T.J. Watt hasn’t been the destroyer of worlds the Steelers have been accustomed to seeing over the past five seasons. While his 7½ sacks are a solid pace through 11 games — and has him on track to finish with 11½ sacks — he ranks 13th in the NFL, tied with the Jaguars’ Travon Walker and the Lions’ Aidan Hutchinson, the latter of whom has played just five games.
Still, if Watt were to finish 11½ sacks, it would be the fifth time he’s reached or exceeded that mark in his career.
However, if the Steelers want to be an elite defense and team, having their highest-paid player making more big plays in key moments could go a long way.
Against the Browns this past Thursday, Watt had just two pressures with no sacks or quarterback hits on Jameis Winston. But a review of the tape shows that isn’t because Watt was being dominated by an offensive tackle or unable to win his one-on-ones; it was because the Browns made a concerted effort to double-, triple- and even quadruple-team Watt throughout the game.
During the second quarter, the Browns used heavier packages with an extra offensive lineman and a tight end on Watt’s side to make it harder for him to get pressure.
There were four players to the right of the center with their hand in the dirt, and Watt ended up getting sandwiched between two of them on a 15-yard completion when Jerry Jeudy used his outside hand to push off of Joey Porter Jr.’s lower facemask to create separation for a big first down.
Read More
Watt’s lack of total pressures has also been a trend for the past three games, as he registered just two pressures against the Commanders and three pressures and a sack against the Ravens just four days before the Steelers’ 24-19 loss to the Browns.
It also isn’t a new challenge for the Steelers, as they’ve game planned around teams adjusting their protection toward Watt. After the Steelers’ 26-18 victory over the Giants on Oct. 28, we detailed in a film study how simply flipping Watt from the left side of the defense — his normal position — to the right side for merely four plays confused the Giants’ offensive protection.
That confusion allowed for a one-on-one opportunity for Watt on a key red-zone possession late in the fourth quarter, when he sacked Daniel Jones, stripped him of the football and recovered the fumble all in one play. Coaches from Mike Tomlin to defensive coordinator Teryl Austin, outside linebacker coach Denzel Martin and defensive line coach Karl Dunbar all commented the following week about how that was part of the plan to help Watt get more playmaking opportunities.
But since then, Watt has only played one snap on the right side of the defense and consistently has lined up in his normal spot on the left.
While that is the side Watt is most familiar with as an edge rusher, it’s also allowed teams to focus their full attention to all but guarantee he won’t get to the quarterback. Later in the second quarter, the Browns lined up the tight end on Watt’s side of the field, and he became the first of four players to get their hands on Watt during the play, as Winston found Elijah Moore for a 6-yard gain.
Part of the issue could be that Watt hasn’t consistently been partnered with the Steelers’ full depth chart of outside linebackers. Alex Highsmith has missed five games this season, while Nick Herbig has missed four. The three of them have only played together in three games — which all came in the Steelers’ first three games of the season.
Tomlin addressed that in his Tuesday press conference.
“For a large, early portion of the season, we were without Alex and Herbig,” Tomlin noted. “Obviously, when you’re minus guys like that, people can focus their energies on T.J. and things of that nature, but also just the nature in which people play us — particularly in one-dimensional passing moments — they’re aware of our reputation and the reputation of individuals of our group.”
Highsmith’s last game that he played from start to finish was the Steelers’ game against the Giants. So injuries could play a role in whether Watt can flip sides.
“It’s probably a little bit of both,” Tomlin answered when asked if Watt’s lack of side switching was more about personnel or matchups. “We were working with a deficit at the Giants game in terms of our edge people. As we get everybody back, we’re more inclined to play from their home spots.”
When asked if the Steelers preferred for Watt and their edge rushers to be in their “home spots” or flip around the formation, Tomlin indicated it was more about matchups.
Another factor to consider when it comes to Watt’s lack of production is the extracurricular adversity he regularly deals with from opponents who play outside the rules. Watt has only drawn two holding penalties despite several moments when it appears he earns what should be a penalty flag — like a missed safety call against the Commanders when Watt was thrown down by his jersey in the end zone during a fourth-quarter play.
But it’s not just holding that Watt must power through, as offensive linemen have resorted to other methods to stop the 2021 NFL Defensive Player of the Year from beating them at the point of attack. Take this second-quarter play for example, when Watt clearly had established leverage against his man, right tackle Jack Conklin.
Conklin was quickly losing ground, and Watt was about to disengage from Conklin and go for a sack. But Conklin decided to counter Watt by simply slapping him across his helmet, causing Watt to lose his balance and not be able to chase after and sack Winston. That’s a move that should’ve drawn an illegal use of hands to the face penalty but didn’t despite an NFL official having a clear line of sight on the play.
DeShon Elliott ended up making the play not matter by forcing a fumble later, but this play was another example of how Watt regularly deals with plays when offensive linemen should be flagged for breaking the rules to stop him — and how the NFL hasn’t done much to combat that.
While that won’t change just because Watt flips sides for a few plays here and there, the Steelers could still force offensive linemen to think more by moving him around.
But it should also be noted that moving Watt around formations at random isn’t something that should be done without specific matchups and plans in mind. Even when Watt is the focal point of an offense’s protection plan and limited in his pass-rush chances, he’s still a force against the run.
Take this run in the third quarter by Nick Chubb, when Watt shed through a double-team to win the edge and tackle Chubb for a loss. Watt does a good job winning leverage with his inside shoulder while keeping his outside hand free to make the play. It’s a factor in his game that’s become routine.
That ability is an asset to the Steelers defense and something they key their off-ball linebackers like Patrick Queen on so he can make plays behind Watt should it come his way.
Watt’s 17 run stuffs this season are second most on the team, only behind Cam Heyward’s 25. But maybe that’s a sign that other defensive linemen must get involved in the playmaking when Watt does draw the attention.
Watt’s 7½ sacks lead the team, followed by Heyward with five. But despite missing nine combined games between them, Herbig is next on the Steelers with 3½ sacks and Highsmith is right behind him with three.
Behind them, Larry Ogunjobi only has 1½ sacks, and Keeanu Benton has yet to register a sack, which is something the Steelers must see improve when teams are spending so much effort to stop Watt.
If you look back at the plays we showed above where Watt was double- and quadruple-teamed, both instances show the Steelers using a stunt-twist combination move between him and the defensive tackle on his side. That’s a pass-rush concept when the outside rusher pushes his rush more to the inside gap so the inside rusher can twist behind and get a clear look at the quarterback.
On both plays, Watt drew multiple blockers, while Ogunjobi and Benton were unable to register pressure against Winston. On a fourth-quarter play, that same opportunity was drawn up and Ogunjobi did pressure Winston — but he couldn’t finish the play, as Winston outran him to complete a downfield pass.
While the Steelers could move Watt around more to help with his production, it’s a complicated puzzle that Tomlin, Austin, Martin and Dunbar will need to rework week to week against each opponent.
The Steelers could increase their attempts to confuse offensive lines with Watt’s location in the defense, but that also may hinge on whether Highsmith, Herbig and newly added Preston Smith can regularly stay healthy for the rotation. And whether that happens, the Steelers’ other pass rushers must also improve their production.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.