Gerry Dulac: OK kids, let's get our chat started. I promise, no April Fools jokes like Tiger Woods...
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: Happy April Fool's Day. There has been a lot of media talk about the concept that if you keep Pickens this year and he leaves via free agency next year, you get a 3rd round comp pick in 2027. Isn't this talk highly speculative because comp picks depend on the "net" gains and losses of signing free agents? If the Steelers are active in free agency next year, couldn't they get nothing for losing Pickens?
Gerry Dulac: Yes, this is true. But I don't think they are going to just let Pickens leave in free agency.
Mike: Any insight on Rodgers working out with DK? Is this a sign that Rodgers is signing?
Gerry Dulac: Who knows with Aaron Rodgers
Tony: Are / should the Steelers be targeting an Interior O lineman in this years draft
Read More
Gerry Dulac: Nope. Try the other line of scrimmage
Guest: Hi Gerry - Do you think if Aaron signs, Tomlin will let him use the middle of the field? This offense struggles as is, eliminating any part of the field, just compounds the problem!
Gerry Dulac: He will use whatever part of the field he is comfortable using. He's not a four-time MVP and first-ballot Hall of Famer for nothing, ya know
Jay: Thanks for the chats Gerry. You have any prospects that you like that no one is really talking about? Not necessarily first round guys.
Gerry Dulac: Jay, not especially, because every prospect is usually talked about by somebody
Jeff M: Do you think the Steelers knew about Larry O's suspension before releasing him? I read the Bills did not until after they signed him.
Gerry Dulac: I don't think that's the reason they released him, but I guess it's possible
Bubby's Rooster: Gerry instead of Aaron Rodgers, wouldn't Dan Marino make more sense? He's about the same age, just as mobile, has Pittsburgh roots and a stronger arm.
Gerry Dulac: Be sure to tip your waitresses!!
Bogey Golfer: Hey Gerry, what do you think is the percentage of people asking you questions in these chats that think you are the Steelers GM and have a say in anything player related? :-)
Gerry Dulac: Hey bogey, roughly the same as me making a 6-foot, left-to-right, downhiller
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: I know that you favor a DL in round 1 and it is hard to disagree with you, but doesn't Jaxson Dart profile as a much stronger prospect to take at #21 than Pickett was to take at #20? More athletic, 2 years younger, bigger hands, stronger arm, more than a one year wonder in college. Will fear of making the same mistake twice actually cause the next mistake?
Gerry Dulac: Nope. He might be a better prospect than Pickett -- maybe -- but I don't see that happening
Jeff M: If the Steelers draft a mid round QB and signed their washed up QB of choice, do you think the draft pick can get enough reps to show if he can be any good before being replaced by a high draft pick next year?
Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure it will affect what they do next year.
Yogi in Yonkers: Good morning Gerry. I thought Arthur Smith's offenses were supposed to be based, to an extent, on significant use of tight ends. Do you foresee the Steelers possibly moving on from their niche TE's (Washington, Heyward) and going after a big time all around player to pair with Freiermuth? Tyler Warren would look great in black and gold.
Gerry Dulac: Yes he would, but that's not happening. Tight end is the least of their concerns. And Warren will be long gone by then anyway
MFC: Hi Gerry. Let’s say after all this waiting that we end up with Mason being the starter (which I don’t mind at all). It’s pretty much a game of attrition with him being put at QB3 a few years ago. But, here’s the million dollar question - will he be allowed to use the middle of the field?
Gerry Dulac: What's with these middle of the field questions???
ABC: Gerry, why is trading Pickens a thought after getting Metcalf? They are very comparable players so trading him would essentially put our WRs in the same spot as last year minus a second round pick? Even if you were to trade him and spend the third round pick you get back on a WR, we've seen how the Steelers gradually work rookies into the gameplan so there would be no immediate payoff. Not to mention the last 5 WRs, besides Pickens, have not had any long term success (wilson, austin, claypool, diontae, james washington). Keep pickens and metcalf together and have multiple legit playmakers for once. Thanks.
Gerry Dulac: I think they will keep them together for now. Just don't anticipate Pickens getting a second contract here
Yogi in Yonkers: Gerry, the disastrous run defense in the playoff game - was that really 100% attributable to the DL or was it also a case of the ILB's not getting off blocks?
Gerry Dulac: DL. DL. DL.
Tampa Too: Gerry. Do you see the NFL going to 18 games soon? If so, do you think they’llhave two bye weeks. Also, would they increased roster size because the increased injuries associated with more games ?And finally do you think this is a good idea?
Gerry Dulac: I thought 16 games was fine. But, to answer your question, yes I do
Guest: Any reason Steelers never use non exclusive franchise tag
Gerry Dulac: Yeah....money
wallace82@comcast.net: Any truth to the rumor Rogers is signed,but it won't be revealed until after the draft to protect comp picks?
Gerry Dulac: Uh.....hmmmmm.....let's see.....NO!!!!
Stevie: If you had to definitively say right now who you thought the Steelers would take with their first round pick at #21 who would it be?
Gerry Dulac: Here's the thing, I don't have to
J D: Gerry, wouldn’t it be the biggest mistake to not take a DL in round 1?
Gerry Dulac: BIGGEST!!
Guest: The five stages of grieving the lack of a franchise QB:Are you at acceptance yet for Aaron Rodgers being the QB in 2025?
Gerry Dulac: Better yet, are the Steelers?
DCSteelers: If Rodgers does not reach an agreement with the Steelers before the draft, what are the chances that they take a QB in the first round despite the glaring need at DL? They made the bone-headed choice to draft Pickett in the first round when they should have waited another year to draft a QB, so I am not confident in the decision-making.
Gerry Dulac: The chances are about as good as Aaron Rodgers making a decision today
Stevie: I can't remember a more embarrassing offseason as a Steelers fan than this offseason. Not sense the 80's Steelers. Waiting for an old QB that's a major drama queen and will never win them a Super Bowl. Is it really worth it? Or better to just draft a rookie QB?
Gerry Dulac: Is it worth it? If it's the old Aaron Rodgers -- by old I mean, the guy from seven years ago -- then maybe. If it's the old Aaron Rodgers -- by that I mean the 41-year-old model who won 5 games last season with three good WRs -- then no.
574 Fan: Nobody has been more consistent than you in pointing out the pressing need to restock the d line - if I recall you were saying this out last year. The need is now paramount (outside of qb - which is not an issue solvable in the first rd), even with all the other holes in the roster. Just a thank you for remaining a voice of reason since I can’t seem to stop myself from clicking on every ridiculous mock from self proclaimed “analysts” that ends up mocking a rb to them in the first rd. But seriously, they wouldn’t…would they?
Gerry Dulac: Actually have been trumpeting the DL line pick since they chose Pickett. But, I will say this, RB is a priority for them, maybe right behind DL. And I have been told not to discount one in any round. But, because the RB draft class is deep, I think they think they can get someone on the third round
Brian Duncan: I run a 3rd generation business myself, and I think Art Rooney might just be trying too hard to emulate his previous family members by never changing coaches and being stuck in the past in some instances. What are your thoughts on that?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think he's trying to emulate them as much as it's engrained him as the son of the previous owner and the grandson of the team's founder.
AK: Trey Lance? Joe Milton? Kirk Cousins? Is there any QB that Steelers fans won’t advocate for?
Gerry Dulac: None. They want 'em all. Until they get him here, clamor for him, then boo him out of town
AK: I see there are fans who think the Steelers can get a first for Pickens. That means the best they’ll likely get is a third, given Steelers fans continual overvaluing of their players?
Gerry Dulac: Correct
Joe: Are the Steelers definitely going to take D line, one of Grant, Harmon or Nolan, in round one? Chances they draft a QB or RB in the first round?
Gerry Dulac: Can't say definitely because I'm not in that draft room. You can rule out a QB in Rd 1. I won't say the same about a RB, even though I don't think that will be the case.
No QB in the First: Please tell me the Steelers aren’t going to waste a first round pick on a QB this year.
Gerry Dulac: As Bruce Arians once said when asked if rookie Matt Spaeth was another Matt Kranchick, "Lord I hope not."
Guest: It sounds like Rooney wanted Wilson and Khan wanted Fields. Tomlin wants Rodgers, so that is what will likely happen. Do any coaches have the power he has? Clearly, Khan reports to him and Tomlin seems more powerful than Rooney. After seeing the place he has put this franchise over the past decade, what has he done to justify this much power?
Gerry Dulac: Mike Tomlin is not more powerful than the owner. Never was, never will be.
Guest: Is there a WR that we might draft that will be a problem and traded within 3 years?
Gerry Dulac: Sure
Guest: Long time reader, first time responder. I like Michigan's Grant with 21st pick but not sure he will be available. After Grant, Harmon or the guy from Ole Miss. My guess is that 2 or maybe all of these guys will be gone by 21st pick. Who would you pick if all 3 are gone? Please not QB.
Gerry Dulac: No QB, but I'd keep an eye on Harmon
QB?: what would be the backup plan at QB if Rodgers signs elsewhere/retires?
Gerry Dulac: Sign a veteran QB to be Rudolph's backup
cal from nh: what would a trade package for any established qb look like? 71 first rounders for mahomes? what would Kyler Murray package be?
Gerry Dulac: There won't be anything like that forthcoming.
QB?: Even after acquiring Metcalf this offseason… is Egbuka in play at Pk 21 if available?
Gerry Dulac: I doubt it, but I can tell you I really like him as a perfect fit for the Steelers and a perfect complement for Metcalf when Pickens is gone
Matt Lohr QB1: Gerry, love the chats!! What are you hearing about the Steelers confidence on DL after the signings? Can the current group set the set?
Gerry Dulac: No they can't, and let's trust the Steelers don't think they can.
QB?: Do you see us moving back in Rd 1 to pick up another day 2 pick? Hopefully a 2nd Rd.
Gerry Dulac: Always possible. But moving up to No. 21 doesn't require giving up a No. 2 pick, I don't think
Linebacker Lounge: Gerry, you seem happy with the Slay signing. Isn’t it time for a younger starter on a 3/4 year deal? Thought they should have went that route in FA. What say you?
Gerry Dulac: Hey LL, happy is a strong word, but I don't have a problem with it at all. One year
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Anyone who knows anything about the Steelers know DL has to be a priority. Anyone who knows pro football knows nothing matters without a franchise QB.Is there a QB not named Cam Ward you would roll the dice on in the 1st round?
Gerry Dulac: Nope
QB?: Is Kyler Murray a dark horse trade candidate if Pittsburgh misses on Rodgers?
Gerry Dulac: That would be an even worse courtship
Ball Knower: Gerry, what is the % chance Steelers trade down for additional picks based on Omar Khans comments yesterday? If they did, would that impact what position we selected?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think any of his comments yesterday had anything to do with acquiring additional picks. They were more about the possibility of having additional comp picks that would allow them some maneuverability.
Matt Lohr QB1: Gerry, do you agree that unless the Steelers would get a 1st (unlikely) or a 2nd rounder plus other picks there no reason to trade Pickens because they would probably get a 3rd comp pick? Or is his potential distraction fuel to trade him now for a 3rd?
Gerry Dulac: Pickens is one of those players who would command something good in a trade. Need I remind you the Steelers got a No. 2 for Chase Claypool??
cal from nh: could they trade high smith for a second? then bring in a Mathew Judson type player and let herbig start? He had a great year when watt was hurt, but maybe a little overpaid, very good backup, and need a second. then draft dart and second round dl?
Gerry Dulac: Don't see it playing out that way at all at any point
Bruce: Tomlin has seemed almost to exclude Milroe on purpose when listing young QB's in the draft but throwing out Howard, Leonard, Ewers when listing young QB talent. Is this a smokescreen or are they really out on him? I don't think he's going to be Jalen Hurts day 1 for 2025 but as far as mid round QB prospects go, he has a ton to work with.
Gerry Dulac: He mentioned those players -- not by name but by school -- because he was merely listing the three most recent pro days he and Okar Khan attended last week. That's all
574 Fan: If you were a betting man, who would be your pick between Trice and Slay to play the most snaps at cb2 next year?
Gerry Dulac: That's an easy bet. Barring injury, it ain't Trice
Rudy: Whatever happened to the "Steeler Way"? We had the most talented team in the NFL 2018-2019 and did nothing with it. Tomlin has no coaching tree and I have been a fan until the last few years when his stuborness to change has let both the O and the D pass him by. Rocky once told me that players would work on a handshake with the Chief. Dan was pretty much the same. Question, can we get back to the "Steeler Way" or will it be impossible under Art and Coach T?
Gerry Dulac: That's what happens when you don't have the KiIller B's, Pouncey, DeCastro, a younger Cam Heyward
Linebacker Lounge: Do you foresee an open competition for ILB next to PQ? Wilson and Holcomb?
Gerry Dulac: I think they will use them the same way they used Wilson and Elandon Roberts last year.
Linebacker Lounge: Have you picked up a nugget yet at The Breakers?
Gerry Dulac: Chick fil A was closed Sunday
Outside the Box: Hey again, Gerry…what are the chances in your mind that the Steelers move George Pickens before or during the draft?
Gerry Dulac: Not at all....then
574 Fan: Assuming the team enters the season with the wr room as it is now, who would you pick to have the most snaps in the slot next year between R Wilson and Austin?
Gerry Dulac: Probably Austin, but too early to tell
Greenwood: Gerry, If Mason was given the starting QB job and keeps it all season, do you believe he has what it takes to lead the team to a Super Bowl?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think the Steelers team has what it takes to get to a Super Bowl, regardless of the QB
Wayward: Gerry, As you see the dl that may be available at 21, Grant, Nolen or Harmon, who would be your preference and why?
Gerry Dulac: Harmon. Best fit
574 Fan: I haven’t paid any attention to the LIV guys this year. Would you expect any of them to contend at Augusta or would your clear favorites be Rory and Scottie?
Gerry Dulac: DeChambeau
AK: The only reason I could see not taking a DL in the first is if all the first round grade defensive linemen are gone by the time the Steelers draft. Agree?
Gerry Dulac: Yes. They won't reach.
Hi Gerry -: Based on his behavior and contract expectations, I find it hard to believe that someone would give up a second. Would you let him hold in/out and take the compensatory pick next year, or clear the decks of his personality and take a mid-to-high 3rd this year? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: You are underestimating the desperate nature of today's NFL GMs
Fox in the Snow: Do you believe that MT's national profile has diminished over the past five years in light of noncompetitive playoff game losses and whiffs on OC and QBs?
Gerry Dulac: Haven't seen evidence of it
Bruce: What % chance do you give Omar trading back in the first to pick up another day 2 pick? Or even trading out of it to get a small haul? Seems like this year would be the year to do that.
Gerry Dulac: Don't think you get a No. 2 or a "small haul" by moving up to No. 21
Hi Gerry -: I'm not sure I can believe I'm saying this out loud, so please don't tell anyone. However, would signing Rogers force the Steelers to alter their anemic offensive schemes and risk tolerance, and try to score more points through the air?
Gerry Dulac: They are always interested in scoring more points, but I will use this question to point up once again that the Steelers averaged nearly 29 points a game in the first seven games when Russell Wilson took over.
Hi Gerry -: If KC said they would give you a second for Pickens if you added our LG to the trade, since they need interior help, and he's in the last year of his contract, would you do it? What else would you want, a 4th?
Gerry Dulac: So you're suggesting trading Pickens and Seumalo for a second-round pick and seeking something else in return, like a fourth? OK, I'm listening....
Retire21: Will Rory finally get his Green Jacket next week?
Gerry Dulac: Let's hope
James K in Jax: So, it's seemingly come down to Steelers vs Vikes vs retirement for Rodgers. Doesn't the video of him throwing to Metcalf seal the deal with the Steelers? 2 high end receivers, decent tight ends plus last year's injured UM receiver would seemingly be desirable to Rodgers as an offense. If he wanted to retire, none of this throwing would be going on and Minnesota isn't showing him enough love. So it's the Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: The wind appears to be blowing in that direction
Ivan: Good morning, Gerry. We're living in a post-Ben era, just like we once did in the post-Terry Bradshaw days. If Aaron Rodgers doesn't come, do you think Mason Rudolph could give us a Neil O'Donnell-type performance at QB? I'd take that!
Gerry Dulac: I think that's a very good comparison!!
Josh: If you had to chose, Rodgers will be a steeler or not?
Gerry Dulac: I'm guessing he will be, but I'm not choosing
QB?: Other than QB, are there any more Free agents signings you see the Steelers making?
Gerry Dulac: Not really
Josh: Was Mark Kaboly sleeping?
Gerry Dulac: I think he was in between growls
Jim Bow Dean: I saw some speculation that Rodgers is waiting to announce he’s joining the Steelers on the Pat McAfee show that is in Pittsburgh on Wednesday. Would Dan Rooney would have ever tolerated that? I know it’s a different world but that seems ridiculous.
Gerry Dulac: You chose the right word -- ridiculous
Matt Lohr QB1: Gerry, who is the pole position for punting duties?
Gerry Dulac: It's a one-horse race -- CJ
Matt Lohr QB1: The Steelers will take a RB in first 3 rounds? Fact or fiction?
Gerry Dulac: Could be a fact
Hi Gerry -: How can anyone have confidence in this staff developing a young QB? They have made a mess of it at every turn. I can't wait to see Kenny light up the Steelers when they play the Browns; I'd bet a round at Pebble Beach he wins at least one of the two games on his play.
Gerry Dulac: I think you better reconsider because that a round at Pebble ain't cheap
Ron: Some sports commentators are saying the Steelers are almost writing this year off because of all their comp picks for next year & the QB situation they are in,
Gerry Dulac: They never write off any year.
Hi Gerry -: When in the offseason, will acquiring free agents not count against their comp picks for next season? There are a few bell cow backs still available, if needed.
Gerry Dulac: They will draft a RB, not sign another
Guest: We're entering year 4 of the Steelers rebuild and the play and coaching have gotten worse each year. How many more years until some significant changes happen?
Gerry Dulac: Wow, and they made the postseason in three of those four years. Imagine what a rebuild will do...!
Pittfan: Do you think Mike wants Aaron here to win a Superbowl or keep his non-losing streak going?
Gerry Dulac: To win a playoff game
John from Tampa: I'm playing Fox Chapel in May. Any tips? Also, masters pick?
Gerry Dulac: Yeah...enjoy it. It's a gem
Hi Gerry -: Does Rooney care that most of the fan base has turned on Tomlin and finds his coach's speak nothing more than a nuisance?
Gerry Dulac: I'm guessing not, though
Shawn S: Why is everyone worried about Pickens' attitude didn't Chad "Ochocinco" Johnson get him squared away? He guaranteed there won't be any problems with him.
Gerry Dulac: That's his mentor??
Pittfan: If the Steelers plan to kick Benton out to 5 gap, the big dancing bear of a nose tackle from Ohio State seems like a good choice. I read he's a 3 down player. I don't think he'll get out of the 2nd round.
Gerry Dulac: Agreed
Hi Gerry -: Why do people consider Tomlin a great coach when current and former players routinely ridicule his offensive and defensive schemes? Is it just the national media living in the past? When was the last time the Steelers physically pounded another team or outcoached them with their game plan? I struggle to recall any meaningful games where this happened in the previous three to four seasons.
Gerry Dulac: Because they believe he gets the most out of a roster than doesn't have a great amount of talent.
SteelGotIt: Gerry, respectfully WTH is Art2 trying to do right now??? No deadline, come as you will, we will wait for you, etc. for Rodgers and NO SENSE OF URGENCY. They clearly want him to be their QB, but if this is how he is treating them and running the team before even being signed, imagine what'll be like after he is signed and in the actual locker room. This is a mess, a travesty, and a disgrace to the Steelers legacy and makes us look like a desperate team. The Steelers should be desperate for Super Bowl #7, NOT a 41year old Pre-Madonna drama QUEEN (not king) who isn't even on the back nine, or Hole 18... HE'S ALREADY IN THE CLUBHOUSE SIGNING HIS CARD. MESS, MESS, MESS.
Gerry Dulac: Been waiting to say this all morning.... Pay the man!
AK: Rodgers was cut fans, he does not affect comp picks!!!
Gerry Dulac: Correct
Hi Gerry -: From a long-term perspective, if you could trade the LG and replace him with the #1 pick from last season, trade back in the first round and acquire a good RT, and then utilize the depth to add multiple pieces to the defensive line, would we be better off? Isaac is not getting another contract here.
Gerry Dulac: I'll tell him
SteelGotIt: Should I buy into the theory that the Steelers are stockpiling comp. picks so they can trade up and draft a QB in next years draft which is going to be held in... *checks notes*... Pittsburgh?
Gerry Dulac: This guy is 2 for 2
Steve in Canton: If DL Kenneth Grant is there at #21, do you run the draft card up to Big Roger?
Gerry Dulac: It's possible.
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, the owners meetings are ramping up. Gotta go. Thanx for the questions





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.