Fields, and Warren fits the bill perfectly here. In a year without the superstar wide receiver, it matches their need for a playmaker tight end while the team still has Garrett Wilson as receiver.
Batko: Jalon Walker, LB, Georgia. Offensive line is the bigger need, but if the versatile Walker is the best player available, new coach Aaron Glenn can’t pass on that.
8. Panthers
Carter: Jalon Walker, LB, Georgia. Carolina needs help on defense, and Walker is a presence who can help with pressure off the edge or help at off-ball linebacker. Either way, his dynamic abilities seem to fit what the Panthers need to improve.
Batko: Tyler Warren, TE, Penn State. From a Nittany Lion to a Panther, Bryce Young gets his safety valve.
9. Saints
Carter: Shedeur Sanders, QB, Colorado. I know the rumor mill has spun Sanders away from this pick, but I still see this as the most sensible move for the Saints, who need a quarterback even more desperately than the Steelers with Derek Carr's injury.
Batko: Jaxson Dart, QB, Ole Miss. Kellen Moore gets a quarterback to build around … but it’s not Shedeur Sanders.
10. Bears
Carter: Mykel Williams, EDGE, Georgia. The Bears need help rushing the passer, and Williams' value has skyrocketed over the past month. I expect the Bears to want to add some more teeth to their defense, and he'd be a good fit.
Batko: Ashton Jeanty, RB, Boise State. This is lower than he should go, but uniting him with Caleb Williams would be a lot of fun for a football city that needs some fun.
11. 49ers
Carter: Walter Nolen, DT, Ole Miss. The first of the Steelers' primary defensive tackle targets goes off the board. The 49ers could use help in the trenches on either side of the ball, and many have pushed Nolen's perceived value in the NFL to be a top-10 player or hovering just outside of that. He'd make sense here.
Batko: Shemar Stewart, EDGE, Texas A&M. They had to gut their defense, so taking a big swing on a big man who can move like Stewart is a reasonable pick.
12. Cowboys
Carter: Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona. The Cowboys need another star receiver, and they end up getting a player in McMillan who normally would be gone by this spot in the draft.
Batko: Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona. If they don’t trade for George Pickens, of course!
13. Dolphins
Carter: Will Johnson, CB, Michigan. The news of Jalen Ramsey possibly being moved means this team needs a new outside cornerback, and I see them going with Johnson despite his recent injury history.
Batko: Jahdae Barron, CB, Texas. This regime needs a hit, and a talented Swiss Army knife should have a high ceiling.
14. Colts
Carter: Colston Loveland, TE, Michigan. The Colts could use a weapon at tight end, and if they don't move up to get Warren in the top 10, Loveland would be an amazing athletic option for the position as a playmaker.
Batko: Colston Loveland, TE, Michigan. If ever there were a team that needs to spend a premium pick on a tight end ...
15. Falcons
Carter: Mike Green, EDGE, Marshall. Green's value climbed faster after he dominated the Senior Bowl, and I see him as one of the best edge options in this class. The Falcons do need help rushing the passer.
Batko: Mykel Williams, EDGE, Georgia. It’s almost too perfect to keep a Georgia native and Bulldog right at home.
16. Cardinals
Carter: Jahdae Barron, CB, Texas. Arizona gets a steal with a player I rank inside my top 10 players at any position.
Batko: Armand Membou, OT, Missouri. Whether he plays right away or sits a year, he’s added to Kyler Murray’s security team, though defensive help is sorely needed, too.
17. Bengals
Carter: Kelvin Banks Jr., OL, Texas. Joe Burrow has been knocked out of two seasons with injuries in his NFL career, and it's not a problem the Bengals have fixed with their offensive line yet. Look for the Bengals to solidify their line here.
Batko: Kenneth Grant, DT, Michigan. Swiped away from the Steelers (or at least from their consideration) like Amarius Mims a year ago.
18. Seahawks
Carter: Matthew Golden, WR, Texas. Golden might be the best pure athlete of the receiver position with his speed and burst. Would make for a dangerous pairing with Jaxon Smith-Njigba.
Batko: Matthew Golden, WR, Texas. A ready-made replacement for DK Metcalf (or at least to stretch the field the way Metcalf can).
19. Buccaneers
Carter: Malaki Starks, S, Georgia. The Buccaneers need safety help, and Starks is ranked as many experts' top option. He's my second-best safety, but his tape shows he can fit a lot of different roles in the secondary, which would be welcomed in their defense.
Batko: Jihaad Campbell, LB, Alabama. Another stud linebacker to a Todd Bowles defense and a roster that’s fairly complete.
20. Broncos
Carter: Omarion Hampton, RB, North Carolina. Denver fans might have PTSD over another early pick on a running back from North Carolina, but Hampton grades much better than Javonte Williams, and they should sprint to the podium to add a playmaker like him to the offense.
Batko: Omarion Hampton, RB, North Carolina. Bo and O make a good backfield duo.
21. Steelers
Carter: Kenneth Grant, DT, Michigan. Grant's ability as a run defender to eat double teams and not lose ground will speak loudly for the Steelers, who had problems at the end of the season. They need a strong interior presence against the run who can also help against the pass. Some scouts don't believe Grant's a good pass rusher and never will be, but I think it's something he'll figure out much quicker than expected.
Batko: Derrick Harmon, DT, Oregon. Also a decent chance he’s available later in the round for a trade-down, but you never know.
22. Chargers
Carter: Grey Zabel, OL, North Dakota State. Zabel may be listed as a tackle, but his experience gives him the flexibility to move inside. The Chargers don't need any help at tackle, but you'd better believe Jim Harbaugh will be all about owning the trenches. If McMillan, Golden, Hampton and Loveland are off the board, I see this as the move.
Batko: TreVeyon Henderson, RB, Ohio State. The new Triple H: Herbert, Harris and Henderson, who adds a big-time speed element to complement Najee.
23. Packers
Carter: Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M. The Packers need help on the edge, and Stewart's impressive athletic profile seems like a perfect fit for someone to take in the middle/late part of the first round.
Batko: Emeka Egbuka, WR, Ohio State. A first-round receiver in Green Bay needles Aaron Rodgers.
24. Vikings
Carter: Nick Emmanwori, S, South Carolina. Emmanwori is my top safety, and I've seen him linked to the Vikings multiple times this offseason. He's an athletic freak who can play on any level of the defense.
Batko: Walter Nolen, DT, Ole Miss. Brian Flores will put him to good use, particularly if he has some time to marinate behind Javon Hargrave and others.
25. Texans
Carter: Armand Membou, OT, Missouri. This is a big fall for Membou, who I have as a top-10 prospect. But he won't get past here, as the Texans need help on their offensive line to protect C.J. Stroud.
Batko: Tyler Booker, OL, Alabama. Building a nice pocket for CJ Stroud to get back to business in Year 3.
26. Rams
Carter: Jaxson Dart, QB, Ole Miss. Matthew Stafford's age plays a big role in this decision, as he's around for another year or two but isn't the long-term option. Dart isn't a starting-caliber quarterback right now, but if he learns behind Stafford for a couple seasons, maybe he proves everyone wrong about him.
Batko: Malaki Starks, S, Georgia. Everyone instantly thinks offense with this team, but these guys invested in impact pieces on defense last year and can continue to do so.
27. Ravens
Carter: Josh Simmons, OT, Ohio State. The Ravens get some much-needed help to protect Lamar Jackson for great value. Simmons is rated more toward the middle of the first round, but if he fell here, the Ravens would happily take him.
Batko: Donovan Jackson, OL, Ohio State. He’ll get to try to block fellow Buckeye great Cam Heyward at left guard.
28. Lions
Carter: Derrick Harmon, DT, Oregon. The Lions could use more help on their defensive front, and Harmon's a great fit as a five-technique player. Watch out for him and Aidan Hutchinson in the long run.
Batko: Luther Burden III, WR, Missouri. A good friend of Jameson Williams joins him in what’s now an even more dynamic receiving corps.
29. Commanders
Carter: Donovan Ezeiruaku, EDGE, Boston College. The Commanders need to add a pass rusher and take a player I have ranked toward the middle of the first round. Good value.
Batko: Kelvin Banks Jr., OL, Texas. Jayden Daniels gets another blocker for the long haul.
30. Bills
Carter: Trey Amos, CB, Ole Miss. The Bills’ secondary needs reinforcements, and Amos would be a good fit for what they want to do on the ball.
Batko: Nick Emmanwori, S, South Carolina. The physical traits are too good for him to slip out of the first round.
31. Chiefs
Carter: Josh Conerly Jr., OT, Oregon. Remember when the Chiefs offensive line got bullied across the field in the Super Bowl? Expect that to be a primary concern for this team to address early in this draft.
Batko: Josh Simmons, OT, Ohio State. Super Bowl showed how much they need to commit to keeping Patrick Mahomes upright.
32. Eagles
Carter: James Pearce Jr., EDGE, Tennessee. The Eagles get right back to adding to the defensive front that won them a Super Bowl with a dangerous pass-rusher like Pearce. He's got great athletic traits and should be a good fit.
Batko: Donovan Ezeiruaku, EDGE, Boston College. Yep, they probably just got another very scary game-wrecker up front.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.